Great Freedom No. 7 (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Another fine Kautner film.
Dwolvesbane23 November 2008
In Great Freedom no. 7 we are once again faced with an excellent piece of film work by the mid-century German master, Helmut Kautner. The story, as is common with his films, focuses on a love triangle and also uses sailors and their transitory way of life as a complication to this triangular arrangement as he does in Under the Bridges. He also reprises the theme of musicianship which he uses for characters in most of his films, from the composers in In Those Days and Romance in a Minor Key.

As usual for Kautner, the film employs a more mobile and freewheeling camera. Zooms and pans are used to convey shifts in relationships, for example when Gisa is talking to her mother just before leaving the farm.

Of particular note in this film is the dream sequence experienced by Hannes. Through this sequence Kautner explores the possibilities of manipulating colors, pushing the boundaries of the new technology. His use of form in this sequence is also worthy of discussion. The slanting angles and semi-realistic sets that he uses, especially when Hannes and Willem are fighting on the ship, are reminiscent of the German Impressionist films of three decades before. This application of an earlier film style is particularly well suited to the content of those scenes, as German expressionism was an attempt to externalize onto the environment the internal attitudes of the characters its modes and tropes lend themselves quite well to hallucinations and dream sequences.

In this film Kautner once again presents a sort of timeless, a political Germany. Even though the film was produced under the grip of one of the most brutal regimes in history, and was a thorn in the side of Joseph Goebbels, there are no traces of the political climate of the day, let alone anything resembling propaganda. The characters exist in a Germany that is modern and recognizable, but is clearly not the Germany that the audience knows. This feature of Kautner's films during the war years seems to have been an attempt to remind people of their essential humanity, even among the horrors of war and the domination of a brutal government.
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A German film from 1944 that is no propaganda
frankde-jong30 July 2019
The two best known films of Helmut Kautner are situated in shipping circles. "Unter den Brucken" (1946) is about inland shipping, "Grosse Freiheit nr 7" (1944) is about sailors.

"Grosse Freiheit Nr 7" was made during the last phase of World War Two, and the Nazi propaganda was hoping for an heroic movie. They were utterly disappointed by the film, which was not shown in Germany until after the Second World War. To recoup some of the production costs the film was nonetheless exported to other countries.

What exactly did arouse the resentment of the Nazi's? I think it was the sphere of melancholy ans nostalgia that permeates the film. Instead of an heroic seaman the film is about a retired sailor who earns a living by singing in a nightclub in the red light district of Hamburg.

In the beginning of the film two former ship mates are visiting his club. At the outside of the club they see their old fellow as a mechanically moved mannequin pop. At the inside the memory's of times gone by immediately set the tone.

This relationship between the old pals is more important for the ambiance of the film than all the romantic complications that are to follow. Complications that are nevertheless responsible for a magnificent dream sequence where our main character is torn apart between his love for the sea and his love for a girl he has recenly met.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"The sea is my bride."
brogmiller16 April 2024
Although arguably not Helmut Kautner's greatest film it is probably his most popular and the one for which he will be best remembered whilst Hans Albers, despite a distinguished career, will forever be associated with Hannes the singing sailor.

The bawdy, boozy, brawling sequences in the Grosse Freiheit no 7 of the title are well choreographed but for this viewer at any rate the film's effectiveness lies in the intimate scenes where Kautner's gift with actors comes into play. The performances of Albers, Ilse Werner(also teamed to great effect in 'Munchhausen') Hans Soehnker and Hilde Hildebrand are exemplary whilst the director puts on his actor's hat as Karl and fellow screenwriter Richard Nicholas does a turn as an ancient mariner. One of the film's obvious highlights is the magnificent nightmare sequence splendidly edited by Annaliese Schoennenbeck.

Kautner managed to navigate the perilous waters of National Socialism and refused to allow his films to be infused with Nazi ideology which naturally brought him into conflict with Herr Goebbels. Originally endorsed by the Propoganda Ministry as a tribute to the Merchant Navy, the finished film was deemed to be immoral, unheroic, demoralising and subversive. As a result it achieved the distinction of being one of ten films banned by Goebbels in 1944. As for Albers, he cleverly distanced himself from Nazi propoganda and as with the equally popular Heinz Ruemann, the Hitler regime turned a blind eye to his partner being Jewish.

Although perhaps not equal to the sum of its parts, Kautner's film with its melancholic strain continues to cast its spell and bears the hallmarks of a master film-maker. Shot in glorious Agfacolor by Werner Krien its songs undoubtedly contributed to its success, to the extent that outside Northern Europe Herr Albers is renowned more as a chanteur than the fine actor he was. As a son of Hamburg his statue still stands in the Platz named after him and he was to get more mileage out of the Hamburg connection with 'On the Reeperbahn at half past Midnight' and 'Heart of St. Pauli' in the late 1950's when he was, alas, well beyond his prime.

Kautner went on to become a beacon of light in the commercial wasteland of post-war German cinema.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
poignant tale of Hamburg's Saint Pauli district
Lars-654 December 1999
In this poignant tale of Hamburg's Saint Pauli district, a former seaman, now a singer in a sailor's nightclub, opposes his girl's love for a dockworker. Directed by Helmut Kaeutner in 1943/44, this film enjoyed enormous postwar popularity in East and West Germany. Kaeutner makes a stunning use of the new Agfacolor material, and Hamburg never looked more mystical. The film was shot on location and Berlin, but after the air raids in both cities, completed in Prague. Goebbles didn't particularly like this film and didn't allow it to be shown in the Reich. Therefore, German audiences only got to see this movie after 1945. Hans Albers is brilliant, and for fans of him this movie is an absolute must. I personally must have seen this one 8 or 9 times already. The movie also features a couple of good songs, sung by Hans Albers. "La Paloma" is probably the most remembered tune of this film.
26 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
GOING AGAINST THE GRAIN ALL THE WAY
J. Steed13 February 1999
As always going against the grain Käutner made another film that was not appreciated by Goebbels; this one was allowed showing only outside Germany. Main reason: German sailors and women do not act as shown in the film.

From directing till script, from acting till (Agfa colour) photography this is a brilliant film, with everyone involved giving best of their talents. What we see is a compelling drama, well balanced, psychologically well conceived and at the same time a film that is great fun to watch over and over again. In this film there are only people and their lives who are not up to standard Nazi definition. There are also great songs, including the bitter "Beim ersten Mal tut's noch weh'", sung superbly by Hilde Hildebrandt.

There is one minor distraction: Käutner is beside the mark with the dream sequence, with which we could have done without. On the other hand, who cares: this film is made from the heart. With Romanze in Moll and Unter den Brücken this is the best of Helmut Käutner.
19 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Got the story more clear
cynthiahost8 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I had gotten the VHS version sometimes back. It was a good print but soft focus transfer. It was transfered from pal version probably brightness turned down to bring out the colors. I later bought the DVD version. It was more sharper and brightness turned up a bit. I had gotten the story wrong I had thought Gisa ,played by Ilsa Werner actress also a singer who had participated in early TV in Nazi Germany also known for her whistling, was Hans brother daughter making her Hans niece but I got it cleared. In this picture she's shows her acting skills. I'm surprises that Kautner did't have a singing scene in this movie for her but shes was totally dramatic. Because of her participation in Wunsckonzert, by force, she was suspended for 1 year from acting in Germallywood. The story, Hans brother, Jan, dies. He promises took look after his girl friend Gisa.He goes to where she works, with her mother, and offers her his benefaction. Bored and wanting to sees St Pauli she takes the offer. He is rather unhappy because he'd like to go back to the sea but he can't.He sings at his girl friends night club call ,the Hypodrome. The Girl friends ,played by Hildt Hildabrandt, the Mae West of German cinema. His ship friends played by Gustav Knuth and Gunther Luthers, come off from the ship they work at the Padua.Well later on as Gisa is buying bear and food for Hans when he comes back from work. A ship mechanic notices her ,played by Hans Sohnker, and becomes interested in her .She later works at a shop selling ties so he makes his introductions to her by buying a tie. Behind Hans back she decides to go out with Wilhelm. Later on Hans finds out and they almost have a fight. They end up confronting each other at the hippodrome and end up in a fist fight. Gisa leaves Hans and a suggestive sex before marriage, after math, is shown. In the U.S.A at the time because of the production code such scene would not been allowed in American films.Hans wants to marry her but later finds out what happens. He ends up going back to the sea to work on the Padua. The Agfa color cinema photography was great. Even though I had trouble understanding what they were talking about the acting was excellent. Why did they have Gustave Knuths hair shaved?He was still lean ,later on he'd put on a few pounds in other movies,like Sissie series, in which he played Romy's father.This would encourage a sequel or what looks like a sequel in the fifties. Recently in Febuary this was shown at a film series in Harvard college,I think, for the first time with American subtitles. This is when i discovered why i was so drawn to the filmmaker Helmut Kautner. He did 2 American films for Universal in the late deifies.One i saw on American Movie Channel ,befor it went down hill. June Allisons last film in which she played a lead,Stranger in my arms, which was not about ordinary people. Available at German war films dot com
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Great Boredom Nr. 7
Horst_In_Translation28 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Große Freiheit Nr. 7" (and there are so so many alternate titles in both English and German that I won't mention them) is a German movie from 1944, so this one will have its 75th anniversary soon. And if you read Germany in 1944, you will immediately think of Nazi Germany of course and yes this is where this film was made. But by then the war was (pretty much) lost for the Germans and this is certainly not a propaganda film anymore. It is a story of fiction written and directed by Helmut Käutner fairly early in his career and a while before he went on to become one of Germany's most successful filmmakers. I personally found that this film looked a lot newer than 1944 and this is probably due to the fact that it is in color, like many films during the Nazi reign, and due to the fact that even in the late 1960s there were still German movies in black-and-white. But this is really the only truly progressive aspect about No°7. The best thing about it is probably Hans Albers. I can understand somehow if people say he was too young for the role, but he still shows how talented he is and makes the character his own. Unfortunately, nothing else about this film is on par with one of Albers' career-defining performances. Of course, the role also fits him perfectly with his Hamburg background. Other than him, there is no reason to see this one. The script and plot is really forgettable, it lacks realism on many occasions, the supporting cast is not memorable either in terms of performances. But you have to say in their favor that the characters other than Albers' were also not written interestingly at all. For me, Albers alone cannot carry this film on his shoulders so that I would recommend it. He relies on quality efforts from other people in front of and behind the camera. And these just aren't there. The result is a movie that drags a lot during its overlong 110 minutes. I give it a thumbs-down. watch something else instead.
3 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed