The Judge and Jake Wyler (TV Movie 1972) Poster

(1972 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Sort of like "Barnaby Jones" with a sex change.
planktonrules21 January 2017
The idea for this film is very much like the TV show "Barnaby Jones". You have an elderly private investigator who employs a younger guy to do pretty much all the work! So, just like Jedidiah who did all the real investigating and regularly got his butt kicked in the TV show, in this case Jake Wade (Doug McClure) has these duties while his boss, the Judge (Bette Davis) mostly stayed at her desk making phone calls. Not a bad set-up for the boss! The only big difference is that Jake is an ex-con and you would think, even with the Judge's help, he'd never get a license to do this sort of work post-prison!

The case in this episode concerns a guy whose death has been ruled a suicide. His daughter (Joan Van Ark) employs the private detective agency to find out whether he actually might have been murdered. Considering that several people beat up Jake or threaten him, it sure looks as if something sinister is afoot.

Apart from laughing because Davis' character HATES cigarette smoke and can't be around it (she was a HUGE smoker in real life), this is a decent but not especially great made for TV detective show. Never dull but also never so good you wish they'd turned this into a TV series.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A potential TV series for Bette that never went anywhere past a movie of the week.
mark.waltz8 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
It is obvious to me that as Bette Davis got older, she enjoyed little bits of camp here and there in her films, knowing that her movies would continue to be watched, not only for their excellence, but their silliness, long after she was gone. For the last 25 years of her career, she appeared mainly on TV in a variety of parts, from anthology shows of the 1950's and 60's, to TV movies like this that dominated the weekday airwaves of the 1970's. Audiences will laugh hysterically upon hearing the life-long chain smoking Bette admonish private detective Doug McClure for smoking in her presence as "any type of smoke has a bad effect on her health". She's a retired, recluse judge, a widow who continues to stick her nose into local mysteries, and here, the mystery surrounds the murder of a wealthy industrialist whose daughter (Joan Van Ark) has been disowned because of her rebelliousness and the presence of a greedy, second wife. McClure, as the lead detective of Bette's private investigative agency, often squabbles with Davis over his methods, having once been in jail and only able to do detective work on the side. Davis is never seen outside of her character's house, so she doesn't get to do a lot of moving around, and many of her scenes are on the phone, so other than that clipped voice delivering some campy lines, she really isn't involved all that much in the action, except when one of the suspects (Gary Conway) breaks into her home to threaten her.

"The Dark Prince of Genoa City" (Eric Braeden) is seen here sans mustache as an Algerian business tycoon who is wanted in questioning by McClure for Van Ark's father's death, and like "The Young and the Restless's" Victor Newman, he is a commanding character, always threatening his enemies, yet charming when he needs to be, especially with Van Ark. (The two were reunited several decades later when Van Ark joined "Y&R" for a short stint as the original Gloria Fisher.) Most of the action is given to McClure who follows the various suspects around, questions each one, and even gets chased around when an unseen person in a car tries to mow both him and Braeden down in a children's park as a Humpty Dumpty cutout is zoomed in on, seen visibly over a children's swing set. Another tense scene has McClure confronting the dead man's partner (Kent Smith) over an embezzlement charge as Smith shoots at targets in his mansion's back yard. There are too many twists and turns in the film's last 15 minutes so you might wonder who the real killer was unless you pay very close attention. But some clever dialog involving a fake grenade brings on some humor with one of the suspects, and of course, Davis gets in the last word. Too bad she had no more words as this character; She would have been a great addition to the NBC "Mystery Movie" series that dominated Sunday nights in the 1970's.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Bette Davis detests cigarettes?
bkoganbing30 May 2017
The Judge And Jake Wyler finds Bette Davis and Doug McClure respectively in the title roles in this made for TV film that looked an awful lot like a TV pilot. In fact a year later this same film was redone with Lee Grant and Bob Cummings. It wasn't that good to warrant it.

Davis is a former judge who now runs a detective agency in which she employs former convicts and she has McClure, James McEachin, and Barbara Rhoades in her charge. As they are paroled to her she's essentially a slave master. But there certainly have been worse in that occupation.

The agency is employed in this story first by Kent Smith to get the goods on his cheating wife Lisabeth Hush and her boyfriend Gary Conway. But when Smith dies apparently by suicide daughter Joan Van Ark keeps on retaining Davis's firm.

Smith had more than domestic problems that would cause people to want to kill him. As you gather this was not suicide.

Clearly Davis was in this for her marquee value while McClure would have done the actual heavy lifting in this action series. Davis did look bored during the whole thing, possibly why the series wasn't picked up.

Bette's character was a Monk like hypochondriac who had an excessive fear of germs. And she detested cigarettes. I think the creator was having a little joke there.

Even second rate Bette Davis is better than most of the rest. But The Judge And Jake Wyler was all right, nothing more.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed