Man braucht kein Geld (1931) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Delightful COMEDY about how a high finance bluff saves a job, a bank, a town and a love!
larry41onEbay21 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
No Money Needed in German: "Man braucht kein Geld" is a 1932 German comedy film directed by Carl Boese and starring Heinz Rühmann, Hans Moser and featuring a very young and pretty Hedy Lamarr. It premiered on 5 February 1932. It was based on a play by Ferdinand Alternkirch and was shot during November 1931. A virtually bankrupt businessman in a small town manages to convince people that his newly arrived cousin, who is equally impoverished, is an American millionaire.

A French remake "Pas besoin d'argent" and an Italian remake "Non c'è bisogno di denaro" were made in 1933. Boese himself remade the story in 1953 under the title The Uncle from America.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
early Hedy
cynthiahost5 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I would have to say that this film produced in early 32 or late in 31.It is pure Wiemar.Instead of having any Nazi propaganda, it has actually has an anti depression message.This was design German audience to be inspired by it.It has an early appearance by Hedy Lamarr,Who plays the Kathe.Your corpcatting classic film distributors hope that this film never turns up.Why? cause she worked with actors ,who would work under the third Reich eventually, my guess is that she stayed mad with them after the war too.These mainstream distributors and broadcaster of classic films are protecting the stars anti Nazi reputation.They fear that the political correct will protest against showing her Hollywood films,as the excuse to horde their money when it comes to broadcasting and distributing classic films. They are greedy.Some might be Jewish too and don't want to face their past against them or any body else to face their past for them,which is stupid.Past denial is dumb The plot, The Brandt family, Frau Brandt,the mother, Herman Brandt, the father and older daughter Kathe.They all lost their money on their oil leases.The bank Heinz ,works in , has no more clients.He and the bank president Binder hear about their clients rich uncle coming to visit from Chicago.They stick on the chance if they can get him to invest in their bank then more people will invest in the bank too.The Brandts feel that they can borrow money from their uncle Then once he comes they find out that broke too.So Heinz comes up with an idea to use him as a front to get investors to put money back into his bosses bank.So there by the bank can prosper and the family can have their oil lease back and prosper too.Kurt Gerron is one of the tragic figure of acting history.He made a mistake in turning down a Hollywood job.But later on , in his desperation, he even beg Billy Wilder for a rescue and turn him down.He ended up by murder by the Nazi's .He plays Binder.Heinz portrays Heinz Schmidt the bank worker.Stalwart character German actress,who always grins ,Ida Wust plays the mother .Hans Junkermann plays Herman the father.Hedy plays the daughter.Every time she shows up in a scene she upstages everybody because of her beautiful face and good acting skills.She throws Heinz Ruhmann off too.It all of a sudden start to become her vehicle instead.Well , Hans Moser plays the uncle from Chicago Thomas .Also shows up in this feature is another familiar faces of character acting, Albert Florath as the hotel owner and Paul Henckels as the mayor.A good cast.The uncle stars to resent being uses and he attempts to leave but Heinz always stops him.The family gets their leases back and prosper ,the modern convenient that they get,at the time,some of them are still not out of date, like the electric door.Hans Mosers character is timid,like he was in real life. He decides to give in and stay.Everyone thinks he still wealthy .you know it was way before Hitler cause even the American flag is in the film. Excellent digital print available at Germanwarfilms.com 02/05/12
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Here's a gift for those who care to unwrap it, a Frank Capra like comedy made in Germany in 1931.
Larry41OnEbay-225 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Man braucht kein Geld (1931) Translated to "No Money Needed." Our film starts at a bank in the heart of the depression when the bank manager tells the teller (there are only the two of them left) they need a good idea to save their jobs and the community. The teller, he's busy opening the banks' safe, not to get any money but to get the only thing stored there, his lunch. The teller comes up with an idea! A once rich family in town with a beautiful daughter (Hedy Lamarr) is expecting a rich relative coming from America and if they can get him to invest in the bank, oil fields, town, etc.... it might start some hope in the destitute town. So a big welcome is planned by the family at the train station to greet their millionaire American Uncle. SPOILERS: But when he arrives, it turns out he spent everything he had to get to them and even left the U. S. owing money! Our teller thinks fast and comes up with a plan, if they act like the uncle is rich someone else might follow his lead. So the teller suggest they borrow a bunch of empty suitcases and check Uncle into the best suite at the biggest hotel. And here's the magic, they tip the bell hop using a $10 gold piece! (Yes it was all the money he had.) And the word gets out that if they have that kind of money to throw around... so everbody wants to sell Uncle something, but he's to busy to see anyone (and he's being kept from leaving. He's against the ruse.) Well not only do things start to turn around for the town, it's as if a title wave of cash floods back into the bank, into investments, into businesses, etc. The teller even suggest that he marry Lamarr's character just so it can look like he's family! Things go great for a while, but you know the truth has to catch up with them somehow.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed