Horse (1970) Poster

(1970)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Cartel Vs. Gabin: Poor Cartel!
boblipton3 May 2021
When he discovers his grandson, Marx Porel, has two hundred milion francs worth of heroin, Jean Gabin destroys it. When the criminal for whom Porel has been holding it comes and demands the drugs and the man, and threaten his family and farm. Gabin shoots him, hides the body, sinks the crook's car in the swamp and sticks his grandson in the potato cellar. His cattle are stampeded and killed, his barn is burnt. Gabin gives his orders but no explanation to his family and workers, despite the police taking an interest.

This being a Gabin film, I was never in any doubt as to how it would turn out. Indeed, the idea of a multi-billion dollar mob of criminals going against Gabin is soberly funny. Gabin is quite believable as the stiff-necked, autocratic proprietor of a family farm in Calvados, just as he is in everything.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another well made French film
innperu24 March 2021
Wonderful film with wonderful actors and great story plus Gabin is the greatest actor I dont understand some rather low scoring and sorry its not Rambo but Hollywood has copied many ideas from European films
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Forgotten Gem of the French Gangster Genre
mben11126 March 2017
Ever the tough guy, Jean Gabin plays a steely farm owner who runs a strict operation. When his grandson becomes involved with dangerous criminals, the family farm becomes a battleground. Gabin defends his home from the gangsters using equally brutal measures and traps. In addition to the criminals, the police begin to look in on the farm and the numerous deaths. Not Gabin's most complex performance, nor the most well constructed gangster flick, La Horse is still a satisfying, bloody thriller which is plenty fun worth looking for.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hero and heroin
dbdumonteil9 June 2005
This one was the first of a series of "rural" thrillers which began to appear in the first part of the seventies.We can also mention "la veuve Couderc" "les granges brûlées" and mainly "l'affaire Dominici",a true story which also featured Gabin,in a part very similar to the one he played in "la horse" .

The clannishness in a rural milieu was not new in 1971: Becker's great "Goupi Mains Rouges" is the granddaddy of "la horse" .Granier-Deferre was never looked upon as an auteur and however his movie has stood the test of time quite well.It's a short movie (about 85 min) and the audience is never bored.Gabin is excellent in this part of a grumpy die-hard farmer.He rules over his family and no one dares to contradict him.He lives in a world that no longer exists but he is not prepared to accept another one,so the others must follow.He never contradicts himself,and even if it's difficult to side with him,because taking the law into your hands is hard to swallow for a normal human being,one cannot deny Gabin's behavior its internal logic. The villains -traffickers in drugs- are cardboard characters but it does not matter,cause it's Gabin's one man show.When he learns his grandson is involved in this dirty business,he sees red: no one in his family has already been arrested ,and his family is sacred,the only way of getting out of this mess is striking back.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Solid Gabin in weak flick
adrianovasconcelos21 November 2020
Weak direction, sloppy photography, a script with more holes than Swiss cheese, and some rampant animal cruelty all make LA HORSE a mediocre and immediately forgettable flick.

An aging Gabin - solid performance, full of menacing looks - runs his farm and family with a shotgun and he thinks nothing of blasting away the gang of drug runners, and he keeps mum to police, who - thankfully - are not very persistent in their investigation.

Happy ending after plenty of corpses. Buy it at your peril!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Stern Gabin the patriach
surfisfun26 February 2022
I like the 70s rural french feel.

Gabin still as mojo.

I tought the photography was good for what it is.

Any review under 5 are too harsh.

Recommended.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An old family man
mihaiatanasie22 April 2011
I had not known this film before, I ran into a photo of a helicopter which was a capture from it and I became curious. I am very happy I have seen this movie, it is one of the best I could see these last months. It is that kind of story of a very strong character, a man who feels responsible for his family and does whatever he can to keep the honor intact. Even though, at first, he thinks he can do it all by himself, he soon discovers that if one wants to help one's family, one needs the family's help. The main character, that of Jean Gabin, is the image of the old French farmer and landowner, who is subjected to his land and rules his home like a dictator. No one dares to talk back to him, or, if any does, the old man knows how to shut his mouth. And when a danger appears that threatens the family, he does not hesitate for a second to react radically. When the danger becomes even greater, Maurice uses the help of his sons-in-law, and I think this is the moment they finally become family. The last one who proves to be a member of the family will be Henri; found in his cellar by the police, he finds the exact words and action that discharge him and his grandpa in the eyes of the law, and in the last scene of the film, he accepts his status of a farmer, by accompanying his old men to work. All in all, I liked this film very much and I will recommend it to my friends.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An underseen gem
millerian-5520 August 2022
A movie about a very simple but strong-minded man. Gabin is excellent in the lead role, as your typical annoyed, but sort of solemn old man who only cares about his duty to protect his family. The movie really does a great job developing and visually presenting his relationship with his children and grandchildren, he's in charge, and whatever he says, goes.

I love when a character can rule and command people simply through his mannerisms and the way he presents himself. Despite having decades on most of his family, and even the drug smugglers he finds himself in battle with, he always manages to be intimidating to them through sheer resilience and presence.

The way the movie is structured is handled very well, we start out with a crime thriller-esque plot where he takes turns fighting this drug smuggling gang, and the movie switches gears and sort of becomes a legal or investigative movie where we see how his family has been instructed to act in the face of law enforcement (don't say anything). And despite having those elements, the movie still manages to have a wonderful sense of humor, sometimes very dark, but mostly just situational humor that's very well done. And while it manages to be tense throughout, the comedy is wonderfully woven in, where it never feels phony or stale.

In a lot of ways, this film feels almost like an old-timey Western, and John Wayne being in Jean Gabin's role wouldn't be that shocking, but what this movie does differently is that it takes the 70s era realism and adds it to a very Western-esque scenario and plot to create something that is incredibly engaging. And like many Westerns, I really loved how the movie was presented and framed in its cinematography, with lots of wide shots with beautiful blocking, through simplicity. There's a shot after the drug smugglers attack his cows with their truck, and at the end of that scene is a beautiful shot of a dead cow in the foreground and the truck leaving in the background, showing the damage they left behind.

After watching a lot of Hollywood or American movies recently, I've noticed that I've grown tired of the lack of genuine nature and artificiality in these movies. This is why watching this movie was so refreshing, every element of this movie feels real and genuine, and the disturbing stuff that happens is genuinely shocking because it looks and probably is, real.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not much here, except for the score
vostf9 October 2012
The score is wonderfully out of place here and it is the only thing that didn't sink deep into oblivion. So you can skip the movie and find the score by Serge Gainsbourg (and Jean-Claude Vannier), even experience the contrast with images by watching the 3min opening credits on YouTube.

At 76min (i.e. 73min without the credits sequence) the movie has the appropriate rhythm, which is rather slow, in accordance with life at the farm. The story is really simple, and actually everything and everybody is quite simple in La Horse. Even simplistic. In the end you feel that the story doesn't amount to much and that it sides with the rural family law that is very close to Mafia ethics or to the vigilante movies that will flourish during the 70s. Frankly this is not the kind of conclusion that I find satisfying; at least they could have closed the movie on the daughter's face.
8 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
LA HORSE (DIDIER BECU)
Didier-Becu18 October 2003
"La horse" is the kind of movie no one mentions but it is definitely one you must have seen as it's superb! We are put in some French village at where everybody knows everyone and at where we find a farmer's family that's been led by the dictatorial Jean Gabin who only believes in one word "work". The man's dream got totally splattered when one of his sons is involved in drug traffic and brings the white powder to the farm. Gabin thinks that throwing it away solves all problems but of course the mob wants their stuff back... What then follows is a superb exciting piece of a movie in where the contrasts between the old French and the new ones are explored in great 70's cinematographic arts. Superb movies that is over before you realize it. Also musical score by the godlike Serge Gainsbourg!
16 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Bottom of the barrel.
brogmiller10 November 2021
During a career that lasted almost fifty years the great Gabin made nigh on a hundred films. Considering this output there weren't that many duds but this one is absolutely atrocious. A deeply unpleasant opus that panders to the baser instincts, lumbered with a moronic script, garish colour and a terminally irritating score by Serge Gainsbourg that bursts in at the most inopportune moments.

Suffice to say Monsieur Gabin is riveting but apart from Christian Barbier as one of his sons in-law and Pierre Dux as a judge, the rest of the cast is strictly 'B'.

It beggars belief that Pierre Granier-Deferre who gave us 'La Veuve Couderc', 'Le Chat' 'Le Train' and 'L' Etoile du Nord' could have been responsible for this unadulterated trash.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hoodlums vs peasants
searchanddestroy-119 January 2023
That's a movie where Jean Gabin played a character very close to his real life, because the great French actor as a peasant, besides studios lots, this was his life, his DNA, his purpose. He made movies only to buy lands and take care of his farm, his horses, his cattle. So, you see, this role was made for him. For L'AFFAIRE DOMINICI, it will be more or less the same. The family head among peasants, but of course in another formula. Here a bunch of hoodlums, drug traffic high scale gangsters, are dealing with ordinary but die hard peasants. This emphasizes on the contrast between those urban villains and the good countryside men. Typical French crime film form the late sixties. A cult film for Gabin fans. And the music score is fabulous too.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed