It Could Happen to You (1937) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Cast And Crew Try To Make An Important Movie
boblipton7 December 2018
Alan Baxter has just graduated from college and has the chance to buy the "Foreign-American Institute" from Walter Kingsford, teaching immigrants what they need for their citizenship papers. Owen Davis Jr. has just become lawyer. Andrea Leeds is the girl they both love, and with whom they split malted at the shop of Al Shean. He's Mr. Davis' father, but he looks on all three as his children. Baxter discovers that Shean has saved up $600 to outfit a law office for Davis. He goes to steal it and winds up killing Shean.

It's an ambitious production for Republic Pictures, from a script co-written by Nathaniel West. There's a long excursion, before Baxter is identified by the police as the killer, involving Walter Kingsford, forcing Baxter to blackmail his students to pay his fees lest he report them as foreigners, and using Nietzsche to justify it. The first shake-down is tried on Christian Rub, who has a very good scene.

Nietzsche was the boogey-man of philosophers in the early 20th century; because he wrote about the mob's willingness to accept any charlatan on a white horse and do terrible things. People who never bothered to read him assumed he approved; plus he spent time in a madhouse; worst of all, he was German. So people quoted snippets, thought they represented everything about his opinions, and despised what they believed he had written without having read it. No wonder he went mad.

In the end and despite considerable acting chops in the cast, the cheapness of the production leaves director Phil Rosen with little more than a simplistic fairy tale, with Kingsford as the ogre and a good mob scene at the end. You can see the ambition of everyone involved in this production, trying to make it something telling and inspirational. Unfortunately, at second feature length and budgeting, they couldn't afford to do more than produce a standard tale.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Another potential classic butchered for TV airing.
mark.waltz4 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
One day, I'd like to see the 71 minute release print of this above average Republic drama which cut out two reels for TV, including some of the most necessary footage for the film to make complete sense. Alan Baxter is on trial for the murder of his best friend's father, Al Shean, killed in a botch robbery. In spite of that, Shean's son (Owen Davis Jr.) Defends him, citing extenuating circumstances and the testimony of the jealous Astrid Allwyn which makes a date with whatever just sends is given to him most likely. It also doesn't help that public opinion against Baxter is strong.

This is a film dealing with xenophobia (not known by that name at the time, just considered a prejudice against all foreigners), culminating in a scene where an immigrant is threatened with deportation because he lost his papers even though he's been in the United States for years. Andrea Leeds, having won a claimed the same year as the tragic heroine of "Stage Door", is Davis's loyal girlfriend.

This is up there with the footage that I saw in the edited print with films like "Fury" and "Black Legion" documenting the dangers of the madness of the mob, and I found that definitely deserve to have them seen in its entirety. Many of the Republic films were edited for tv, but in a way that made sense. That isn't the case with this one. But I'll rate it to what I feel it deserves based on the importance of what I saw. Definitely one that I'll revisit again once I find the complete film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed