Jake and the Fatman (TV Series 1987–1992) Poster

(1987–1992)

User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Bring back Penny
videorama-759-8593912 March 2017
What happened to Joe Penny? He's obviously another one of those actors, pigeon holed for the small screen, and it's a shame. In my opinion as just recently tuning into re runs of the series, he makes the show, where I know a lot of viewers would be barracking for his partner in law, the grouchy Jake, a beefy guy of a few words, and I know Conrad plays it brilliantly, but it's what Penny does with his character. He has a certain kind of enviousness, and pathetic style. He has an unhurried coolness. We know exactly what he's about and what he wants. But there's much more to him. Basically, the show has him as a sexy PI, and Penny really enjoys his job. After he catches the bad guy, and makes the case, our fat grouchy DA (Conrad) prosecutes with his few words. This wasn't the best drama on the block, but it was up there. The stories were tightly scripted, and at the time, quite original. One episode had a female fatale, Penny let himself be controlled by, via a deadly concoction of drink, a twist of that, not just of lemon, as I recall, watching an another episode over a year ago. Without Penny as the lead, this show truly wouldn't have the same impact or fun. He's just embodies a character, I really find fascinating, like I do with roles of other actors, whether film or t.v. T.v shows music score is something that really brings back memories of 87. If you've never seen this, watch it, sheerly for Penny, the driving force of the show, but Conrad's much smaller screen time appearances are gold. He reminds me of and could of played the Lawrence Tierney character in Reservoir Dogs. I really hope Penny's career is resurrected in the future.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
William Conrad's Second Most Famous Role
Sargebri10 October 2003
This is probably the only other character besides Frank Cannon that William Conrad will always be associated with (other than his portrayal of Matt Dillon on the radio version of Gunsmoke). This was a good mixture of action and humor and the chemistry between William Conrad, Joe Penny and Alan Campbell was what made it so fun. Also, the best years of the show was when the locale was switched from Los Angeles to Honolulu. This seemed to add a little something to the show. Unfortunately, they had to move the show back to L.A. and that seemed to take the edge off the show. However, this show still will be one of the most underrated shows of the late-1980's.
27 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
They always cancel the best ones first.
dnwalker16 December 1999
Why was this series cancelled? With the exception of Hunter, it was probably the best detective show since William Conrad starred in Cannon. Conrad played the eccentric district attorney, J. L. McCabe, with his ever-present dog Max to the hilt, and Joe Penny played detective Jake Styles just as well. The interplay of McCabe's and Styles's personalities added much to the mix.
29 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Too much Penney, not enough Conrad
shakspryn21 May 2018
This was an OK show. William Conrad, notable for being one of the greatest actors in radio history--certainly among the top ten on any list--adds his memorable presence. Penney gets a lot of screen time as he runs around doing legwork and handling the action aspects. To me, Penney was always a fairly generic sleek good-looking type. I thought he was about adequate in the role, but I also thought any of three dozen actors could have done it as well. But William Conrad! He was a talent for the ages.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
July 2008 Release of the Season One DVD Set
aimless-4631 March 2008
It all started during "Matlock's" first season (1986). The sixth episode of that series featured William Conrad as District Attorney James "Fatman" McShane. The next year the producers took this character, changed his name slightly to Jason Lochinvar 'Fatman' McCabe, and with Conrad created the long-running series "Jake and the Fatman". Conrad's deep voice gave him quite a radio/television career, much of it unseen as he played Matt Dillon on the radio version of "Gunsmoke" and did voice-over commentary for "The Fugitive" and "Rocky and Bullwinkle".

The 106 hour-long episodes of this police drama were originally broadcast on CBS from 1987 to 1992. This pending DVD set contains the first half of the 23 episodes from the first season, 21 regular episodes and a two-part pilot, which actually ran "after" the show had premiered.

In some ways the two title characters in the first season of "Jake and the Fatman" could be considered the most authentic looking of any police drama. While Conrad's character on "Cannon" was dubbed "Cannonball" by Mad Magazine, lampooning was unnecessary with the "Fatman" character and Conrad actually seemed to gain weight with each passing episode during the first season. For the second season he slimmed down a bit for their move from Los Angeles to Hawaii, everything is relative. Like "Cannon" he groans and complains but manages to get his man by the end of each episode. But while "Cannon" at least looked presentable, the "Fatman's" grooming makes him look he's been staying in a homeless shelter and staining his tie in soup kitchens.

Of course this was supposed to contrast with his suave police associate Jake Styles (Joe. E. Penny), who cruises for babes in a silver Porsche speedster. But this guy isn't like the squeaky clean detectives on "Hawaiian Eye". As Harry and Wally said: "Jake is some young, oily hotshot who works undercover to do the legwork....Jake looks like the kind of guy who would proposition your fourteen-year-old sister". He did seem slightly more wholesome once the two moved to the Islands but for DVD buyers that won't be until Season Two.

Then again, what do I know? I'm only a child.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Forgettable
AMAZINGzingzing6 August 2023
Jake and the Fatman During the 80s there were tons of lighthearted "comedy crime" series, such as murder she wrote, Matlock etc.

Jake and the Fatman is another one of these shows.

Conrad and penny are both great actors and their acting ability and charm make This dull series a bit more enjoyable

The problem with this series is its far too genteel predictable and safe, I would have loved the series to be more gritty

You can tell Joe penny is a real life tough guy,they should have highlighted this, instead he plays the role of loverboy

The comedy segments are cheesy and seem forced, and usually revolve around Conrad getting angry or making a mistake

I really wanted to enjoy this series but I gave up after watching 4 episodes.

I recommend viewers to watch kojak or Rockford files instead, who loves you baby?
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
GREAT TV CRIME SERIES
NashBridges21 February 2001
I agree to my previous speaker: "Jake And The Fatman" was one of the best TV crime dramas, and surely on top of the list during the late 1980's. I would say it lines up nicely with the great TV crime series like The Streets of San Francisco, Cannon, Petrocelli, Vega$, and Miami Vice - all quite different and individual, but all classic. By the way, I had the impression that William Conrad had his good days and less good days during the Jake And The Fatman series, especially in later episodes filmed on Hawaii. Does anyone know if William Conrad suffered from (a beginning) Parkinson's disease?
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An Honest Review
generationofswine9 February 2019
Magnum P.I., Riptide (my personal favorite), Simon & Simon, and all the other little detective shows that were on during the late 70s and early 80s network battles were light entertainment.

It's not to say that they weren't great entertainment, but just that the tone of the shows were less stressful and more family friendly.

Jake and the Fatman got a bit darker. The action and comedy were still there, but it sort of feels like the older sibling of detective shows. And it does so in almost the same way that Columbo feels like the adult in the room of detective shows from that era.

However, it's still entertaining fair that I would love to see brought back in some form. Buddy detective shows are a lot better than police procedural melodramas.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great, fun series.
wkozak22119 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I have always liked William Conrad and Joe Penny. This is a fun series. The banter between the 2 leads is funny. The series can be serious or light hearted. J.L. is Gregg but he can be kind hearted also. I love the dog. He adds some great dialog. What makes me laugh is I have the feeling J.L. can't cook. He is always asking Jake to cook. I feel sorry for Jake because J.L. is always raiding his fridge. Priceless....
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mahalo!!
sanchezr01515 September 2011
Jake & The Fatman was a great experience for me, to participate in many episodes as an extra gave me the opportunity to meet so many talented actors and make many new friends. I truly enjoyed the times that I was asked to be part of all episodes of this great show, I truly enjoyed very much and learned a lot about the TV industry...and the experience led me to more participation in other TV shows shot in Hawaii! Jake & The Fatman was an exciting and wonderful experience for many of us...meeting, socializin and just being next to so many great actors, actresses, and fellow extras were unique moments to treasure Looking forwards to more TV shows in the Future!! Thank you for the Opportunity to have been part of TV history in Hawaii Rolando Sanchez
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Women are the perdition of the world
Dr_Coulardeau21 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Those stories are detective stories mostly in Los Angeles with something like one year deported to Hawaii. The original is old, so the remastering was not possible that easily and the pictures are slightly distorted to fit in a wide screen. They did not bother to add the now standard subtitles for hard-of-hearing people. That's ok when the bulldog is speaking, meaning barking or grumbling, but with human characters, it is slightly difficult.

This series comes from a time when, in one way or any other, the main culprits were naturally women. If men get in the way of the police or justice, it is only and most of the time always because the poor man got entangled with a bad woman. It is in many ways irritating to brandish such sexism. The first two seasons even went further, and in the title sequence, an allusion to the sexual activities of the investigator, Jake, with women, were his way to be able to have the great life he had, but the Fatman doubted how he could do it with the simple pay of some kind of police or district attorney's investigator. And the allusion to his being a gigolo in a way, was heavily repeated for at least two years if not three. Then, in later seasons, the flimsy skin-rubbing scenes were only thrown onto the screen from time to time but without the gigolo allusion.

Maybe I overdo it by calling Jake a gigolo. In fact, he was just a complacent and easy partner who could not resist the temptation systematically thrown in his way by any woman trying to get some advantage from this semi-cop. It is true it would be difficult to imagine Columbo doing that kind of sport, especially since Columbo has a wife somewhere. But it is the Fatman who is the impersonation of Columbo. A fat slob is quite similar to the sloppily-dressed character that cannot be missed at any time of this presence anywhere because of his odd behavior. The Fatman is just plain fat, and he eats so much and so badly that he is literally killing himself. He even pushes the connection with Columbo one step farther, and he has a dog he cherishes, and he overfeeds to make him some kind of a couch- - what the Brits call a settee - -ridden slobbish dog if we can still call that a dog.

The crimes and murders and all other sorts of offenses are funny, more ah-ah than strange. They always turn around a twist in the fabric or a bias in the language of the people who are supposed to be witnesses and investigating personnel. And you can play with words along their stylish line and replace slob with snob because they sound alike and the Fatman makes it an aristocratic nobility to be fat, and the impolite if not insolent disrespectful dummy who may snicker at the fat perambulating cardiac arrest, can crawl, on the mat, hat off, with a bat in his belfry, and a cat in his scullery raiding the meat cabinet, on all fours, hands, elbows, shoulders, knees, and feet, a lot more than four, true enough, begging for leniency. "Noblesse oblige," as they say in French, "Honi soy qui mal y pense," as they say when they speak from the garter - not the gutter of course not - all these noble aristocrats, all men, and none women, who swear in their Order of the Garter that they are as pure in mind and body as newborns, or the cleaned up skeleton that has stayed in the earth for at least five centuries.

And don't ask the silly question: "Since garters are for women today, what did this garter suspend in the Middle Ages for men? I guess the G-String or G-thong or G-loincloth of the happy males whose G*****Ls are not floating around and swinging or swaying in the wind. Yes, Honi soy qui mal y pense. And a good rope might be just proper to hang the culprit high and short on Bartholomew Fairgrounds, just before the Fair, to give some sanguinity to the audience before dismembering, disemboweling, gelding, emasculating, and other orchidotomous extractions of the eyes, the ears, the nose, the breasts and nipples, and other prominent jewels of the body, to end up with quartering him. After a while, we try not to see the fat anymore, but I must say it is pitiful to cultivate such fatness that ended badly for the actor.

The stories are always on a similar pattern. You see the crime being committed but often not the criminal. At once a person of interest or two appears in the limelight, and you can be sure it is not the proper answer, and this proper answer is going to be an evil woman who has managed to hide her evilness long enough for the investigation to last a few days. But the bad woman will be dealt with and processed like a bunch of data in a database. And you can have a nightcap and go to sleep in some kind of DUI (Drowsing Under the Influence) stupor.

Enjoy the fun of the Fatman and the lust of Jake, the investigator. Luckily, he sees, from time to time, a little bit beyond the tip of his dick.

Dr. Jacques COULARDEAU.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Strange things in the early hours
thebumswillalwayslose31 December 2004
Warning: Spoilers
Hailing from the UK i am not that familiar with niche 80's US detective shows, so imagine my surprise whilst flicking through the various cable channels at 4am (dont ask) that i came across Jake and the Fatman.

although other people might disagree i found myself hooked on this show which for an 80's programme (reaganite politics aside) is extremely groundbreaking in a cheesy sort of way. episodes that dealt with vigilante husbands punishing random muggers due to his wife being gang-raped (something he was made to watch)years previously to an avenging cops wife shooting her husband and his partner for the miscarriage he rather violently inflicted on her in the past.

i am aware of the censorship issues that are in operation in network American TV so it is all the more refreshing and intelligent that such a programme could have dealt with these issues in (i am assuming) its prime-time slot.

if you happen to read my rather general review on Jake and the Fatman and i have piqued your interest you would not be wasting your time if you were to give it a go, so search the stations on those cold dark nights and be entertained.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Flip-side of "Matlock"
KUAlum2627 April 2010
It shouldn't be much of a surprise that this show was (co?)produced by Fred Silverman,who also created and produced the highly successful "Matlock" on rival nets NBC and ABC. This inhabitant of the CBS midweek scheduling(usually Tuesdays if memory serves)seems like as much a sort of photo negative of the earlier offering starring Andy Griffith,where instead of a defense attorney fighting to exonerate a wrongly accused yet highly viable suspect,a sly,pro-active prosecuting attorney--in this case,portly J.L.McCabe(the late,great William Conrad)--battles to find who the real guilty culprit in in cases that seem cut-and-dried in another direction. To his aid are a handsome,seemingly 'Devil may care' private investigator(and ex-cop)named Jake Stiles(the handsome,now 'Where Are They Now?' material Joe Penny) and the loyal assistant attorney Derek Mitchell(Alan Campbell).

While I cannot profess to be a loyal fan of the show,I watched it with some regularity through the first two seasons or so and was reasonably impressed with how the show(for its day)could deconstruct a "Now you see it,now you don't" type of murder mystery that was similar to the show about the crafty,blue suited Atlanta defense attorney. The combination of the veteran bluster of Mr. Conrad and the seemingly feckless charm of Mr.Penny was able to fill up an hour capably. Even though this show had a solid five year run(that was almost cut down after season one),it's pretty tough to find re-runs of this. If you can,and you feel like this kind of easy-to-digest,late eighties entertainment is your cup of tea,then check this out.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Christmas Episode in Hawaiian Hospital Children's Ward
SpecialMouse864 March 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Does anyone know which episode contained William Conrad telling the Christmas story to a bunch of Hawaiian kids in the hospital children's ward? I can't tell from the episode guide. I'd love to have a video of it as a gift for my husband. Does anyone have one they'd be willing to sell or trade? We loved the series, although have to agree that it was much better when set in Hawaii than in Los Angeles. It's a shame that it never made it to syndication. We felt that it ranked right up there with many of the best of the 80s detective shows, and the relationships between the two stars and of course, Max, were very well drawn. Jake and Max were perfect foils!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
more than crime serie
Kirpianuscus16 July 2018
I saw this serie for William Conrad performance. and, sure, for his dog. and the resemblace between them. in same measure, for the inspired architecture of each episode. and, sure, for the humor. because it remains more than a great crime serie. but one of the most energetic shows, and good example of the build of contrast in the portrait of lead characters.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed