User Reviews

Passion for Life begins with a new teacher coming to a rural village. This teacher, Pascal, is fresh from college, eager, and with new ideas about how school should be taught. For one, he does not like sitting on a raised platform above the students. For another, he distrusts rote memorization. Finally, he wants the students to develop a passion for learning and to always be curious. These beliefs put Pascal at odds with the village leaders, the old teacher Pascal is replacing, and, at first, the old teacher's daughter.

I saw Passion for Life at a summer college film series. None of the audience members knew anything about the film. They ended up being very pleased with the film. It is a hard one to dislike. Passion for Life is a light, pro-student, pro-education film that runs only 90 minutes. This is classical French filmmaking, pre-New Wave, when the emphasis was on rustic characters.

I am not often taken by sentimental films, but I like this one. True, it offers few surprises and the script is not overly risky. However, the film succeeds at everything it wants to do. I was also pleased to see that the climatic speech was given by one of the students instead of the teacher. Passion for Life deserves to be better known in the United States.

L'école buissonnière is a film directed by Paul Le Chanois and is a tribute to the French educator Célestin Freinet who was wounded in the World War I and began to experiment and to promote new methods (learning by doing) of education in France.So we see how Monsieur Pascal changes little by little the teaching: manual activities ,the pupils make investigation ,write a newpaper,etc.Bernard Blier is extraordinary as Monsieur Pascal.But we must also mention all the children for their performance.L'école buissonnière is very good film.

Dedicated to Mrs Montessori(Italy),Mr.Claparède (Switzerland) ,Mr Bekulé (Tchecoslovakia),Mr Décroly (Belgium) and to Mr Freinet (France).The latter's wife contributed to the screenplay ,and Monsieur Pascal is none other than Célestin Freinet.Celestin Freinet who was wounded in WW1 ,and thus could not talk very much so had to find new methods which revolutionized teaching skills.Unlike Monsieur Pascal,he did have to resign and to create his own schools.Even today ,even if you are not in a Freinet school,you can feel his influence here there and everywhere:if it had not been for him,education would perhaps have remained purely theoretical.

Now for the film.

First of all,this is a GOOD movie,nay,a splendid one,regarded in context.Jean-Paul Le Chanois,too often dismissed by those fusty Cahiers Du Cinema (which should be relegated to the archives,we are in 2007 dash it!),outdoes himself and gives his best film ever.Bernard Blier is wonderful as Monsieur Pascal.We all would like to be his pupils.With him,gone is the iron discipline ,gone is the lesson you learned by heart even if you did not understand a single word of it,gone is the dunce the teacher shamefully hides in the back of his classroom.Monsieur Pascal loves all his pupils,he wants to give them all a chance:the classroom's dunce,reciting the 1789 Declaration des Droits de L'Homme et du Citoyen -which is much more important to Mr Pascal,and now to the youngster himself than the future

tense ,an arithmetic operation or the Sun King's death- in front of the board of examiners during his "Certificat d' Etude" (certificate formerly obtained by pupils at the end of primary school;it no longer exists) climaxes the movie.

WW1 was just over -and in 1948 ,when the film was made,WW2 was just over too- so the time had come to face the changes..Pascal displays the same enthusiasm,the same faith in man and the same joie de vivre as the youth of Jacques Becker's "Rendez-vous de Juillet".He believes in social advancement:the antique dealer's attitude is revealing ,by preventing the old lady from selling for a song her valuable piece of furniture ,they begin to rebel against the establishment for the first time:for that man ,being part of the city council has got the power in his hands.

"Let there be light" is Mr Pascal's motto.When he sees an old typewriter he thinks " printing" and as Gutenberg did at the end of the Middle Ages,he is ready to take his pupils out of obscurantism.

Another remarkable fact:

the women,who would not vote,who were not part of the city council are often smarter than their hubbies.A blind woman "feels" the good vibrations ,she feels that now children are happier,more responsible .Only naive viewers are still thinking that Truffaut was the first to turn his attention to the brats' misfortunes in Rousseau's land.Le Chanois was one of the first to start a mini-woman 's lib :this is already present here,this will be more obvious in "Le Cas Du Docteur Laurent" (1957) ,a plea for painless childbirth.

Joseph Kosma's music is magnificent :during the cast and credits,it is so stirring,so infectious that we are sure the film will not disappoint us.Something like the music George Van Parys would write for "Si Tous Les Gars du Monde" (1956).This tuneful piece will be used again music box style when the children draw the poor cat's story and sung by the whole classroom to support their dear teacher threatened by the antique dealer and his bourgeois friends.

There are so many things to write about "l'Ecole Buissonnière" : teachers of the world,you have got to see it .... and to show it to your pupils to make them comprehend how lucky they are to work with their computers,in their modern classrooms : there was a time when teachers had to invent everything: a water-powered electric generator which the children,learning by doing,built ,and let there be light!

As a former user said, "teachers of the world, you have got to see it...". I happen to teach myself at the University and they just showed "L'Ecole Buissonnière" tonight, at the late show, on the National French TV France 2. What a good surprise it has been ! Actually, this is a very interesting movie of the late 40s, based upon the personal experience of Célestin Freinet, in 1920, but the subject is still all the rage. No doubt that all those who enjoyed "The Dead Poets Society", "Mona Lisa's Smile", "Looking for Forrester" or "Les Choristes" will appreciate it. Not to mention more recent titles, such as "L'Esquive" and .... the 2008 Palme d'or in Cannes, Bertrand Cantet's "Entre Les Murs".

They showed us this film in education grad school at San Francisco State - then one of the two best schools of education in the US - when I was working on my secondary credential. It so move me that I modeled my teaching, as much as possible, on Monsieur Pascal. For years I tried to find a copy for sale - but as it turned out, I had the director's name wrong. So I called the media center at SF State, and found someone who knew the film backwards and forwards. Once she gave me the proper name of the Director, I found the film at Facet's Video in Chicago and immediately ordered two copies on VHS. The young woman who took the order said, "What is about this film? You're the second person today to place and order." "Have you seen it?" "No, but I will now!" For the past 50 years, the film has been an inspiration. No longer on VHS - last time I looked it was going for $200 - but you can download it from INA the French National Archive without English subtitles. It's an extraordinary film, whether you're a teacher or anyone interested in how schools should work. Do NOT miss it.