West of Zanzibar (1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Moving Past Trader Horn
boblipton19 April 2019
A tribe in East Africa has moved from their old areas, which has dried up and is no longer suitable for farming, down to the lowlands near Mombasa. Some of the young men finding that killing elephants illegally and selling their ivory is a way to get ahead in rapidly changing East Africa. Anthony Steele, on official leave from his job working with the natives, tries to track down those who really profit from the trade, with the reluctant urging of his wife, Sheila Sim.

It's a late colonial era view of East Africa, amidst which is set one of those tracking-down-the-smugglers stories that was a fixture of British crime drama. However, this Ealing production has moved on a bit from TRADER HORN, and the natives are human, particularly Edric Connor as the chief, and so is the villain of the piece -- Martin Benson, playing a native lawyer, a graduate of the Sorbonne, who lectures Steele on England's industrial revolution and angrily congratulates him on his naive good will.

This being a movie set in Africa, the movie can shift at any moment from an indoor courtroom to documentary footage, showing the most dangerous animals in Africa -- hippopotami -- or the markets of Zanzibar, wart hogs and elephants at a watering hole, native fishermen using suckerfish to catch sea turtles, or a native fishing festival. The director is Harry Watt, whose filmography indicates he was happier filming documentaries than story films.

Still, it's a well-told if typical story, set in an exotic location, and if its attitudes are not those we espouse today, there are some bright moments that survive well.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
West of Ealing.
morrison-dylan-fan21 August 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Taking a look at IMDb's page for British movies from 1954,I was shocked to discover that the year featured one of the few sequels that Ealing studios ever made,which led to me excitingly getting ready to go west of Ealing.

The plot:

Suffering from a terrible drought,an African tribe called the Galana decide to move to Mombasa.With there being little money around,some of the Galana decide to work for an underground gangster,by killing the local elephants,and taking their Ivory.Catching some of the Galana in their latest Ivory hunt,games warden (and friend of the Galana tribe) Bob Payton gets set to take them to the police.Talking to the tribal leader,Payton discovers that the young Galana's are working for a major gangster,which leads to Payton deciding that he will not take the Galana's in,and instead go after the big game.

View on the film:

For this sequel from Ealing Studios,the screenplay by co-writer/ (along with Jack Whittingham and Max Catto) director Harry Watt features a rather peculiar contradiction,with the writers focusing on the daily routine of the Galana tribe on their own, (in un- subtitled scenes) but using Bob Payton (played by a good,stiff upper lip Anthony Steel)to show that only an "outsider" is able to handle serious matters during the regions colonialist era.Whilst the film at first appears to be set up for a wild adventure,the writers never allow the potential edge of the seat action in Payton's mission to set off,which leads to the title feeling incredibly dry.

Despite the use of stock footage and some poor back projection dampening things a bit,director Harry Watt shows a real eye for sweeping wide shots which allow for the natural beauty of the location to shine as the main star feature of the film,as Ealing Studios heads to the west of Zanzibar.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
What Went Around, Is Still Going Around!
spookyrat17 January 2019
West of Zanzibar is a real historical oddity. Besides being the only sequel that Ealing Studios ever produced, the film does highlight true to life conservation and social issues that still impact our contemporary world some 65 years later. It's just a pity that in searching for solutions to these issues, it's frequently inferred that the white colonial masters often have the best ideas, whilst playing down past colonial involvement which may have led to the problems beginning.

I have no idea why these Bob Payton yarns were so popular at the time. It can't have been the magnetic charisma of Anthony Steel, the actor playing the game warden character. He simply doesn't have any. Neither does he have any chemistry whatsoever with his onscreen wife, Mary. He also manages to have his acting pants pulled down, by Edric O'Connor, who plays Ushingo, the chief of the local Galana tribe. O'Connor is quite exceptional in the role and clearly was no amateur performer.

The dramatic content focusses on illegal ivory poaching and smuggling (the I suspect, real life footage of an elephant being hunted and killed for its tusks is jarring) which as mentioned earlier still plagues our world and especially the elephant populations of the planet. A sub-story deals with the Galana's tribal lands being affected by soil erosion, with the resulting effect of younger tribal members drifting off towards the city and both its attractions and associated social problems.

Harry Watt, a regular Ealing director, specialised in both raising socially aware issues in his films, whilst making said films overseas. I direct interested readers towards his 1959 offering made in Australia, The Siege of Pinchgut, which is definitely NOT your typical crooks versus cops siege movie.

In WOZ, Watt is less successful in laying down a coherent narrative and sustaining a pacy delivery supplemented by a good deal of suspense. Things do pick up in the third act, where I found the constant back projections and use of inserted documentary stock footage, rather entertaining, but probably not for the right reasons. It was also amusing watching Mary Payton thundering through the African plain lands punishing this ancient 4 wheel drive truck, come personnel carrier.

This is by no means a flawless film. But Watt and his script writers, obviously had a handle on some of the big issues affecting the African continent in the 50's. Come the second decade of the 21st century and folks, they still haven't been resolved.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A solid adventure yarn.
searchanddestroy-111 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
First, don't confound it with the Tod Browning feature, a silent one, starring the great Lon Chaney. This movie is British and directed by the interesting Harry Watt, who gave us this kind of exotic features, and in a semi documentary style. See for instance, WHERE NO VULTURES FLY, or SIEGE OF PICHGUT. Of course British movie industry was very used to adventures stories, and this till the early sixties. We can analyze that as a sort of reflection of the colonialist history of United Kingdom. That's what I think. And after the fifties we saw the birth of the "Kitchen Sink" way of filming, with such directors as Tony Richardson, Bryan Forbes, Lindsay Anderson and Karel Reisz. The DNA of other film makers like Ken Loach,; the digging into the major social problems of the usual population. But that's another comment. This was not for the same kind of audience.

Back to this film, it is a very good time waster for those who like old fashion movies that we saw in childhood. We can think of KING SOLOMON'S MINES. Ivory hunters who have to fight against natives tribes. Nothing special but worth watching.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Worth seeing, despite important faults!
JohnHowardReid9 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
An Ealing Studios-Schlesinger Production. London trade show: April 1954. New York opening: 17 January 1955 (at the World). U.S. release through Universal: January 1955. U.K. release through General Film Distributors: 19 April 1954. Australian release through British Empire Films: 17 June 1955. 8,506 feet. 94 minutes. Cut to 91 minutes in Australia.

SYNOPSIS: When Bob Payton discovers that the Galanas, a tribe he has long befriended, are being forced by soil erosion to move from the area which has been their home for many years, he urges their Chief Ushingo to lead them up into the hills. There, he says, they will find fresh and fertile soil which will give them their living and where they can continue to live their old lives in peace and happiness.

But the young men of the tribe favor the attractions of Mombasa which to them represent a new and exciting civilization and way of life. Payton knows that this would be fatal, that such a move would place these simple folk in the way of many irresistible temptations not the least of these being the activities of the large-scale ivory smugglers operating in Mombasa and the plausible offers of cheap city slickers who would quickly corrupt the new settlers.

A vote is taken and the decision made to go to Mombasa.

COMMENT: Bad dialogue and poor acting by the principals do not wholly impair one's interest in this semi-documentary, directed with his usual occasional felicity of visual image by Harry Watt. Photographed in Technicolor by Paul Beeson.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"I can't see how there are any elephants left; every second shop seems to be an ivory dealer!"
richardchatten22 January 2022
Cannily scheduled during the chilly month of January by Talking Pictures, the second of Harry Watt's two Technicolor tours of the Dark Continent boasts excellent photography of the local wildlife fairly well integrated into the action (although described in the credits as made at Ealing Studios).

The narrator describes at the outset that the 'white gold' of smuggled ivory has taken the place of the 'black gold' of slavery; which at least was a step in the right direction.

But the conflict of interests between European tree-huggers and black 'smugglers' continues to worry away today.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Dull And Slow
malcolmgsw4 March 2015
At times it is difficult to make out if this film is supposed to be a dramatic narrative film or a glorified travelogue.Since this was the pre jet age,not many people could journey to Africa and see these sights for themselves.They could view them in black and white on their 12 inch TV screens but that was it.So the antics of the dung beetle seem to supplant the importance of moving the plot onwards.In the cinema the audience had to suffer in silence whereas we can now happily fast forward.the plot is about ivory poaching,apparently as bad then as it is now.Anthony Steel plays the game warden and seems to be carved out of ivory himself.Sylvia Simm seems to have a different costume for every scene.Michael Balcon's Ealing only had 2 years remaining,and watching lame efforts like this ,it is not very surprising.
3 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Ivory traders
jimjamjonny396 February 2023
You can understand why certain illegal ivory hunters do this job. They're poor and need to survive. Only problem is that the people paying them to murder the elephants are giving them a pittance and are making huge profits for themselves. It's amazing to think that Africa's elephant population from 26 million elephants in 1800 to fewer than one million today. Elephant tusks from Africa average about 2 metres in length and weigh over 20 kg.

The buyers of ivory express genuine concerns about cruelty towards animals, however, less than one-third of them believe that elephants are very endangered.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Stopping the evil of ivory poaching.
mark.waltz29 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
With their lands dying and the absence of practically all vegetation, an African tribe is forced to move to a more fertile land, of course the white man is responsible for telling them where they need to go, and an election utilizing beans confirmed that. The well meaning Anthony Steel and his even more well mraninc wife (Sheila Sim) add the chief of this tribe and trying to stop his people from becoming involved in Ivory poaching, something that results and rampant crime and more importantly to the chief, The disappearance of Hospitality, an aspect of his tribe that the chief finds the most distressing. Members of the tribe are kidnapped find men involved in the poaching, and the chief along with steel and his wife set out to help him find them.

An exciting British adventure movie filmed on location, this features a nice film debut for Juma, the very personable young native from Zanzibar who befriends Steel's son, and briefly aides him in his efforts to get information on the poachers, also coin of course. Juma, the Sabu of the mid 50's, only made four films, but his screen charisma is undeniable. There's plenty of natural Wildlife to keep the family entertained along with the gorgeous photography and non-stop action. Edric Connor stands out in the cast as the very noble chief who risks his life time and time again for his people and his white friends. One thing though. For a film that is about Ivory poaching, very few elephants are shown.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed