Legione straniera (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Old-fashioned but could have been worse
guy-bellinger9 March 2011
More old-fashioned than this pot-boiler is hard to find. What you get is the standard legion flick, complete with murder, wrong man-joining- Foreign-Legion, Femme Fatale, sadistic sergeant, the lot...

Yet, very surprisingly, "Legione straniera" IS watchable. The credit is for Basilio Franchina, its director, who, without going above and beyond his stale material like Josef von Sternberg, proves able enough to maintain a minimum of interest.

Among the good points are Viviane Romance's convincing performance (as cabaret singer Chérie, she manages to convey emotion behind her seductress ways), Marc Lawrence (a delight as the hatable sergeant),one or two well-framed and well-edited sequences (the best being Chérie's statement of contempt towards her former lover, Marc Lawrence/Sergeant Ouvrard), the good capturing of French colonial reality and a fine long battle sequence.

Not a masterpiece for sure but Basilio Franchina limits the damage, which is a feat in itself considering the poor story the film is based on.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Brothers in arms.
ulicknormanowen20 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Viviane Romance was one of the two bad gals of the French cinema of the thirties and of the forties ;and it's there that this movie belongs, an old-fashioned drama ,which ,made in 1953,looked rather quaint.

Romance plays the femme-fatale-with-a big-heart , still attractive in her forties, but her fans might be disapppointed :she disappears in the last third and the denouement is thoroughly Romance-less.

For the rest , the gist of the movie that it ,it is rehashed Duvivier' s"la bandera"(1935) stuff: the Légion Etrangère , a way to escape when the police are hot on your heels,even though you are totally innocent. But when you have signed a five-year enlistment ,it's hard to give the slip to this elite army ;no cliché is spared: the sadistic sergeant , the tiring training ; the kind corporal who helps the new recruit 's young brother join his sibling in the fort , soon to be attacked by the baddies, namely the wicked Arabs .

The film begins like a melodrama as old as the hill (the daughter of a well off family can't marry a sailor ) and ends up as a tribute to the Legion Etrangere , the last scene recalling that of Hathaway 's "lives of a Bengal lancer" (1935)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed