Ein Herz spielt falsch (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Slow? Unplausible? Yes. And still...
suchenwi1 January 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Anybody who criticizes this film as being a forgettable melodrama tear-jerker may be perfectly right.

But what you get depends on what you expect. I expected a time-capsule that conveys feelings of 1950s Germany. What film-makers thought would sell well. And in this light, this wasn't exactly a bad experience.

Peter, a do-no-good, is involved with hatter's shop-girl Gerda - enough to make her pregnant, but not enough to marry her. Instead, he finds out that a very rich girl (whom he knows from school) has only months to live, and endeavors to marry her for the heritage.

His plan works out well. Only.. he finds that he'd rather see her live than die. An Italian doctor may find a cure, so he embezzles and smuggles company money to support his research...

Not sure how realistic this was back then, but I enjoyed the show (and O.W. Fisher plays the initial bad guy more convincingly than his later reformed part).

Reissued on DVD by ScreenPower, the soundtrack seems to have been filtered from all noise, so that the voices sometimes come through very low. Anyway, well worth the 5€ I spent on it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Creaky old-fashioned sudser
jandewitt20 July 2004
Virtually rushed through her next production 'Ein Herz spielt falsch' while the excitement over her runaway success 'Die grosse Versuchung' was still hot, Ruth Leuwerik emerged as an absolute box-office sensation. Within a few month the elegant, regal beauty topped all popularity polls and went on to even bigger fame the next year.

A truly affecting performance by Ruth Leuwerik distinguished this old sudser of a rich father secretly bribing a young man to marry his daughter who had only one year to live. Love dawned after the hasty marriage, then she found out THE TRUTH, and - oh heavens, the agony of it all....They could have sold tissues by the boxful at every performance of this 40-carat weepie that kept Germany's womanhood in tears for month.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed