Swooner Crooner (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Porky finally gets his day!
planktonrules27 January 2014
Although Porky Pig appeared in almost 200 shorts and films, "Swooner Crooner" marks the only occasion where the pig got nominated for an Academy Award...and it lost.

Porky is operating a weird egg production factory filled with hens. However, when a crooner chicken (meant to be a parody of Frank Sinatra) shows up and sings, the hens stop working and jeopardize the farm. Considering it's during WWII and Porky is helping feed America and the troops, it's imperative that he gets the hens back to work instead of swooning as Frankie sings. So, Porky advertises to get is own crooner--and tries out some who are meant to parody Al Jolson, Bing Crosby, Jimmy Durante and Cab Calloway. While the impersonations are clever, they aren't all that funny nor would many viewers recognize the singers. I do because I am an old movie freak! As for the ending, however, it's VERY funny as well as incredibly creepy! Of all the Oscar nominated animated shorts, this is probably the weakest that year. Worth seeing but I can understand why this one didn't win.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An Egg-cellent Classic Cartoon
ccthemovieman-131 May 2007
This wartime cartoon features Porky Pig as manager of the "Flockheed Eggcraft Factory." Yes, nobody loves plays-on-words more than the writers of these cartoons.

The hens clock in for their wartime assembly-line duties. The assembly is clever and funny, how they picture the eggs being dumped out of a bombardier, caught below with catcher's mitt, etc.

The caricature of Frank Sinatra had me laughing out loud. If you've seen pictures of Frank when he was really young and the girls were screaming over him, you saw a real skinny guy with a bow-tie. The artists here had fun with that, and portraying the different ways in which all the hens "swoon."

Later, we see other famous singers "audition" but no one makes the grade until "Bing" shows up....and the swooning starts all over again. The the two stars both sing and the egg production goes sky high!

I grew up a decade later but I can still appreciate this fantastic cartoon, which was part of the Looney Tunes Golden Collection Volume Three.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sooner or later, "Powerhouse" had to get mixed with the Rosie the Riveter culture.
lee_eisenberg17 April 2007
In the only Porky Pig cartoon to receive an Oscar nomination, filmdom's most famous swine owns a farm and has the hens lay eggs all day - to the tune of (what else?) Raymond Scott's "Powerhouse" - but the hens get distracted by a crooning rooster. But when Porky hires another rooster to woo the hens back, the whole ordeal really turns into a battle of wits.

An obvious aspect of "Swooner Crooner" is that it's truly a product of WWII, what with the clear allusion to Rosie the Riveter. But of course, they parody singers like Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra. Yeah, those guys may have been really popular in those days, but I just bet that most people in my generation believe that BC and FS deserved to get mocked as brutally as possible.

OK, so I don't know whether or not I can speak for every member of my generation. But I can say that this is a really funny cartoon. It got included in Leonard Maltin's "Bugs and Daffy: Wartime Cartoons".
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"When My Dreamboat Comes Home..."
slymusic15 March 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Directed by Frank Tashlin, "Swooner Crooner" is an excellent Warner Bros. cartoon that takes place at a chicken farm/factory. The proprietor is Porky Pig, but he's not really the star of the picture. All of his hens are defense workers doing their part for the war effort; they show up to work every morning with their badges & lunch pails and punch in their time cards. Their job is simple: to lay eggs while being transported on a conveyor belt. But when a debonair popular-singing chicken arrives, the "young ladies" all leave their posts in order to become entranced by this one-of-a-kind hypnotist ("It's Frankie!!!"). The hens' "absenteeism" stops the whole operation, and Porky panics...until another vocalizing chicken named Bing shows up.

My favorite moments from "Swooner Crooner" include the following. Aside from the excellent caricature of the Bing Crosby chicken (Hawaiian shirt, hat, pipe, & voice), there are several well-made caricatures of other chickens that Porky auditions before he meets Bing: Nelson Eddy (singing "Mommy's Little Baby Loves Shortening Bread"), Al Jolson (singing "September in the Rain"), Jimmy Durante (singing "Lullaby of Broadway"), and Cab Calloway (singing "Blues in the Night"). Frankie's emaciated body disappears behind the microphone stand as the hens all scream in ecstasy, and the popular standard "As Time Goes By" causes all the hens to happily faint. Upon hearing Bing's vocalizations, one hen lays such a gigantic mountain of eggs that her henhouse actually rises upward on top of the egg structure!

"Swooner Crooner" may not exactly be the quintessential Hollywood caricature cartoon, but no matter; the chicken caricatures are quite good, and the songs are memorable. This cartoon is on Disc 2 of the Looney Tunes Golden Collection Volume 3, and for an added bonus, treat yourself to a very interesting audio commentary by music historian Daniel Goldmark.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of my favourite Porky Pig cartoons
TheLittleSongbird17 November 2012
I have loved Looney Tunes cartoons for as long as I can remember, and I could watch them all day if I wanted to. Swooner Crooner is just wonderful, and one of Porky's best for me. Porky is great value here, he can be bland when he is partnered with stronger characters but he is always endearing regardless. The animation is beautiful to watch, very crisp and vibrant in colour, while the music has so much character and nostalgic value. The songs are a treasure trove of old favourites, and are just a joy to the ear. Maybe the story is not the strongest one in the world, though it is an original one, but that doesn't matter in the slightest to me as there is never a dull moment and the whole of Swooner Crooner is relentlessly entertaining. The dialogue has freshness and wit, the gags are clever and imaginatively timed- the auditions especially are an absolute riot- and the caricatures of Frank Sinatra(the best one for me), Bing Crosby, Cab Calloway, Jimmy Durante, Nelson Eddy and Al Jolson are really fun to spot. Mel Blanc's vocal characterisations never disappoint, always a large part of why Looney Tunes cartoons work so well as a majority whole, and Swooner Crooner is no exception. All in all, wonderful and recommended with no hesitation. 10/10 Bethany Cox
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Bizarre, grotesque and not very funny
phantom_tollbooth3 November 2008
Frank Tashlin's 'The Swooner Crooner' is a cartoon I never saw on TV as a child and seeing it on DVD now it's clear why it was kept off children's TV. The concept for the cartoon is one big dirty joke! Porky Pig is a farmer who wants to increase the amount of eggs that his hens lay. He realises that the sexual arousal they experience when watching a Frank Sinatra caricature rooster perform results in them laying eggs in enormous quantities. So Porky sets about auditioning singing roosters to keep the hens in a permanent state of arousal. 'The Swooner Crooner' is a bizarre and ever-so-slightly grotesque short which I've never warmed to in the least. Most of the gags consist of various images of swooning chickens or chickens laying piles of eggs in one go. It's scarcely the stuff of split sides. Nevertheless, the cartoon was nominated for an Academy Award. No doubt the Sinatra and Bing Crosby caricatures were funnier back in the heyday of both performers. Indeed, the funniest part of 'The Swooner Crooner' in the rooster auditions in which we see a variety of caricatures of such performers as Jimmy Durante and Cab Calloway. The plot on which these caricatures are hung, however, is paper thin and the final gag is particularly strange and grotesque.
0 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Highly Recommended
TexAveryfan15 October 2007
Good cartoon.

Unlike Lee Eisenberg I won't write irrelevant, completely out of the blue stuff in a review, he wrote something like everyone in his generation firmly believes Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra should be mocked as brutally as possible. Where did this come from? I don't know. Why was it worth including? I have no idea. What on earth leads him to believe that Crosby and Sinatra are today viewed alongside Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini as some of history's greatest dictators? only in Eisenberg's special little mind can this one be answered.

The cartoon itself is highly recommended.The fact that it is able to skillfully blend a great mix of WW2 propaganda together with humorous parody's of contemporary entertainers at the time, All while not looking a bit dated by todays standards and reaming one of the most entertaining Looney Tune cartons and far more entertaining than most cartoons produced today alone earns it a great deal of merit.

8/10 Highly recommended.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Oscar-nominated! (Well-deserved!)
wm626762 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I agree with most of the above reviews, but the one that appears just prior to mine (at least as I am writing this) has a glaring error! It was written by a man in England who seems not to have been paying attention to the plot, which he scorns! No, Sir, the hens are not laying piles of eggs because they are aroused by Frankie's singing! They are DISTRACTED by his singing and are NOT laying eggs! THAT's why Porky is auditioning other caricature roosters: To get the hens back to work! The auditions are a riot! Sorry that you, Sir, are offended by what happens in this cartoon. Wake up, Man--this is not deep Orson Welles stuff! Take it as the funny send-up that it is!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Porky's sole Oscar nod and it took a battle of crooning fowl to get it for him!
llltdesq3 April 2001
This cartoon, nominated for Oscar, was Porky's only shot at the gold. It's a marvelous cartoon and parodies Sinatra and Crosby, among others. Watch particularly the audition, when Porky is trying out singers to get his hens laying eggs again. The guys at Termite Terrace loved parodies, not only actors, but singers as well. The auditionees are all parodies. It's a scream and great fun figuring out who's who. Reportedly, Bing Crosby hated it when he was parodied in cartoons. How Frank Sinatra felt about it, I have no idea. Recommended.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This Oscar-nominated piece of War-Time Production Prodding . . .
oscaralbert21 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
. . . is about more than propagating enormous piles of chicken eggs, Warner Bros. makes clear. The sign at the beginning of SWOONER CROONER indicates that Porky Pig is managing the "Flockheed Eggcraft Factory--100% War Work." But is this facility REALLY populated by farmyard fowl? Heck no! When one hen is temporarily Defeathered about four minutes into this animated short, it's revealed that underneath her fluffy white quills she's sporting a matching lingerie set comprised of a lacy pink brassiere and panties! Furthermore, whenever the Frank Sinatra or Bing Crosby roosters croon love songs, they send this female flock's egg ducts into overdrive, upping their output from a single white orb to dozens of eggs popped out per hen at a single sitting. Clearly, SWOONER CROONER constitutes a U.S. War Department-sanctioned effort to get America's Rosies riveting overtime. Why all the love songs at a "100% War Work factory?" (After all, these are not the "Make love, not war" 1960s!) Mainly this bullets & bombers by candlelight campaign was implemented due to Hitler's threat to spearhead a "Thousand Year Reich" or Ten-Century Reign of Nazi Terror. This, of course, raised the specter of a multi-generational conflict. That made it the DUTY of every American woman to become pregnant at every opportunity, preferably with twins, at least, since the Babes of Today became Tomorrow's Grunts. (And if Rosie could not be with the one she loved--or to whom she was wed--her marching orders were to love the one she was with!) That way, Rosie could make tanks, and have her baby, too. In hindsight, this proved to be Overbirth, leading to the Baby Boom, but who wants to be a Monday morning quarterback?
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed