Deadly Decision (1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"How can I serve a cause I do not believe in?"
brogmiller5 January 2024
It beggars belief that the figure of Admiral Wilhelm Canaris has been portrayed only thrice on film, so far as this viewer is aware. As played by Anthony Quayle he is a minor character in John Sturges' uneven 'The Eagle has landed', has a miniscular role in 'Voyage of the Damned', in the person of a totally miscast Denholm Elliott and here the magnificent performance by O. E. Hasse cannot alas compensate for the film's shortcomings.

It is not a bad film by any means but lacks the touch of a master as Alfred Weidenmann is no more than capable and in keeping with German cinema of the time has been reduced to a spy thriller with a bit of 'love interest' thrown in.

Needless to say the utterly monstrous Reinhard Heydrich has proved far more appealing to film makers and has been personified on numerous occasions ranging from Hans von Twardowski's grotesque caricature to the quietly sinister Siegfried Loyoda to the chillingly matter-of-fact Kenneth Branagh. His uneasy relationship with Canaris is well realised in this but Martin Held's performance, for this viewer at any rate, fails to convey the sheer evil of the man. As there is no show without Punch, also featured are the always dependable Wolfgang Preiss and the ubiquitous Charles Regnier whilst Barbara Ruetting provides the Oestrogen factor.

One never really gets the feeling of 'being there' and much of what occurs is extraneous with an eye to the commercial element. The makers have chosen to omit, amongst other things, Canaris' relationship with Polish spy Halina Szymanska whilst Frau Canaris is nowhere to be seen. The film ends with his being arrested and driven away.

Tried for alleged complicity in the July Plot he was led naked to the scaffold and hanged on a butcher's hook. It is highly unlikely that he will ever be done justice to on screen but the sensitive playing of O. E. Hasse has at least given us a glimpse of the almost unendurable moral dilemma with which Canaris had to grapple.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fine Film
denis8885 January 2018
This is a very fine film, with excellent Otto Hasse as Admiral Canaris, the very German Abwehr Head who was, as we know, one of the anti-Hitler Resistance leaders, as well as impeccable and surgically neat and excellent Wolfgang Preiss as his aid, Colonel Hollem. There are other great German actors taking part in this period drama, with Martin Held as a chilling cold-blooded Nazi General Heydrich. The film is far from being flawless, as two hours aren't enough to cover life of this highly tragic man, who happened to live in Hitler's times, and who chose to fight, not run. There are weaker parts when the movie slides into a typical 50's schmaltzy detective flick, or when very important events are mentioned just as a faint glimpse. Still, in general, this is a very decent anti-war film with slightly skint but still powerful message that often it takes much courage to say No when all scream Yes. The film proves to show this, and manages to depict great decisions and sturdy assureness. Recommended.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Lacks focus and clear structure
Horst_In_Translation13 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Canaris" is a West German movie from 1954, so this one is already over 60 years old. It is in black-and-white and was directed by Alfred Weidenmann and written by Erich Ebermayer and Herbert Reinecker. The movie was a big winner at the German Film Awards that year and that may have had to do with the contemporary impact the film made back in the day. It is another attempt of Germany's filmmakers in the 1950s to depict and elaborate on what happened in Germany back between 1933 and 1945, a topic that has been worked on on so so many occasions. And with huge quantity, there also comes huge forgettable stuff. Sadly, this film is not among the best the country had to offer in terms of war-themed film. It is not really lead actor O.E. Hasse's fault as he does a convincing job with the lead character. I personally however felt that the film was way too long for its own good. At almost two hours, it lacked focus on many occasions and I felt there were many scenes that could have been left out because they added little to none to the overall picture. In terms of the story, many people may not have heard about Canaris, who really existed, but his story is a bit of a mix between Stauffenberg and Rommel, so you know the general direction this film is taking. It is about resistance against Hitler in the broadest sense. If this subject interests you, then you can check it out. You just should not be expecting too much.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed