The Wall (1983) Poster

(1983)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Hope strikes there, where Destiny cannot reach !
CihanVercan2 January 2009
When the moonlight reflected onto prison bars, they came together to pray for the same wishes. There was hope in their eyes while they were watching the crows fly. No matter what time of the day it was, they searched for the sky. Justice was the sun of infinity, and the sum of their tears; eventually it rose. Duvar had always inspired millions. It has a life enhancing impact for whoever looking for hope and justice. Considering that how so ever bad circumstances we're having at the present time, somewhere in the world there is always other people struggling against worse circumstances. Duvar is a prayer that receives an answer from God.

Produced, written and directed by Yılmaz Güney within his own personal experiences of capital offense, he dedicates Duvar to male teenagers aged 13 to 19 living behind the bars under diabolical treatments. These teenagers get barbaric corporal punishments, injurious harrows, tortures and sexual abuses just for taking the responsibility of their destiny on a wrong turn. Throughout the story we find them fighting for a piece of bread from the garbage trucks, a look of daylight from the rat holes, or a smart way of escaping from a periodic non-sense punishment. Despite whole the unbearable scenes of view, there is absolutely no melodrama, but the facts. Some of the scenes are full of very disturbing images, but at the same time very original and very successful camera shoots; like the scene at the women's ward where a pregnant woman gives birth to a child but with the actual happening of the baby getting out of mother's womb. The whole occurrence of the mother's genital organ opens wide enough to getting the baby out, without absolutely no medical assistance and the camera setting distance of a half feet away from the spot was as good and as bold as a Dogma 95 shoot. The version of the movie which I got to see over the internet was the actual uncut version. So, if anybody sees this movie rather than the Cannes film festival seen cut might not see this scene because of the ratings. Well, we've waited 17 years to see this movie in our theaters in Turkey just because it has been considered as a provocative work of art, at the time when it's been shot. This is an extra-ordinary epic like no other, so dashing and so truthful. Children act so heartfelt. The director Güney must have been devotedly attached to these children that, the communication between him and them have built up the most greatest successful acting no-named children of all time movie history. This is the one and the biggest power that connects us to this epic and to love it and to remember it whole our lives.

For the reason of revolutionary character of the director Yılmaz Güney, Duvar had been considered as a revolutionary film, which is actually not. It truly exposes the inequitable approaches against the teenagers at some of the prisons in 1980s' Turkey without touching no ideas or delivering no political views. It was a matter of humanity hiding the truth of torturing teenagers, while administering justice. Yılmaz Güney had exposed that with no perversion of truth. He made cinema to deliver its mission to show the public what needs to be known.
24 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent film on the prisons during military intervention in Turkey
ahmet-17 November 2000
Duvar is the last film of Yilmaz Guney. It was made in France under very bad conditions. But it is successful on describing the violence in prison without being too much 'political'. It's a striking movie, which nobody could stay indifferent to it.
41 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A gripping political film by Yilmaz Guney.. A must to see!
secilicel31 July 2007
Warning: Spoilers
"Duvar" is certainly my favorite Yilmaz Güney film after "Umut" (Hope). The director mainly tries to describe the prison conditions in Turkey after coup d'état in 1980. Being very political himself, he draws a dark picture of a Turkish prison where most people are stuck because of their political activities.

Here we see men, women and children living in different sections; but we are confronted with the tragic story of children, while the adults have to watch them anxiously behind the windows. In their attempt to change to another prison for better conditions; the children try petition, escape and mutiny. In return, they are faced with continuous beating, harassment and even death. In their section, there is never good food, enough bread or water for bathing. In the film, the only likable person is the guardian "Áli Emmi" (Tuncel Kurtiz), who gets his prize by being humiliated and getting fired at the end.

Güney's dark film shifts between (many) bad and (some) good experiences in the prison context, which makes keeps the audience always interested. He uses some interesting techniques and many references to the political context of early 80's Turkey, which makes the film gripping, especially for the contemporaries.
12 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
BEST REALISTICH MOVIE
bulutsoner812 December 2017
It was one of the best movie ever l seen.. in the movie all players (except Tuncel Kurtiz) are amateurs and its first time they see a camera. its inspire just with a word.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Exploiting a Need
itswe21 April 2014
Prisons, governments, authorities needs criticizing. The place where the film starts is awesome. But when it comes going down the road, it looks weird. It seems exploiting the political situation. At that time, the military government was bad. Expressing it is a service to humanity. However, creating hostility from it, is wrong as military authority. Each scene embodies a needling. For example, children are beaten, behind, the wife has been cheating on her husband, and they're sent to death sentence. Showing the Atatürk's words: Republic will glorify you. Immediately some kiddings about god, the nation and morality. They can do it all. All criticism is vital for living. Although, when you add them all together, it's not doing anything but hostility. Attacking something with art is ugly as crime. I wish, film told the story of teens struggle to survive under hideous conditions at prison, as synopsis said.
6 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed