Cheyenne Roundup (1943) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"I have a hunch I'm gonna be beautifully double-crossed!"
classicsoncall22 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Only in B Westerns and other genre films of the Thirties and Forties do you have such unlikely coincidences as a man traveling three hundred miles on horseback searching for his brother, and finding him wounded and dying in an abandoned cabin in the woods. What are the odds! Stuff like this happens all the time in flicks like this and I just shake my head.

And speaking of unlikely occurrences, here's another one. How may times have you seen this in old time Westerns? We see Buck Brandon revealing his identity switch to Ellen Randall (Jennifer Holt), as the henchmen of bad guy Blackie Dawson (Harry Woods) just so happen to be in the right place and the right time to overhear the conversation. What incredible timing!

But you know what? It doesn't really matter because I can watch this stuff all day. This oater has two of the more familiar cowboy names of the era - Johnny Mack Brown and Tex Ritter. Brown actually portrays twin brothers in the picture, each on opposite sides of the law when the story opens. One big question mark I had with Brown portraying Buck Brandon, brother of outlaw Gils Brandon engaged to Miss Randall, was how much like a jilted lover he seemed, even when Ellen wasn't around. Why would that be - he just met her!

Well don't watch this with a critical eye, just sit back and enjoy the picture, well interspersed with musical offerings by the Jimmy Wakely trio to liven things up. By the time we get to the finale, the good guys have things sorted out and Buck Brandon even gets the girl! But not until that final showdown resulting in a full scale bar room brawl at the Golden Nugget. I didn't think Blackie's bunch had so many bad guys!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Two Johnny Mack Browns
boblipton24 April 2020
Johnny Mack Brown comes out west to meet up with his identical twin brother, Johnny Mack Brown, only for them to find one of them is dying. So Brown goes undercover as himself with the gang who -- I almost wrote 'what' there -- shot him, breaks off his engagement with Jennifer Holt, and runs Tex Ritter to get the rascals out.

I hope that's as clear as mud. It's better than I've misdescribed it, and under Ray Taylor's direction, moves along at a good clip: just under an hour. Universal could turn them out with a bit of gloss, and this one has it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Has Johnny Mack Brown gone evil?!
planktonrules21 May 2022
This story is, at first, confusing. After all, you see that Gils and his friends are wicked crooks....and Gils is played by Johnny Mack Brown! Now this is crazy, as Brown ALWAYS played the hero. Well, here's how they get away with this. It seems that the evil Gils is just a twin...and his identical twin Buck is good and honorable! And, Buck pretends to be his brother in order to clean up the town of El Dorado and make it fit for settlers.

So is this any good? Yes. Like several of Brown's films he made for Universal, he's assisted by Tex Ritter and Fuzzy Knight and the film is enjoyable...albeit strange with the whole twin angle. Worth seeing...a decent B-western.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Review
tomwal13 February 2011
This western has it all .Top stars,production values,and plot.Johnny Mack Brown plays a dual role of twin brothers,one good and one bad, Gils and Buck Brandon.The plot opens with Gils being run out of town by Marshall Tex Ritter Gils vows that someday he will return to take care of Ritter. Later Gils and his gang,Roy Barcroft,Robert Barron and Harry Woods come across a ghost town,gold is discovered, and the three become rich. Gils sends for his girlfriend Jennifer Holt.Before they can marry,Gils sets out to fulfill his promise to kill Ritter.To reveal more of the plot would take away the suspense of watching this very good B western.Brown and Ritter handle the fights,riding and gun play in fine fashion,William Sickner lenses with a sharp eye for detail and Hans Salter provides a score that perfectly compliments the on screen action.Elmer Clifton directs the cast with a sure hand. Three big stars.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Two Johnny Macks
bkoganbing23 June 2020
In Cheyenne Roundup which is not in Cheyenne and there's no roundup Johnny Mack Brown plays a good and bad guy. Bad Johnny is killed in a shootout with Sherif Tex Ritter. Then his twin good Johnny joins Ritter playing his late brother in a scheme to capture the rest of the outlaw band led by Harry Woods and Roy Barcroft. The outlaws have taken over a former ghost town and made it boom under their control.

One of the dumber plots I've seen in a B western. Tex sings a couple of nice ballads and Jimmy Wakely contributes musically as well. Fuzzy Knight is there for comic relief.

For diehard western fans.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Okay Mix
dougdoepke2 August 2017
Okay oater-- lots of hard riding and gunplay, along with a final big brawl. But don't expect much scenery since the shoot never leaves greater LA. The plot's more complex than most, Brown getting to play two parts as identical twins. Seems good guy Brown (Buck) is helping clean up boomtown that bad guy Brown (Gils) has helped corrupt—so keep a scorecard to tell them apart. Meanwhile Ritter's ace Sheriff is brought in to help. And guess what—there's Fuzzy Knight for comic relief gargling out what may be the worst song in oater annals. Good thing Jimmy Wakely's Trio is on hand to get back my ears. No, no fan of these matinees follows them for logic. I mean catch all the shooting where no one aims and horses never go down no matter how big the fusillade. After all, we front-row kids would have stormed the screen over a dead horse. And I guess this now front-row geezer would still storm the screen, TV, that is. Anyhow, it's an okay time-passer without being anything special.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed