A Woman Is the Judge (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A reverse twist in a potentially cliched story.
mark.waltz22 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Secrets involving mother and child usually have the mother in trouble, but this one is quite the opposite. Frieda Inescort and Rochelle Hudson are quite good in this crime drama where Hudson is the defendant in a murder case, having been blackmailed by the man she killed (Arthur Loft), determined to keep her secret of why she committed murder. Judge Inescort has no idea of the ties that bind them, and her romantic friendship with the prosecuting attorney (Otto Kruger) makes a change when circumstances have her as Hudson's defense attorney after she must step down from judging the case.

A well written and acted B crime from Columbia, directed by Nick Grinde (who was behind the camera in many of their fun programmers), this is filmed on their best sets and has Inescort as glamorous as Kay Francis when not in her judge's robes. The best performance in this film comes from Mayo Methot as Hudson's best friend, tough but loveable, risking everything for her. Married to Humphrey Bogart at the time, she is top notch, making her sad fate truly tragic. Beryl Mercer as Inescort's housekeeper also deserves a shout out. Quite a gripping programmer and one of the top forgotten films of the greatest year in the motion picture industry.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Well Handled Melodrama
boblipton11 December 2023
Frieda Inescourt is a judge on her state's criminal court. She has a secret, though. Twenty years ago, she was married and had a little girl. Then she discovered her husband was a brook. He left and took the baby with her. Ever since then, she has had a cake for the little girl. It's a secret known only by her faithful maid, Beryl Mercer. Now she is presiding in a case of a major criminal, Arthur Loft. He knows the secret, because Miss Inescourt's husband was one of his gang then, and after his death, the daughter, Rochelle Hudson has continued to be. Loft provides Miss Hudson copies of the papers, and orders her to go to Miss Inescourt to blackmail her. Miss Hudson refuses; her mother is her one point of pride. She demands the originals, but Loft refuses. She goes to his apartment to get them, and Loft is dead,

It's a good, if melodramatic script by Karl Brown, competently directed by Nick Grinde. Grinde was one of the competent journeyman directors, who helmed one Oscar winner, How To Sleep and never quite made the grade to A pictures. Nonetheless, he handles the depressed philosophy of Mayo Methot as "A girl's gotta live" with appropriate despair, and gives Otto Kruger one of his rare nice-guy roles as a prosecuting attorney who yearns for Miss Inescourt.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed