And to Think That I Saw It on Mulberry Street (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Mix of live action and animation of the Dr. Seuss story
llltdesq2 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
This is a George Pal Puppetoon adaptation of the Dr. Seuss story. Mild spoilers are ahead:

The short begins and ends with live action footage of a young boy heading off to school and then returning home The live action serves to frame animated footage. The contrasting black and white heightens the overall impact of the fantastic Technicolor animation in between.

The boy first starts off by relating that all he sees on Mulberry Street is one cart drawn by a horse, which is soon converted into various other sights by his very vivid imagination. His imaginings are brought to life by the wonderful stop-motion animation created by Pal's studio.

The short is visually gorgeous and the transformations of a simple cart and horse into more and more unusual flights of fancy are a joy to see. Ultimately, one lonely cart and horse turns into a parade of sights and sounds and when the live action returns, the boy is running home excited by what his imagination has made of the rather drab and mundane sight he actually saw. The ending is bittersweet, so I'll leave that untold here.

This short is included as an extra on a recent Blu-Ray release of The Puppetoon Movie done by a specialty production company as a limited release of 3000 copies. The Blu-Ray itself has been beautifully done and is well worth getting. This short, along with quite a few others, is also well worth the time and effort to see. Recommended.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
And To Think That I Saw It On Mulberry Street
oongawa8 October 2007
I am 55 years old this month and the only time I saw this partially animated short was on an old Motorola black and white television almost 50 years ago. So if this review seems to be amateurish and childish you would probably be correct because this is my first review ever and it is coming from the memory of me when I was a child. I can't even tell you if any of this feature is in color because our family did not have a color TV.

However if the test of time is any gauge on the 50 year memory imprint of a young mind I give this short the maximum rating possible. If my memory serves me correctly the portions where Marco the main character, is talking to his father and relating to the real world the feature is filmed with real props and actors. Only when Marco starts to embellish on his observations does it turn to animation.

I totally enjoyed this short as a child and haven't seen it since. I sure would like to though!
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Pal Deserves Better DVD Representation
Mencken5930 January 2005
Unfortunately, the only place this classic, Academy-Award-nominated short can be seen at all is that it is excerpted - in short snippets - in the "In Search of Dr. Seuss" video.

While Arnold Leibovit's excellent "The Puppetoon Movie" has many of Pal's greatest Puppetoon/"Madcap Models" shorts - and the extended version DVD has a dozen additional shorts(!) - the Dr. Seuss shorts are sadly lacking. I, and indeed many animation aficionados, would LOVE to eventually see "The Complete Puppetoons" in a DVD collection. (The auspices of a "complete" collection might be the only way to get many of the "Jasper" shorts out there as they tend to be controversial - though if Disney can present complete collections as part of their "Disney Treasures" and apologize for potentially offensive material with a little disclaimer from Leonard Maltin, I'm sure the same could be done on George Pal's behalf.)
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed