The Village Shoemakers (1923) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A Finnish Regional Comedy
FerdinandVonGalitzien17 June 2011
Esko and Jaana are two children who often visit an elderly bachelor and former soldier who lives in their small village. The old corporal becomes very fond of both children and writes in his will that whoever marries first will inherit 500 riks from him. Years pass and Esko grows up to become a shoemaker like his father, Herr Topias. Frau Jaana, now a fraulein, has been Topias' foster child since her mother died and her father went off to sea; Esko's mother, Frau Martta, a temperamental and strong fraulein, decides to marry Esko off before Jaana so he will inherit the 500 riks. Frau Martta sends Esko outside the village to look for a bride, an adventure that will prove most eventful.

"Nummisuutarit" ( The Village Shoemakers ) was directed by Herr Erkki Karu after his "Koskenlaskijan Morsian" ( The Logroller's Bride ) (1923) and was just as successful as the first film both in Finland and in neighboring countries. It was based on a very popular Finnish play by Herr Alesksis Kivi and, since its premiere in the 19th century, it gets staged every year.

If "Koskenlaskijan Morsian" was a powerful melodrama, "Nummisuutarit" was a completely different film, namely, a Finnish regional comedy that proves the ability of Herr Karu to adapt easily to any film genre. This is a Finnish road movie with a simple minded hero searching for a bride and a big fortune. The film is full of local color and amusing Finnish characters and customs.

The peculiar Finnish sense of humour and its idiosyncrasies are sometimes hard to comprehend if you're a German aristocrat but some subjects transcend nationality; namely the ironic look at religion, matriarchy and ambition. Esko, a clumsy, innocent youngster is the type of character to be found in classical stories from all over the world.

The early virtuosity showed by Herr Karu in "Koskenlaskijan Morsian" can be seen too in "Nummisuutarit" but this time in an even more elaborate way technically and demonstrates Herr Karu's mastery of the camera and special effects. There are clever double exposures and inventive camera-work in the scene of Esko's drunkenness and the story goes back and forth in time to show what might happen if different courses of action are followed. This is not a conventional comedy but Herr Karu shows a command of narrative devices and rhythm common in classic comedy.

And now, if you'll allow me, I must temporarily take my leave because this German Count must continue his quest for bachelorhood.

Herr Graf Ferdinand Von Galitzien http://ferdinandvongalitzien.blogspot.com
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best adaption of a classic Aleksis Kivi -play
MadFish29 March 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The first and definitely the most successful adaption of Aleksis Kivi's famous play can be counted as the brightest star among Finnish silent film.

"Nummisuutarit" is a funny but tough story about the traditional Finnish (hu)man nature that needs no further explaining. Esko's character lights up all that one needs to know about the culture of its time.

How beautiful is the ending when Esko says "I'll never marry" and walks away to sit in his house with his pet piggy. In his early works Erkki Karu had really the concept of "sarcasm" in his hands!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Aleksi's Kivi's Nummisuutarit seen as a movie for the first time
Petey-1010 October 2011
Esko goes to marry the fair Kreeta, but it all ends to a huge disappointment, since she is getting married to somebody else.This leads to all kinds of funny situations, like Esko drinking booze for the first time.Nummisuutarit (1923) is directed by Erkki Karu.Today we celebrate Aleksis Kivi's day.He wrote this excellent play in 1864.Three movie versions have been made of it and this silent film, which I just saw on a VHS, is the first one.And it's a very good one.Some of the credit you have to give to Axel Slangus, who plays Esko.And the rest of the cast are also the right people for their parts.Alarik Korhonen portrays the father Topias.Kirsti Suonio is the mother Martta.Brother Iivari is played by Kirsti's actual son Antero Suonio.Aku Käyhkö plays Mikko Vilkastus.Heidi Korhonen is Jaana and Juho Puls her father Niko.Jaakko Korhonen plays her love interest Kristo.Adolf Lindfors plays Sepeteus.Martti Tuukka is Antres.Märta Hansson plays Kreeta.Behind the music are some true masterminds.I'm talking about Jean Sibelius, Selim Palmgren, Toivo Kuula and Oskar Merikanto.There's some great photography in this movie.Take the scene where Esko is drunk and the camera keeps spinning.And you sure feel nostalgic watching that old Finland.All movie versions have been good adaptations and Kivi would have been proud of them.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed