In "La grande speranza," director Duilio Coletti brings forth an acceptable Italian production that dives into the wartime experiences of a submarine commander and his crew during World War II. Renato Baldini leads the cast with a commendable performance as the Italian sub commander, delivering a portrayal that captures the emotional complexities of his character. The film effectively explores the challenges faced by the crew as they navigate the moral dilemmas of rescuing survivors from the very ships they have torpedoed.
The cinematography by Leonida Barboni, although occasionally not very brilliant, manages to convey the harsh realities of underwater warfare. The use of stock war footage enhances the authenticity of sea battles, contributing to the overall immersive experience.
Nino Rota's musical score, reminiscent of his later work in "The Godfather," adds a layer of depth to the narrative. The film's dedication to the men who perished in Italian submarines during the war adds a poignant touch, underscoring the gravity of the events portrayed.
The ensemble cast, featuring European actors like Folco Lulli, Aldo Bufi Landi, and Spanish actor Jose Jaspe, complements Baldini's performance. Lois Maxwell, known for her role as James Bond's Moneypenny, delivers a noteworthy portrayal as a woman soldier caught in the midst of the submarine's operations.
"La grande speranza" stands out as an unconventional war movie, delving into the human aspects of war, including the camaraderie among the crew, the challenges faced by rescued passengers, and moments of celebration and reflection. The film successfully weaves together drama, emotion, and thrills, making it a worthwhile watch for its magnificent acting and strong supporting cast.
This war film with marked anti-war tones is part of a series of movies from the recent post-war era aimed at shaping the myth of the "good Italian," portraying Italian military enterprises as an example of good wartime behavior. However, we know that Italians have been equally formidable as other contenders. This phenomenon must be framed within the recent construction of a European sentiment, which, just three years later in 1957, led to the signing of the famous Treaty of Rome, the constitutive agreement of the European Economic Community (EEC).
In conclusion, despite some technical shortcomings, "La grande speranza" remains a compelling war film that resonates with its portrayal of the sadness and humanity intertwined in the throes of conflict.