Gli uomini, che mascalzoni... (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
An italian classic
janus-1230 July 1999
In this movie we can find the best of italian movie-makers of 30's (the age of "telefoni bianchi", the "white phones", in relation to comedies in which Wh.-Ph. were often used): Camerini as director, Vittorio De Sica, who worked as actor but years after will be one of the most relevant directors in the world, Bixio & Cherubini who wrote one classic song of italian music "Parlami d'amore Mariù" ("Mary, speak about love to me"). The plot is easy, the scenario is in an old Milan, but... seeing this movie means going back in years in which... love was the most important thing.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Pleasant Early Camerini-De Sica Collaboration
boblipton19 January 2023
Every morning, Lia Franca's father wakes her with "Get up sleepyhead! Time to go to work." Today is different. Along comes Vittorio De Sica on his bicycle, holding onto the bus he takes. Her coworkers at the perfume shop tell her he's not what she should be looking for. So when he comes by driving a big car, she accepts a ride home in his big auto, which turns into an excursion to the Lakes. There he abandons her, because his employers see their chauffeur out with the car which he told them needs repaired, and he has to drive them home, and he gets into an accident on the way back and....

De Sica's first of nine movies for director Mario Camerini is a slight one, a romance of working-class people meant to show off the beauty of the countryside around Milan and the gaudy excitement of the 13th Milan Fair as much as the stars. They give good performances, touchy and uncertain, he thinking she's a gold digger but he wants her anyway, she thinking he's a louse, but wanting him. Will they ever get over their injured self regard and get together?

Well, it's inevitable they will, of course, in the movies, but there are enough obstacles thrown in their way, and bumper cars too!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Appealing early sound De Sica rom com.
Mozjoukine10 April 2011
Nice, small scale romantic comedy, already offering an appealing star couple and many of the features of later Italian Realism.

Dismissed as "Signor Biciclette" by the perfume shop girls, cloth cap mechanic Vittorio borrows the car he's repairing at the garage and collects the appealing Lia Franca for a run, ending at the riverside cafe, where the old couple have put a coin in the proto juke boy, which plays "Love's last Word Is Spoken," for Vittorio and Lia to dance but their idyllic afternoon is disturbed by the boss' wife who has spotted the car and sees this as a lift home, stranding Lia.

Calamities and misunderstanding accumulate, with the leads finally working at a Milanese Industrial Fair. This generates a rather winning ending to this advanced, agreeable, light weight.

The film more than stands comparison with contemporary product (eg. the films of René Clair,) shooting material in real locations, which would have been done in a studio in Hollywood or Paris, and foregrounding working class characters, anticipating the neo realist films. There's even an unemployment sub-plot.

De Sica is billed under Franca, the lead of RESURRECTIO, the first Italian sound film. It's probably his first talkie and he's perfectly relaxed and natural. Designer Medin will accompany him on his career.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Miracle (of love) in Milan
ItalianGerry24 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This delightful romantic comedy, had it been made in America during this same period might have featured Jimmy Stewart and Jean Arthur and might have been directed by Gregory La Cava.

It gives us a Vittorio De Sica as a chauffeur, Bruno, who passes himself off as a man of importance by offering Mariuccia (Lia Franca) a ride in the car which he passes off as his own. She is the daughter of taxi driver Cesare Zoppetti. From the city of Milan they go off to the country for, spending some time at an inn, enjoying each other's company. Bruno romances her with the song "Parlami d'amore, Mariù" or "Talk Love to Me, Mariuccia" by Cesare A. Bixio, which made the Italian hit parade of the time.

The idyll is disrupted when Bruno is forced by his employer's wife to take her back to the city, getting into a car accident on the way, and poor Mariuccia gets stuck at the inn, feeling that she has been ditched and being saddled with the bill for refreshments and having to spend the night there.

The hurt young lady will have nothing to do with Bruno after this. Ultimately he finds her working at the fair in Milan (in a wonderful sequence shot at the Festa Campionaria di Milano) and in the 64 minutes it takes for the film to run its course of love-misunderstanding-separation-reuniting, all turns out happily with Mariuccia's father blessing his daughter and his son-in-law-to-be.

There isn't much of a plot here or a message or a moral, but who needs those? Especially when you have an amiable, ingratiating and stylish piece of entertainment like this at the hands of one of Italy's finest directors of this period, Mario Camerini.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed