This Island Earth (1955) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
164 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Entertaining Sci-Fi from the 50's
claudio_carvalho4 October 2015
The electronic engineer Dr. Cal Meacham (Rex Reason) is a prominent scientist that is studying industrial application of nuclear energy and also a great pilot. One day, he receives a different condenser and soon his assistant Joe Wilson (Robert Nichols) receives a manual instruction and several components of a sophisticated machine. Carl and Joe build a communication apparatus and a man called Exeter (Jeff Morrow) contacts Carl. He tells that Carl has passed the test assembling the Interocitor and invites him to join his research. The intrigued Carl decides to travel to meet Exeter that sends an unmanned airplane to bring him to an isolated facility in Georgia. He is welcomed by Dr. Ruth Adams (Faith Domergue) but she mysteriously does not recall their love affair in the past. They team-up with Dr. Steve Carlson (Russell Johnson) and they note that the other scientists in the facility have been transformed, having a weird behavior. They decide to flee in a car, but they are attacked by rays and Steve dies. Carl and Ruth also witness the facility blowing-up and they escape in an airplane. However they are pulled up into a flying saucer and realize that Exeter is an alien. Whal is the objective of the aliens?

"This Island Earth" is an entertaining sci-fi from the 50's, with a story of aliens that need help from the Earthling scientists in their war against another planet. For a film made sixty years ago, the special effects, the monster, sets and scenarios are great. My vote is six.

Title (Brazil): "Guerra Entre Planetas" ("War Between Planets")

Note: On 17 November 2017 I saw this film again.
24 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
WHAT'S THE PROBLEM?
Bob-4515 July 1999
Guess I'll have to watch MYSTERY SCIENCE THEATER 3000: THE MOVIE to find out what is so bad about THIS ISLAND EARTH. The film is intriguingly plotted, beautifully photographed, and has excellent (even by contemporary standards) art direction, costume design and special effects. So what if Rex Reason sounds as if he was dubbed (he always sounds that way), and some of the other performances seem a bit stilted. The Metaluna Mutant was the most memorable outer space monster until ALIEN.

I can only recall one technical error in the film. After the interociter (communicator) has been reduced to molten metal, Rex Reason picks up a Geiger counter and says, "It's no longer radioactive." There IS no set up for this (i.e., when it proved to be radioactive).

I'd certainly rate this film in the top ten of the best science fiction films of the fifties (probably in the top five). It's philosophical, exciting and well made.
116 out of 139 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Visually beautiful for its time; a rather good "B" adventure and unusual
silverscreen88814 June 2005
I am old enough to have seen "This Island Earth" when it was first released. After "Forbidden Planet", it was the only other film for a decade to take place outside of Earth's solar system. Galactic fiction had been written for decades by Edmond Hamilton and a handful of others, very successfully; but it is still rare and hard to handle in film, because it requires some level of ideas and logical development of a political-philosophical system other than conventional and unimaginative acceptances--the stock in trade of those who rip off headlines, use titles such as "Across the Ses of Stars"--and then write nothing at all to go with the promising title. Here we have a mysterious robot-controlled aircraft's flight, mail from aliens, the building of an Inter-Rossiter communication device, tall-domed aliens (exhibiting a variety of ethical characters), interstellar flight, a war on a planet called Metalluna, flaming comet-missiles, a competent alien mutant creature, an intelligent cat named Neutron, romance, news conferences, good and bad advice and more. The original story line, for those who have not read Raymond Z. Jones' original mystery-sci-fi, is much better than what was done with its ideas in the film's script. In that novel,Earth was to be destroyed, because it was in the way and being used as a base by one of two sides in a huge interstellar war; at the end, the hero, whose ingenuity has saved the one side, has to make a speech to save the Earth--a climax that did not make it into the film version. Handsome Rex Reason, who lacks classical accent ability, plays scientist Cal Meacham, opposite Faith Domergue, a fair actress who does well as Ruth, his long-lost love, or is she. The film is stolen by Jeff Morrow as Exeter, also star of "Kronos"; Douglas Spencer is a bit disappointing as The Monitor, as is Lance Fuller as an evil Metallunan; the special effects such as rays that explode cars and the aforementioned comets are interesting for their time. What is right about the film I suggest is its color, its adventure narrative and swift-paced unfolding, since it is rather well-directed; what is lacking is the first-rate ideas of the novel from which it was adapted. "This Island Earth" ( a phrase later used in "Star trek's "All Our Yesterdays" also) is arguably a welcome change from all those sci-fi films where rockets seem tied to earth, unable to expand the human horizon. I like it, and recommend it to anyone who wants to escape from the present mean-streets ugliness cult's movies; it is physically beautiful and frankly more entertaining than most have credited it with being these past 50 years.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Loved it at age 11; still find it great at 56.
Hank Lay19 May 1999
When it came out, I thought this was the most fantastic movie I'd ever seen. It was easy to identify with the lead character and to share his fascination with the technology that the aliens used to capture his attention and recruit his talents. I particularly remember being entranced by the special effects; the use of vivid color was outstanding among sci-fi offerings of the time. 45 years later, it's still my favorite of the era. I enjoy watching the movie on video and recalling the thrill of seeing it on the big screen for the first time.
85 out of 89 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mixed Bag of SF Conventions.
rmax3048236 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The film divides itself more or less clearly into two parts. In the first part, electronic genius and atomic power researcher, Rex Reason, is challenged by an unknown source to build an interociter. He successfully passes the test. The interociter acts like a big, triangular TV except that it has a self-destruct mechanism and can emit deadly rays that melt lead. When Reason turns it on, he is able to communicate with Exeter (Jeff Morrow), who describes himself as "a scientist like yourself." Morrow invites Reason to take a trip on a mysterious, pilot-less airplane, which he does. The plane lands at a fully equipped laboratory complex which houses a handful of the most famous scientists in the world. All of them seem to be working on the conversion of matter into energy. Morrow warns them not to discuss their work with each other and, in fact, the place is a bit like a fancy prison. Reason and another scientist, Faith Domergue, are spirited away in a space ship and the other scientists destroyed.

In Part Two, we get a load of the flying saucer's innards, which have a familiar look about them. These plastic tubes come down over the occupants and rev up their ability to withstand pressure on the planet they are heading for. Similar tubes prepared the crew of the ship in "Forbidden Planet" and I don't know how many times Captain Kirk and Scotty went through them. Metaluna, the planet on which they land is in sorry straits. It's under constant attack by meteors guided by space ships from the enemy planet of Zygon. It's only defense is an ionization layer maintained by nuclear power, and Metaluna is fast running out of energy, which is why the earth expedition was mounted. It turns out to be too late to save Metaluna. Only Morrow, Reason, and Domergue are able to escape in the saucer and return to earth, where Reason and Domergue land safely and Morrow does not.

Part One is the more interesting of the two. I kind of enjoyed the way Reason responded to the challenge of building an interociter from a schematic diagram the size of a football field. "Where do we start?" asks his assistant. "Right here," replies Reason, planting his fingertip firmly on a sketch of what looks like a power tube. And the scenes at the laboratory complex were fun, too. Morrow keeps complimenting the others on their "curiosity" but they didn't seem to have much in the way of curiosity to me. The first thing I'd have asked upon landing was how come Morrow and his henchman have such terribly big heads. The gradual realization by the earth people that not all is as it seems, is well done too, except that it's rather brief. Reason asks Morrow over dinner, "How do you like Mozart?" "Mozart?", says Morrow, "I don't think I know the gentleman. Oh -- you mean your composer." "Our composer?", says Reason. "I'd have thought Mozart belonged to the world." It's a nice little touch, a snag in the texture of conventional life, like catching your coat sleeve on a nail, but it's about the only one. It needed more incidents like that, so that the suspicion would grow. As it is, it's already there, full blown.

Part Two is less interesting because there are few surprises and little to wonder about. Everything seems overwhelmed by the special effects. Why do all the inhabitants of Metaluna speak English? And why is the name of the planet in Latin. Why does Exeter have such an echt-British name? And why is there a war between Metaluna and Zyglotz or whatever it is? Now THAT'S an interesting question. All these eggheads on two planets who can zip between galaxies as easily as you and I take a spin in the car -- and they can't help exterminating each other? It's so very Buck Rogers.

Rex Reason is tall, masculine, and has a deep voice. Faith Domergue isn't and doesn't. Jeff Morrow isn't an especially interesting actor but he has the most complex role. He's in conflict with his boss, the "monitor", who is concerned about nothing but saving Metaluna, even if it means the earthlings are expendable, and, on the other hand, his genuine liking for his earthly friends and his worry about their welfare.

There have been better, and there have been worse.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
An Interositer, every family should have one
bkoganbing20 April 2012
This Island Earth was a film I feel might have run out of budget. There was so much time spent on introducing the characters and having those two earth scientists trapped for a trip to the planet Metaluna that when they got there, they seemed in a big hurry to get them in and out.

The Metalunans have a mission they are seeking to obtain all the uranium on earth to power their defenses against a ruthless interplanetary enemy. It's why they send Jeff Morrow and Lance Fuller to Earth. Also to prepare the planet for a possible invasion.

If that was their intention, they're a day late and a dollar short. Metaluna is being decimated by meteors controlled by the enemy of the Metalunans whom we never see. They've got defenses that repel the meteors, but are powered by uranium and the planet has run out. Looks like some really bad planning here for a culture that is so advanced from where Earth is.

The bait is an Interositer which is an all purpose machine as advertised by the Metalunans who've come to Earth in secret in one of those flying saucers every now and then spotted. Building one intrigues scientist Rex Reason and it turns out to be a communication device where Morrow contacts them.

Eventually the laboratory that the Metalunans set up on Earth is destroyed when the Earth people discover they're being used and all but Reason and Faith Domergue are killed. They are captured and brought aboard the flying saucer and learn what's happening on the trip to Metaluna.

Some really nice sets, very imaginative were done for this film by Universal. This definitely has the look of being a more ambitious project than what turned out.
13 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Classic and strange piece of imaginative science-fiction with primitive but enjoyable effects
ma-cortes18 May 2018
The planet Metaluna is desperate need of Uranium to power its defense . As Aliens led by Exeter , Jeff Morrow , come to Earth seeking scientists to help them against enemy invaders . Two scientific , Rex Reason Faith Domergue , are deceived , menaced , abducted and transported from earth to a weird and ruined planet where occurs explosion and destruction.As our heroes are theatened by unknown forces .

Acceptable Scifi movie has thrills , intricate gadgetry , emotion , FX ahead of their time and super mutant monsters .This classic and rare Sci-Fi is considered to be the first serious film about interplanetary escapades .It contains primitive special effects and abundant matte painting . Including passable effects of a flying saucer based on a famous picture of an unidenfitied flying object UFO . Mediocre interpretation by an average cast. Starred by little known actors as Rex Reason as a nuclear scientist , Jeff Morrow as the rare alien , and the beautiful Faith Domergue as a nuclear fission expert who screams lustily . Other secondaries are given little to do such as Lance Fuller , Russell Johnson , Douglas Spencer and Richard Deacon . Here stands out the decent makeup by Bud Westmore creating pulsating cranium FX makeup on a gigantic and ugly Alien monster. Although some reviewers felt that the mutant utterly ruined an otherwise acceptable film . It was shown in US drive-in on a double bill with another classic Scfi titled Forfidden planet .

Strange but appropriate musical score from Herman Stein , Hans J Salter and Henry Mancini . Colorful cinematography in brilliant technicolor , by Clifford Stine , as technical details are presented in convincing enough fashion , being the only technicolor scifi movie Universal-International ever made .This genuine and decent science fiction was well produced by Willian Alland and professionally directed by Joseph M Newman . He was a prolific craftsman who made all kinds of genres as drama , gangster movie , Film Noir , adventure , such as : Tarzan ,Jungle patrol , The king of the roaring 20s the story of Arnold Rothstein , Love nest , Great Dan Patch and , of course , Science Fiction with this vintage film of the fifties titled This island earth. Rating : 6/10 , decent movie . Essential and indispensable watching for SciFi buffs . Well worth seeing.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good For Its Time, Hard to View in the 21st Century
robbotnik200025 April 2009
Just saw it for the first time (in 2008). One of the other commentators called it the 'Star Wars' of its time. I think that is a fair comment, because each for its time had good effects, wooden acting, and a bare bones plot. 'This Island Earth' has a plot which has become one of the B movie standard plots, Aliens who, for some reason and despite the obvious advanced technology that enables them to arrange transportation to and from Earth, need technology from earth. Why such an advanced civilization requires it is barely logical, although TIE gives it a try. The acting is not first rate, the romantic relationship is juvenile, which is appropriate for the sci-fi of the 50's, but good movie writers did much better work even then. Science Fiction is a great field, created in the 19th century, nascent in the 30's, and blossoming with the advent of the nuclear age. Movie producers gave it short shrift until the 60's, but there are two outstanding American SciFis of the 50's: 'Forbidden Planet', and 'Day The Earth Stood Still'. These movies have good levels of acting, very good effects, a sense of humor, and some real ideas if not messages, without intruding on the plane fun of many of the scenes. These movies give us a standard to compare with other movies of the time. By the use of this standard, TIE weighs in as acceptable fare for the era, but not even close as imaginative story telling to FP or DTESS. Watch it for comparison, watch it if wasted, if you want the brain engaged, go for one of the traditional greats.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Nice Sci Fi Movie of the Fifties
Hitchcoc20 April 1999
"This Island Earth" is not the greatest science fiction movie of all time, but it deserves more respect than it is often granted. The boys at MST3K (whom I think are great) may have done this film a great disservice. In its day, it was thoughtful, imaginative, and the special effects were excellent. I disagree with those who say there is no plot. The cold war fears and xenophobia were once again at the center of this fifties effort. The alien as our "friend" was later used in many settings, including one of the best of the "Twilight Zone" episodes, "To Serve Man."

I was young when I first saw this in a movie theater, but even then I found the home planet, Metaluma, very striking and its fate frightening. I fear that often our smugness in criticizing older films, judging them by standards that they could not have hoped to approach because of the limitations of the technology, keeps us from acceptance of their good points and their contributions. I have an acquaintance who can't watch the Maltese Falcon because it is in black and white. What a loss. The sets are striking in this film. The aliens are a bit of a stretch, but I still like what they are. I saw this movie a couple times in a theatre (not the MST version). As people left they were captivated and involved. When we left, we had had fun (not from ridiculing but enjoying). Granted there are no computer morphs and no giant metal bugs sucking brains out, but it is still good stuff.
98 out of 105 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
If you want to visit Metaluna...
RodrigAndrisan17 August 2017
Still watchable after 62 years, despite the fact that it is a modest production, did not benefit from the huge sums of money invested in today's super productions. But, so modestly, the sets, costumes, very important for any sci-fi, are still valid. The aliens from Metaluna look convincing and original with their long forehead and white hair with the crest. Filmed, played and directed efficiently, without boring moments. Only those monsters, they look more funny than scary. And, except Dr. Ruth Adams(Faith Domergue's character), another terrestrial lady who has only one line and one extra-terrestrial lady, you will see only men, including terrestrials and extra-terrestrials. All three main actors, Jeff Morrow, Faith Domergue and Rex Reason, also appeared in other SF films. The music, by 3 uncredited guys, one of them, the great future Henry Mancini. So, if you want to visit Metaluna, the dying planet, go for it! But, I'm warning you, it's not a very pleasant luxury trip.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
So What's the Hype?
Gislef19 March 1999
I had seen this in my much younger years, and nothing in it really stood out. Over the years, I've heard much about how great a movie TIE was. Then I watched it as the MST3K movie, and then on AMC. And you really got to wonder...so what's so great about it, and what were those critics thinking?

It does indeed have lovely matte paintings of Metaluna (sic). But after that... You've got dopey looking aliens, even by 50's standards. You've got a really, really goofy looking ant. And you've got a plot that goes nowhere. "We've come to Earth to secretly draw on your intellectual resources...so we'll let one of our guys blow you all up. Then we'll take you two back to our home planet just so you can watch it blow up. Then we'll take you back in our last ship, right before it blows up." There's a whole lot a blowin' up goin' on, allrighty. The movie starts somewhat intriguingly, but slows to a plod, as the technobabble is tossed out at levels that we wouldn't see until decades later in the Star Trek franchise. I just think the critics don't want to admit how their initial assessment of TIE was so off.
11 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Space Movie That Boldly Went Where Others Haven't--Unfortunately!
pbsbkb4 February 2004
Pulp science fiction created an aura of awe and excitement that is rarely equaled in these current days of sci-fi movie "actioners". Gone are the opportunities to see alien species and their homelands depicted in "wonderous Technicolor". Instead, we are routinely preached to by screenwriters determined to warn us, ad nauseum, of man's follies and the impending disasters always depicted as a forgone result. Yes, now we get chiseled heroes, and heroines, too, who are usually engaged in single-handedly shooting up the screen with loud twentieth century-derived weapons. Where is the fun in these stereotypical, shoot-em-up extravaganzas?

"This Island Earth"("TIE") with (for its time, remember)jaw-dropping visuals, big, truly alien world realizations and theme of inter-solar system war, hasn't been matched since its debut almost fifty years ago! For a plot that catapults you half way around the universe with one beautifully realized set after another and an epic-sized stage on which to play out its themes, perhaps only "Forbidden Planet" ever matched up.

The sounds, the visuals and the story line of "TIE" weren't intended to chastise you as a stupid earthling, but instead, have long served to take the willing on an adventure ride that all too few space movies have chosen to create. Until Hollywood chooses to really explore the universe you ought to have your own copy of "This Island Earth", in order to frequently remind yourself of what we should all be seeing much more often: space movies that enthrall!
121 out of 133 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Scientifically Flawed, But Fully Entertaining
gavin694226 December 2006
A scientist named Cal is invited to join a secret society of scientists put together by an alien from Metaluna. Is he working to get more technology for Earth or is the motive a bit more sinister? Audiences today (2010) probably know this film best as the feature in "Mystery Science Theater 3000: The Movie" (which was a great show but a lackluster movie). Which is too bad, because being on there would imply this was a really awful film. This is absolutely false.

The movie sets up a very interesting plot with likable characters. Early on, two scientists are delivered mysterious parts to be assembled from a source unknown. Once completed, they have built an interociter, allowing them to see somewhere far away and the far away to see them. Like today's video phones or video conferences, only this was in 1955 when such things were unthinkable.

The aliens are believable, if you think aliens are humanoid, and the makeup is decent. Criticisms could be made, but even much later "Star Trek" was using the same ideas, so don't blame these people.

The biggest complaint I can offer is that some of the science was nonsense. Somehow a magnet can trap the hands of a prisoner (are they metal hands?) and a cat is named "Neutron" because he's always positive. This last one might have been a joke, but if so it was poorly delivered. This nitpicks in no way distract from the film, in my opinion.

If you want old science fiction in Technicolor with aliens and new technology, this is your film. Nothing too complicated, but likable and believable characters and situations. Sure, the glowing green airplane is a bit silly, but deal with it. If there is a science fiction hall of fame, I hope this film made it in.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Better watched in Mystery Science Theatre
tomgillespie200218 June 2011
This 1955 cult sci-fi 'favourite' first came to my attention whilst I was watching Mystery Science Theatre 3000: The Movie back in my University days. The clips accompanied by the sarcastic comments of the MST robots was hilarious, and I had to see the film. So, five or so years later, I did. And I realised without added hilarity of Mystery Science Theatre, the film isn't so much funny, as jaw-droppingly awful and frustratingly timid.

Square-jawed, opera-voiced, vanity-ridden cheeseball Dr. Cal Meacham (Rex Reason) is one of the best in his field, and when he starts receiving machine parts that he didn't order, he begins to build the 'interociter' along with the arse-sniffing colleague Joe (Robert Nichols). When it's built, a strange being appears on the monitor and invites Cal to join his academy that boasts a collection of top-rated scientists. Upon arrival, Cal suspects that things aren't as they seem, as the reason they are there is kept top secret. Or perhaps it's because the head the academy, Exeter (Jeff Morrow), has the forehead the size of an airport runway, and the skin tone of a used teabag.

Apparently the special effects were ground-breaking in their day, and perhaps they were. But I felt it actually lacked bad special effects, which at least would have given the film a bit of charm. Don't get me wrong, I usually love these kind of awful films, but the film was played so straight-faced that I just found it a bore. My lack of interest also led to me getting confused about the plot. But there are funny moments, mainly involving the obnoxious alpha-male Cal and his assistant, who follows him around like a dog, and a scene where an embarrassingly crap alien insect attacks Cal and his love interest Ruth (Faith Domergue). For some quality cheesy sci-fi, I would recommend Robinson Crusoe On Mars instead, and give this one a miss.

www.the-wrath-of-blog.blogspot.com
6 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This is a great treat from a wonderful era of Sci-Fi.
MickeyHSr12 March 2003
This is a great treat from a wonderful era of Sci-Fi. Those who complain of the hardware aspects have no romance - an Earth scientist receives an unsolicited manual and roomful of parts to build a futuristic two-way TV, but the parts are a marvel and the pages of the manual aren't paper, but some manner of flexible metal. After constructing the "Interociter", our hero receives a broadcast from Exeter, a fellow scientist with a suspiciously prominent forehead, inviting him to join his research team of the world's greatest experts in their fields. What follows is a comic book come-to-life, and in vivid, 3-part Technicolor! This film is beautiful to look at, and apparently many of today's best Sci-Fi filmmakers did. Rex Reason is fine as our hero, Jeff Morrow is one of the most memorable aliens of the era, and Faith Domergue is a fine actress and is mysteriously one of the most unsung beauties ever. And as to the hardware, the special effects, etc - there is actually nothing to complain about at all...the spaceship, the planet Metaluna, aliens, etc, are not merely passable for the 50's, they are compelling by today's standards. If you have just a bit of imagination, this is one of the best Sci-Fi classics of it's time, and still makes many contemporary efforts pale in comparison.
95 out of 101 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
What a good looking movie!
Stooovie19 August 2002
For every classic sci-fi afficionado, this is a must-see. It´s a bit short and awkward at times, but man, it look GREAT! Some of the FX and camera work are just unbelievable for its time and look very good even now. 8/10 for the production values, 5/10 for the script.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Interesting but not very good
tomimt7 July 2010
The first time I heard of This Island Earth was from MST3K. It was a funny spoof, despite I had never seen the movie, but then I kinda forgot about it, as I wasn't particularly looking for the movie, so I could see it. Until a local TV-station broadcast it.

Now, the good things first. There are some good special effects in the movie. I liked how the alien UFO looked like and their home planet, despite being barren from the war, was pretty neat. The acting is okay, not spectacular, but okay. The main star Rex Reason(?) is a bit too pompous for my liking, but other than that I have no big complaints.

But on to the bad things. There really isn't any specific reason for the human cast to be in the film. I mean, they don't actually do anything and after Dr. Cal and Dr. Adams (Faith Domergue) have been transferred to the alien world, they do even less. The story, while it has some interesting elements, does very little after Dr. Cal Meacham arrives to the mysterious conclave of scientists lead by mysterious Exeter (Jeff Morrow) The movie has a promise of something greater, but it just fails to deliver it. It has some good aspects in it, but as a whole, it's not very good movie.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Results yesterday
TBJCSKCNRRQTreviews22 June 2010
This was in a box-set I got on sale, with seven pictures from this time and in this genre. I haven't watched many of them, but while the FX of this are arguably only decent(with that said, that suit ain't bad), the designs of gizmos are reasonably interesting, and this certainly does deliver all you could hope for in one of these; campy alien beings, a nicely done foreign planet, cool labs and spacecraft, some pseudo-science(portions of which are rather questionable now that we know more...!) and, well, *fun*, with crap blowing up and being/catching on fire. It is also worth noting that for the xenophobia this does have, it doesn't paint *everything* we don't know or immediately recognize or understand as dangerous and something to be avoided. It is genuinely tense at points. The sexism can be annoying; however, it is not as strong as in others of these. Domergue is attractive. The characters are fairly well-written and credible, if not necessarily memorable. Editing and cinematography are average. The acting is good, and the leads are likable. There is a little minorly bloody violence in this. I recommend this to any fan of sci-fi movies from the period. 6/10
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Cheesy and predictable
grantss7 June 2020
Dr Cal Meecham is a top scientist in the fields of nuclear energy and electronics. One day he is contacted by a man named Exeter and asked to join a high-level project he is working on. Meecham travels to Exeter's isolated site in Georgia but it is soon obvious that things aren't as they appear to be.

This film was probably quite topical and interesting in 1955 but today it is laughable. So derisible that, in 1996, Mystery Science Theatre 3000 make an entire film that mocked this movie.

Even if the plot was relevant in 1955 it is still quite cheesily and predictably done. Acting is hammy, script is ridiculous at times and you can pretty much see through any attempts at subterfuge.

Not worth your time. Watch the Mystery Science Theatre 3000 send-up (which includes This Island Earth in its entirety) instead.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Follow-Up: My Complete Review
Whizzer-24 September 2000
The 1955 sci-fi film, "This Island Earth" was spoofed in the film,"MST 3000: The Movie"; but in actuality the film got good reviews from Leonard Maltin, The Motion Picture Guide, not to mention Bill Warren's monumental opus, "Keep Watching The Skies!". The acting in this film is not exceptional, but not dismal, I would say adequate. My favorite character is the Metalunan, Exeter - this dude is one smooth talker, oozing a sinister coolness, while displaying a funky appearance: neatly coiffured white hair, bushy eyebrows, a high indented forehead, coppertone tan and dressed in a conventional Earthian suit and tie (he would have made a great politician or televangelist!). His assistant, Braack, is a carbon copy, as are the other Metalunans. There is an atmosphere of suspense and intrigue and the plot is credible enough. One the technical side, a Metalunan communication device called an Interociter remains a centerpiece throughout the film; it is very versatile, able to incorporate an Interplanetary Generator, Volterator, Astroscope, Electron Sorter, and a deadly Neutrino Ray (all of these are not in the script, rather I got them from the Raymond F. Jones story the film is based upon; however, the Neutrino Ray was demonstrated by Exeter to Dr. Cal Meacham on occasion); Meacham pulled the plug on one of them in his lab, causing it to self-destruct; leading one to wonder if that device were so advanced, then why didn't it have a backup internal power source and safety feature to prevent that sort of sabotage? Moreover, why did it have to rely on an external power supply at all?' The highlight of the film is the voyage back to Metaluna with Drs Meacham and Adams on board; the distant planet is being attacked by enemy Zahgon guided meteors. The Drs were recruited to help the Metalunans rebuild their war depleted uranium supply which sustained their protective atomic force shield- the Earth is rich in uranium supply. The Metalunan spacecraft looks like a cheap, plastic toy pulled from a crackerjack box, but as it cruises through the "thermal barrier", the fiery special effects around the craft look way cool. And the special effects, set design and artwork of the war-ravaged planet and the ongoing battle there are simply excellent for that time period. In addition, the Herman Stein musical score is a tasty delight- the organ parts are simply an ear to behold! No, "This Island Earth" does not have the Oscar-Winning effects of "The War Of The Worlds", the snappy, overlapping dialogue of "The Thing From Another World", the abundant richness of ideas of "Forbidden Planet", nor the spine chilling suspense of "The Invasion of the Body Snatchers"; but what it does have is an irresistable charm, the result - I suspect - of having a peculiar combination of outstanding qualities coexisting alongside of much inferior ones. "This Island Earth" should definitely be part of every 50's sci-fi film connoisseur's collection.
71 out of 79 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Excellent early SciFi thriller
judiwegley30 December 2006
I can't be the only viewer who absolutely loves this movie! Having seen it as a youngster, I was very pleased when it came out recently in DVD format. The color is excellent, thanks to Technicolor technology. The plot, although considered humorous by some, involves the enlistment of earth scientists to help inhabitants of Metaluna build an "interocitor" to aid them in combatting the evil forces attempting to destroy their home planet. Rex Reason has a wonderful voice, and that is a special treat for me, since I grew up on and still enjoy old time radio. It is a shame MST3000 maligned this movie so much. With a supporting cast like Faith Domergue and Jeff Morrow, both veterans of genre, this movie is well worth your time.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Noble yet misguided attempt at serious sci-fi
johnnysugar8 August 2003
The film "This Island Earth", at the time of its production, represented a clear attempt to make a fantastic and thrilling science fiction film while also presenting a strong Message with Purpose. In modern times, however, it seems rather silly and preachy, and makes a fantastic candidate for "Mystery Science Theatre 3000" (this is the film featured in "MST3K: The Movie").

Nuclear scientist Dr. Cal Meachem (Rex Reason) is contacted by a strange man named Exeter (Jeff Morrow), who has assembled scientists from across the world to aid him, including Dr. Ruth Adams (Faith Domergue). The scientists are all involved in nuclear studies, and when all are destroyed save for Cal and Ruth, it is discovered that Exeter is an alien and that he was hoping that the scientists would aid his embattled and dying planet.

For vintage sci-fi, the acting is not bad. Of course, none of it is any good, but it's not painful. The human characters are all fairly archetypal, with Meachem being the stalwart, square-jawed hero and Ruth being the pretty, vulnerable heroine. Ruth is also a scientist, though, and the movie never downplays this or makes her seem unintelligent. Exeter himself is a far cry from the dominating aliens so common in vintage sci-fi, even if his personality seems to have been lost in space somewhere.

Even the special effects are fairly well-done for the time, and its clear from the cinematography and sets that this was an ambitious picture. The effects are at least as good as those on the original "Star Trek" series, which was produced over a decade later. The film's main failing comes in its laughable script.

The plot and pace shows little variation from similar films, but the screenwriters have tried far too hard to make the characters sound like they know what they're talking about. The actors try their best with these lines, but there's just no getting around some of them. At one point, the humans are instructed to latch onto magnetic bars, which would mean something if their hands were made of metal. Keep in mind, as they say in "MST3K: The Movie", that this was made at a time when science didn't have to have a specific purpose. The science bandied about fails to follow any kind of internal set of rules, which is always a paramount concern when making a sci-fi/fantasy film: you can have things that violate real natural law, just make sure it's consistent.

The film also tries to convey that Violence Is Wrong through the struggles of Exeter's people. It's a noble sentiment, and they broach the subject in an unconventional way, but it's delivered with far too heavy a hand, and somehow side-steps any concerns about nuclear power being involved with it. That might not seem to odd for the time, but keep in mind this was not long after the atomic bombs were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The resulting message becomes mired in technobabble and loses any real impact.

Despite the slightly above-average quality of this film, it's still better to see it through the filter of "MST3K: The Movie." It's not a horrible film, but it's good to know that you're not the only watching it that thinks it's just silly. 5 out of 10.
5 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Eeeeek!
BumpyRide5 October 2004
This was the Star Wars of the 1950's. What movie are these people watching when they say there is no story? This is great escapist fun, filled with flying saucers, aliens, monsters and explosions! Some movies are just meant to be viewed *surprise* as entertainment! Kick back, turn off your brain, relax and watch a fun movie and be entertained by the lumbering bug eyed monsters! Sure, Rex Reason (cool name) is a walking totem pole, and Faith sure does scream a lot, but that's what women did in the 50's when they were being carried away by a scary monster. The effects are pretty good for its time, and the whole picture is a great time capsule about where we were mid-century when space was unexplored, and the flying saucer craze was still going on.
69 out of 81 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great Final Act
TheRedDeath302 August 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Your opinion of this movie is going to depend greatly on your opinion of this genre, in general. If you are a new explorer to the histories of sci-fi who may like movies like ALIEN and you've heard that this movie had some influence on it and you're her to explore, then beware that you have to have some appreciation for the era of film that this movie comes from. There are laughable effects, bad acting and outlandish plots aplenty.

There are those vehement defenders of movies like this who are seething at any condemnation of this movie. This is a science fiction film classic and should be treated with reverence. Yes, I understand that, too, but appreciating a Model T Ford doesn't mean I want to drive it to work each day. It's okay to admit that the modern viewer will find some parts of this movie to be amusing reminders of a simpler era.

The plot centers around a scientist, who has a very high opinion of himself, played by an actor who I would guess had a similarly high opinion of himself in real life. One day he has a mysterious plane "accident" followed by the arrival of strange and unexplained mechanical parts. The man does what any scientist/ jet pilot/ genius would do and goes along for the ride. This leads to the creation of the world's largest television set, which only gets one channel. It's overgrown oompa loompas inviting our scientist hero into a plot to gather the world's brightest and create peace on earth. Naturally, our hero doesn't question this peaceful intent even when their giant boob tube is revealed to come equipped with death rays and a self- destruct mode.

The scientist abandons his assistant in a dramatic goodbye scene to embark on a perilous journey to...Georgia. It's here where he encounters a former one night stand and the plot is exposed to be a lie. Of course, the real goal of the aliens is the same as every other movie from this era, to invade Earth. Eventually, we get to see their planet Metaluna, which is a devastated looking place full of hideous mutants. It is these final moments that, for me, are the real draw of this movie.

I'm having a little bit of fun with the plot, but I'm also a fan of these films and expect to have a little fun with it. The first hour of the film could have used a little bit more work in the editing room as the pace slows at times. It's a plot typical of the 50s sci-fi shockers of this time, with elaborate and, sometimes, silly plot points. The acting, especially from our male lead, is very indicative of its' time. There are some decent effects shots for a a drive-in cheapie, though. The death rays still look pretty good and the chase scene in the station wagon looks better than a lot of movies from this same era can claim.

The real draw, as stated, is that final act on Metaluna. This is a desolate planet, full of steaming holes, dark caves and ominous red lighting. Admittedly, it shows its' age some, but it still looks like a terrifying place that I don't want to visit all these years later. You can draw a line from this movie to something like PLANET OF THE VAMPIRES and, eventually, ALIEN. In the years to follow, the real star of this movie has become the mutants, a brilliant creature design, who's image has now become part of the iconic Universal Monsters lineup and is typically included in any toy line or marketing. The legs didn't work and they had to use pants for the monsters, but even with this limitation, these mutants may just be the first truly terrifying aliens ever put onto the screen. The brilliant blue colors and crab-like hands, with those bulbous heads and black eyes go even further towards establishing this movie's rightful place in movie lore and history.

It's going to be a little slow for most viewers today, but if you're a fan of classic film, then this is well worth the time.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Classic
NerdBat14 December 2017
This movie is good but its kinda back and forth. Plot starts off great and all, scientist is recruited by forces in need of his intelligence. Though I will make one good point...the background art and the story line are absolutely wonderful, a great example of classic science fiction. It's one of those movies that has your imagination going on for hours after the film ends. Only thing I found irritating though was, of course you would think the main purpose of the film is to focus on the Metaluna Mutant monster. As the film goes on, you realize they do not mean a mutation when they call it a mutant, but rather a giant species of insect similar to earth's ants. They breed them as slaves, sort of like the classic film "the Mole people". I liked it, but I wish we had more Mutant danger!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed