User Reviews

Ian Carmichael stars as Willie Frith, hapless eldest son of a family of crooks, who finally gets lucky snaffling a suitcase of pound notes, only to find they're forged, with the same number on each. Then his problems begin.

There is no doubt that Carmichael was embarrassed about his participation in this film: in his autobiography he went as far to record that he wished that Rank had destroyed all the prints. He's certainly acutely miscast. Though he specialised in portraying educated, bumbling and unworldly young men, Willie is mainly just gormless, an image compounded by the decision to give him a 'Teddy Boy' hairstyle, which only makes him look ridiculous. Then there's the scene in the swish nightclub, where he makes an exhibition of himself with his pockets loaded with coins, and unseemly behaviour after swigging too much liquid in a doomed effort to get rid of some of the notes. This is firmly in Norman Wisdom territory, and the star no doubt found it all a bit beneath him.

The glamorous Belinda Lee is perhaps a bit too refined as the barmaid in a role apparently turned down by Diana Dors, then trying to establish herself as a serious actress, but it's doubtful that many male viewers had any complaints. She gives a good performance despite the uneven script that portrays her character as sympathetic in one scene, and then a bit of an opportunist in the next. It seems a pity that Bryan Forbes' attempts to improve the writing were dismissed out of hand. I thought Robert Helpmann was a piece of inspired and original casting as the gang leader.

The mistake with Carmichael apart, this is not quite the disaster that some originally claimed and has some amusing moments throughout. In many ways it's a typical British comedy of its time.

Out of Pinewood Studios, The Big Money is directed by John Paddy Carstairs and written by John Baines. It stats Ian Carmichael, Belinda Lee, Robert Helpmann, James Hayter, Kathleen, Harrison and George Coulouris. Music is by Van Phillips and cinematography by Jack Cox. It is a VistaVision/Technicolor production.

When bumbling thief Willie Frith (Carmichael) steals a suitcase from a clergyman, he gets far more than he bargained for. Disowned by star and creators, and left on the shelf for years by the studio, it's safe to say that The Big Money at best is an awkward comedy. It's not bad exactly, in fact there's enough comedy here for those familiar with - and entertained by - British comedy slapstick pics of years gone by. The problem is a poor script that leaves a fine cast wasted.

The premise is a good one, eldest son from a family of crooks is incompetent and desperately wants to not only make the family proud, but also to make it big himself. The latter of which he sees as a way of attracting the opposite sex, notably the blonde siren behind the bar of The Red Dragon. Once he secures what he thinks is his life changing steal, he is thrust into mishap after mishap, all while some unsavoury types get on his trail. What transpires is a gently amusing comedy, but in truth that's not enough to make this a must - seek - out pic for those wishing to blow the blues away. Nice to see Royal Ascot feature though, that is if you like horse racing mind... 5/10

Ian Carmichael comes from a respectable family -- father James Hayter has never been caught, although he has been a pickpocket all his life. Carmichael, however, dreams of the big money, and one day, pursuing his trade of snatching unattended baggage, he achieves his dream, in a suitcase full of small notes. He displays them proudly to his family, but Hayter points out they all have the same serial numbers, obvious forgeries, and that's a specialist's job. Carmichael doesn't care. He's going to enjoy them, one pound at a time, so he's kicked out, despite the protests of his mother, Kathleen Harrison.

Carmichael falls for pub assistant Belinda Lee, who is much taken by the money he throws away; she has no problem spending the money, and Carmichael is too besotted to care. He also has Robert Helpmann, ringleader of the counterfeit gang on his trail.

It's a rare misfire by dependable director John Paddy Carstairs. Carmichael spends his time split evenly between being an idiot and jittering, and Miss Lee is stupid and predatory. I grew tired of the pair of them well before the movie's 85 minutes were up. With the only non-idiot, non-money obsessed character being Hayter, there wasn't much fun here. Apparently the producers agreed. It sat on a shelf for two years, until the Boultings made Carmichael a star with PRIVATE'S PROGRESS.

With George Coulouris, Renee Houston, Jill Ireland and Leslie Phillips.

I've just attended 'Ian Carmichael in Conversation' at the National Film Theatre in London (8 Dec 02). He was very wary of discussing this film, describing it as 'a mistake'. He said that he and Bryan Forbes had attempted to rewrite the script, but this was discarded. According to Mr Carmichael, the film was put away as unreleasable for five years, when another director thought that he could salvage footage of a race meeting at Ascot for insertion into a Norman Wisdom picture. He told Rank that with a bit of work, he could make it releasable - and there it is.

In the 1950s Rank,along with other film producers,were trying to find ways to attract audiences back to the cinema.Having fallen out with Fox over Cinemascope,Rank turned to the short lived Vistavision,to add to Technicolour to attract customers.The fact that this could not disguise the poverty of the script didn't escape them and the film was shelved for 2 years.The best scenes are those at the beginning featuring Carmichael,Harrison and Hayter.After that the film is on a downward spiral.Nearly every actor with a major part is miscast.Carmichael is clearly unsuited to the part.For some reason his hair is made up with a teddyboys quiff.The part would more suit someone like Brian Rix.Diana Dors would certainly have made more of the part than Belinda Lee.Alas Robert Helpmann is just awful as the chief of the gang and would have been better played by Sid James.The climax in the hotel is about as unfunny as you can get.No wonder Carmichael didn't want to discuss it.At a time when he was a rising star of cinema this film could have put him back years.

An English comedy made 64 years ago, still valid today in 2020, which is still funny. There are many successful scenes and Belinda Lee looks splendid. John Paddy Carstairs, the same one who made sparkling comedies with the super funny Norman Wisdom, managed to be funny with this film too, at least it made me laugh. What a pity that Belinda Lee died so young, at only 25 years old!

Enough has been said by previous reviewers about this film, but all I have to add is that this is one of the earliest film appearances I have seen of the lovely Jill Ireland, and she was one of a few actresses who were extremely pretty in their younger days who became more beautiful the older they got. It was so sad that she passed away so young at 54.

An oddly coiffed Ian Carmichael got off to a false start in leading roles in this Technicolor & CinemaScope variation on 'Brewster's Millions', which fortunately for him was still sitting on the shelf when he made 'Lucky Jim'.

It was the only colour film shot by Hitchcock's regular cameraman of the thirties Jack Cox and the vivid hues engage the attention throughout (especially Renee Houston's flaming red hair) in a cynical subject which portrays fifties London as as full of con men, pickpockets, high maintenance blondes and wealthy Arabs able to afford forty-guinea-a-day hotel suites as Samuel Fuller and Jean-Pierre Melville did for New York and Paris in black & white.

Norman Wisdom. His place is taken by Ian Carmichael. I can partly see why he might have been cast - the character here is, although a thief, a hapless and rather naive one - a frequent Ian Carmichael character who struggled to get the girl. But after a promising start, the hokum into which the film descends at the end is much more Normam Wisdom. He always played a hapless clumsy character who often pursued - and ended receiving the attention and love of an impossibly beautiful dream girl (here played by Belinda Lee.

The film would been better with Norman Wisdom providing not just haplessness but also his renowned comedy skills which always uplifted hokum.

Robert Helpman is rather good as the gang leader/fake clergyman Apart from this the colour is excellent (Technicolor) and it does provide a glimpse of 1956 hotel extreme luxury - at least the room decor and bathroom, as well as a vision of an up-market night club. An excellent cast of familiar character actors many of whom had starred in other films, it at least held the interest throughout and was agreeable to watch.

The actors appear to be having fun in this British comedy and this viewer did as well.

Ian Carmichael is the black sheep of a family of thieves (father James Hayter, mother Kathleen Harrison, sister Jill Ireland). One day he heists a briefcase from a dodgy clergyman (Robert Helpmann) which is full of pound notes. Unfortunately they all have the same serial number! Carmichael is seduced by "the big money" and starts passing the counterfits, one bill at a time. Much of his need for money is to impress a pretty barmaid (Belinda Lee) at his local pub. She dreams of the millionaire who will come and give her the good life. This keeps the plot going as Carmichael has to find new ways to pass more and more counterfits, one at a time, and impressing his girl at a fancy nightclub and the Ascot races. Along the way two con-men (George Coulouris and Michael Brennan) try to con Carmichael. Unfortunately Carmichael can't pass the counterfits fast enough to keep up with Lee's aspirations, we're now up to a mink coat, so she helps herself to some of the counterfits. I'm afraid to say that giving the fur shop four hundred notes with the same serial number does attract the attention of the police. Obviously the clergyman and his henchman have also been seeking whoever has stolen his briefcase.

Almost without exception the actors seem to be having fun. Hayter and Harrison relish their parts as straight laced thieves (although the young Ireland has nothing to do but look lovely). Helpmann, more noted in ballet than films, is an incisive villain with a dash of the devil. Coulouris and Brennan, trying to get Carmichael's attention to their scam while he would rather moon over Lee, are delightful. Lee herself, amply displaying why she was a pin-up of the 50's, handles the transition from good girl, to temporarily seduced by wealth back to good girl with charm. Carmichael easily handles many physical bits of comedy with his usual success. Although it did take me a while to accept his performance because I'm so used to seeing him as an upper class twit rather than lower class thief.

The film is well paced by the director (John Paddy Carstairs) and technical credits, including color photography, are fine.

I'm surprised that I had not seen this film before and suspect that ownership or other commercial factors may have prevented it from being included in the movie packages being sold to television in North America. That would be the only reason why this undiscovered film is not more fully appreciated. Certainly the actors and film makers have given us every reason to appreciate this film.