Osceola (1971) Poster

(1971)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Florida 1835
unbrokenmetal5 July 2008
"Osceola" takes us to Florida 1835 when the white farmers want complete control of the land, so sending the Seminole Indians to a reservation far away is planned - which leads to warfare. Chief Osceola (Gojko Mitic) unintentionally reminds me of Tarzan a lot: his main job is to rescue anybody in trouble, for example from a crocodile when crossing the river. The political tasks are mostly for Moore (Iurie Darie), a farmer who looks into the future when machines will be used instead of slave labor. His rich rival Raynes (Horst Schulze) is presented as a merciless racist capitalist who treats the black slaves badly and the Indians worse, whereas Moore even married an Indian girl - an obvious chunk of ideology you have to expect in a production from behind the iron curtain. This movie was shot in Cuba by an East German team (who had few other communist countries with palm trees to choose from, I guess). Director Petzold had also directed Mitic' two previous westerns "Tödlicher Irrtum" and "Weisse Wölfe". "Osceola" is a bit slow sometimes, too much singing and talking in between the action sequences, but it is interesting for its historical background, rather different from the usual Prairie Indians. Somebody gets a credit for "scientific advice" in the titles to point out is was well researched...
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Indians with blacks against planters or the Magnificent Goiko Mitic: part six
lyubitelfilmov26 October 2020
Western. A screen adaptation of the novel "Osceola: Leader of the Seminoles" by the famous English writer Thomas Mein Reed (which I have not read). The film was produced by the East German film studio DEFA, where the main role was again played by the famous Yugoslav actor, "Honored Indian of the Soviet Union", Gojko Mitic. The sixth picture out of twelve that I intend to see and revise. I watched this western in fits and starts, but I could fully appreciate it only now, and here's my brief opinion - Indians with blacks against planters. I will say right away that I did not notice the minuses in the picture, but there are some small comments that I will voice in a separate paragraph, but for now, let your humble servant tell you about the pluses of this western. So, here they are: 1. The story told - the picture tells about Osceola (the leader himself is a real historical figure), played by Goiko Mitic, who strives to live in peace with the pale-faced, but the insidious neighbor - the southern planter, intends to take away their native land from the Seminole for his own benefit. Added to this is the fact that runaway slaves find shelter on the lands of the tribe, so the planter intends to involve the army in this business, so that the Indians have no chance of victory. But Osceola is not alone in this battle, because he has a pale-faced friend who will provide any help. Several scenes, characters and a place of action were left here from the original source, otherwise it is a separate story, following in unison with the historical events that preceded the Second Seminole War. It perfectly reveals the theme of slavery, contempt of white people for blacks and redskins, pride, bragging, greed, deceit, the emerging contradictions within the United States itself, which in a few decades will lead to a bloody Civil War. And again, not all pale-faced people are presented in black tones, there are worthy people among them, although they are a minority. The script is replete with twists and turns if you're unfamiliar with the genre. The final turned out to be good, on the one hand, and tragic, on the other hand, because the struggle of the Indians with the regular army always ends in the same way. 2. Entourage - the atmosphere, costumes, scenery, all this perfectly conveys the spirit of this historical era, and allows the viewer to plunge into it headlong. The costumes and dwellings of the Seminole are very similar to the historical ones that have survived. The life and way of thinking of the Indians is shown very accurately, there are both supporters of peace and supporters of war, and everyone is right, no matter how paradoxical it sounds. The Plantation South is shown in all its colors: white planters, cruel overseers with whips, slave labor of blacks on plantations, escalating contradictions with the government in Washington, blatant contempt for all non-white people. 3. Chases, fights, shootouts - there are not so many of them here, within reason, although I would like more. These scenes are dynamic and can even cause a sinking heart in especially sensitive ones. Blood was delivered, but in small doses. 4. Music is far from being a masterpiece, and loses to "The Trail of the Falcon" and "White Wolves" unambiguously. I could not remember a single melody, but it will go within the framework of this unhurried western. A little about the main characters: 1. Osceola performed by Goiko Mitic - one of the leaders of the Seminole tribe, trying to place the planters with the help of the army to seize the native lands of the tribe. Acts boldly and effectively, doing good deeds along the way. And again, Goiko does all the tricks on his own, and he plays perfectly. Bravo Goiko! 2. Richard Moore performed by Yuri Darie - the owner of a sawmill, where free blacks work, and a friend of Osceola, who does not need the upcoming war. We despise in "high society" for our actions and views. Provides, to the best of his strength and capabilities, assistance to blacks and Indians. Yuri was convincing in this role. 3. William Reines performed by Horst Schulze is a white planter and a very wealthy and influential person who intends to get the lands of the Indians in order to satisfy his greedy ambitions, for which he does not disdain outright lies and intrigues. Horst this time played the role of not a good pale-faced, but a rich and influential villain, which was successful. Well done. Surprisingly, there were several logical miscalculations in the picture, which are visible to the naked eye, well, the scenes of fights, chases and shootings are now no longer able to surprise, little bird. Well, next time Goiko Mitic will again have to take up arms in order to save his tribe from being evicted by the US army. It will be in Tekumse. As a result, we have a good western with a great Goiko Mitic, a good script, excellent surroundings and great acting.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Needed more fine tuning
Horst_In_Translation28 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Osceola" is an East German film from 1971 and if you hear this and the somewhat exotic title, you probably already guess correctly that this is another GDR Indian movie starring the Eastern Winnetou Gojko Mitic. It plays in the first half of the 19th century, definitely an interesting era, but it also becomes obvious here once again that the script and story were just not good enough to come up with a convincing film overall. This hurts especially as this is not a short film at all, is closer to two hours than to 90 minutes. It's not really Mitic's fault. He does not shine particularly, but you can excuse that with the fact that the material he is given by the writer duo here is really generic and uninteresting for the most part. Costumes and landscapes are fine to watch, but this also results in this 45-year-old film being a case of style over substance. It needed major improvement in more than one area in order to turn out a success. This is especially disappointing as two writers (like I already said) and also two director worked on it here. And maybe also the best days of German western films were already over by the early 1970s. Anyway, I give it a thumbs-down. Watch something else instead.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed