Welcome Back, Mr. McDonald (1997) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
20 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Best Japanese comedy since Itami
ankyron-28 December 1999
At a time when Japanese movies are becoming less and less imaginative and more and more standardized, THE RADIO HOUR stands as one of the happiest surprises from their industry in many years. Koki Mitani's script and direction are beautifully assured, and the actors, particularly the hilarious Jun Inoue as the cheerful, prankish Hiromitsu, couldn't be better. Mitani doesn't bother directly explaining anything to the audience; rather, he expertly shows a wide range of human behavior, each quirk of which leads to yet another bizarre twist in the ongoing live-broadcast drama. Fortunately, Mitani likes all his characters, and with marvelous economy, sees that we well understand why they behave the way they do. In fact as the story unfolds, one begins to see Mitani's story as something of an allegory for the filmmaking process, or the process of any endeavor, including the theater or the radio, that involves a broad number of collaborators. There's the actor who'll go along with anything, and the actor who won't; the actress who demands a star turn (but mainly because she feels underappreciated); the technicians who've seen it all before, and scramble to improvise; and, finally, the playwright herself, increasingly weirded out by what's becoming a perversion of everything she intended. But, finally, was what she intended any better than what what the rest of the team threw together? They needed her to get started; she needed them for the same reason.

Collaboration means interdependence, and if the audience is finally happy, as Mitani ultimately suggests, then what better outcome could there be? There is not a finer or more cheerful film to come out of Japan since the last works of Juzo Itami, and it is fitting that his widow, the great actress Nobuko Miyamoto, contributes a (nearly invisible) cameo, to one of the few Japanese films to emulate the spirit of her late husband's art. And like Itami's films, THE RADIO HOUR is that rare Japanese comedy that audiences anywhere can enjoy
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A real hoot.
dreamalert5 February 2000
"Welcome Back, Mr. McDonald" in English. This account of a live radio drama gone awry has universal appeal, while also poking fun at contemporary Japanese culture. There are some wonderfully frantic comic scenes in it. Everything that can go wrong with a young writer's first drama script happens, which is how a love story about a Japanese girl saved by a fisherman turns into the tale of a Chicago trial lawyer rescued by an astronaut who's subsequently lost in space, etc. I give it eight ho's out of ten.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Clever and insightful
planktonrules1 August 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The film begins as a rehearsal is ending. A radio play is to be put on only hours later and everyone is congratulating a housewife for the script--which was a winning entry in a script-writing contest. From all appearances, the final live radio show should be a "cake walk". However, a monkey wrench is thrown into the equation when a very temperamental actress asks for "just a few small changes in the script". Unfortunately, the changes aren't small, as they have a major cascading impact on the script. Plus, the other voice actors are jealous and want changes to be made as well. Soon the original simple tale of a lady who works into a pachinko parlor in Japan is morphed into a tale involving a lawyer and her astronaut boyfriend that it set in gangster-infested Chicago!! And with each "little" change, the original script becomes less and less evident. Additionally, each change seems to set off a cascade of script revisions. Again and again, impossibilities become realities in this wacky script--such as scenes involving the mountains in Chicago (it's actually one of the flattest major cities on Earth) and a boyfriend who has just been named "Donald McDonald"--thanks to inspiration one voice actor who happens to be eating McDonald's food!!

The film starts off pretty slowly and is only mildly funny at first--you need to stick with it. Over time, it starts to take off and become seriously funny--mostly thanks to a great ensemble cast and writing that somehow makes the entire cast quite endearing. In particular, the minor supporting characters were great--I particularly loved the cowboy trucker. A truly original film that is sure to please anyone who has a sense of humor. Good stuff.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
10/10 Japanese Comedy
mainstay30 May 2000
Being a fan of Juzo Itami, I went to see "Welcome Back Mr. McDonald" (English title) expecting a dark comedy. I was pleasantly surprised. Though Mitani's film is much lighter than Itami's "Marusa no Onna" for example, I still was laughing out loud along with everyone else in the theatre over scenes like the Gameboy(tm)-playing security guard teaching frantic techies how to create the sound of a dam breaking over a mountain village with rice and a styrofoam cup. This is a cleverly filmed, intelligently written, and well-acted movie. I just wish recent films from Japan like "Rajio no Jikan", "Mononoke Hime" and "After Life" were given the credit they deserve in the United States.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
thank you, Japan, for making us laugh
lee_eisenberg18 June 2005
Are one of those people who believes that Japan can only make movies about the Yakuza, or such topics? Then look no further than "Rajio no jikan" (called "Welcome Back, Mr. McDonald" in English)! A radio station in Tokyo is broadcasting a love story. It goes smoothly at first, but then they keep rewriting it. From there, their broadcast gets progressively crazier and crazier.

Boy! How they came up with that stuff is beyond me, but they did it. The English title comes from...well, I don't want to spoil that scene. The point is that you gotta see this movie if you can find it anywhere. It hearkens back to movies like "It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World" and "The Russians are Coming, The Russians are Coming", with the way that something seemingly small branches out into total lunacy. Absolutely hilarious.
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
what movies are meant to be
shourav6 September 1999
I bought the last available ticket to see Welcome Back, Mr McDonald this evening, having been unsuccessful at obtaining one for Love Letter. Maybe because I chanced upon this film, not having any expectations, I enjoyed it tremendously. Sure the film has some stock comic characters and stock comic situations and the premise (message?) may strike a chord in every struggling artiste's heart, but the grit with which this film is made is heartwarming. A novice playwright's maiden radio play gets torn to shreds by the powers that be as she hangs on, flailingly, to the emotion that she hopes to convey. A film that reminds us that our heart yearns for the underdog while our mind rationalises the behaviour of the seemingly tyrannical, this film reminds us of what movies are meant to be: an adventure where at the end you can't help but exclaim.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great comedy
mfemyer6 March 2010
If it were possible I'd give this film a higher score.

When I visited Japan in 1997 I saw a TV program that previewed this movie. I had always remembered what the film was about, but I had long forgotten the title of the film and I had never seen it in the United States as the big city I live in isn't big enough for films like this.

Fast forward to late 2009 when my wife and I decided to go to our local library to borrow films to watch. We were looking for Japanese films that we hadn't seen, and this was one of them. I couldn't believe I had finally found the film I was searching for.

This is a great film and is laugh out loud from start to finish. I had to look at some scenes a second and third time to catch the action I had missed from laughing. Of course, for the week I had it I watched it several more times!

The fact that this is a screwball comedy means that action takes place in the background as well as directly in front of the camera. Therefore, it is necessary to look fast and catch all the action, or rewind and watch it again and again and again.

If you like to laugh this film fills the bill very nicely. Not many people can pull off the high quality of this type of film. This film is my new all time favorite movie.

I wish I hadn't had to wait so long to find it. In my opinion, on a scale of 1 to 100 I proudly give this film 1,000,000! (I'm not paid to say this.)

Happy viewing, and don't eat or drink anything while watching this film...you'll choke.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Radio Chaos
crossbow010623 August 2008
A brilliant comedy from Japan about a radio station going live with an original drama written by Miyako, a housewife, who entered a contest the station gave. She is played superbly by the plainly dressed but pretty Kyoko Suzuki. From the beginning, the madness starts. Her screenplay keeps getting tweaked to the point where it is unrecognizable and the last second script changes keep the tension up. Throughout, the characters are so rich: The temperamental actress Nokko (Keiko Toda), the too appeasing producer, the opinionated engineer, the suffering manager of Nokko, Miyako's husband who thinks the screenplay is about him, and so on. Its screwball comedy at its best, frantic, unrelenting and, at times, hilarious. I would not usually give a 10 to a movie such as this, but this one not only keeps your interest, it gets better and better. Even Ken Wattanabe is here, playing a trucker who, while driving his big rig, tunes into the melodrama and is moved by it all. Writer/Director Koki Mitani does a superb job of keeping the pacing perfect in this film. You have to see it, it is really terrific.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A housewife's script goes out of control as it succumbs to the demands of a radio stage play.
mel_protoss17 November 2013
Warning: Spoilers
This comedy didn't really work for me. Let's generalize that: comedies don't really work for me.

Those that (kindof) did include The Proposal, White Chicks, Pulp Fiction, Zombieland, The Devil Wears Prada and Three Idiots. I have no idea where are the lines that divide the comedies that work for me and those that don't. Although this film was tightly packed and well-paced, the humour was a tad too ridiculous and the satire a little too forced. (But then again, satires were never meant to be realistic.)

Originally a stage play, Welcome Back, Mr. McDonald dramatises one night in a radio station. The radio station plans to stage a radio play based on a housewife's melodrama script that won (and was the only submission of) the radio station's contest. However, when the lead actress throws a tantrum and demands her character's name to be edited from 'Ritsuko' to 'Mary Jane', the floodgates open. More and more changes are made as the script succumbs to the demands of other actors, realities of the radio station and plot inconsistencies caused by initial changes. Amidst the chaos and the deadlines, a wholly new narrative emerges (though the happy ending is preserved).

There are three satiric points that the film makes. First, the film criticises the Japanese work place convention and its rigid corporate hierarchy. Second, the film mocks the Japanese social practice of being polite at all costs. Third, the film ridicules Japanese' obsession with the West.

More subtle is the subversion of the creative process. The author, conventionally seen as omnipotent in his own creative universe, is relegated to a mere gatekeeping role (and not even an effective one at that) by the corporate institution's demands. Her script is a meticulously crafted tear-jerker set in a Japanese fishing village. In the end, it becomes an action-fantasy set in Chicago where the hero is lost in space and the heroine is a high flying trial lawyer. Ironically, some of the film's most epic scenes arise precisely from the attempts to make the radio play more epic – a vacuum cleaner imitates the sound of a rocket launch; a flushing toilet is a dam breaking.

But all is well that ends well. And our housewife asks and receives only one thing at the end – a happy ending. And everyone, including the radio play's audience represented by a single truck driver, is happy in the end.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great movie about radio.
ronsayles19 December 2006
This is the greatest movie about radio that I have ever had the pleasure of watching. It is the story of what can and does happen when changes are made to the script just before air time and while on the air. How the story gets wildly out of control and how sound effects are created, on the spot, by an ex-sound effects man who is now the security guard for the radio station. If you like radio as it once was, you will like this movie. It is a 1988 release with English subtitles, but don't let the fact that it has subtitles scare you away. They are in yellow and easy to read. As an added bonus one of the stars is Watanabe Ken who was nominated for a best supporting acting award for the movie "The Last Samurai."
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Watch this film
larry-raynor15 September 2006
"Welcome Back, Mr. McDonald" is funny, sweet, surprising, and laugh out loud funny. Character development is marvelous. The plot twists and turns in a delightful manner. Fast paced, yet connected. The characters are so well developed, it might well be better the second time around. The strength of the film is related to it's insightful view of how a group of individuals interact when time is precious. The film itself is a precious gem. The presentation is fresh, clear, and funny without attention to the "cute factor". I could certainly be labeled a "screwball comedy", but is much more than that. It is sensitive, it is gentle, it is so real.Grab the popcorn and your favorite squeeze, and have a ball.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
An alternative viewpoint: Not worth 100 minutes.
markmarks22 May 2014
I got such great recommendations for this movie, I thought it must be great. What I got... was a disappointment. Half an hour of it was just getting ready to do a radio drama. Another half an hour and the movie sorta, kinda, dragged its feet into a patchy, commercial-filled start. I was feeling the slowness from all the way over here. I sped it up to 2x, scanning the subtitles. Maybe the last 1/3 or 1/4 picked up the pace and added humor, but at this point an hour of my life was blown and no amount of dry humor could bring it back.

It had the long, drawn out scenes that reminded me of Gravity... except the acting was mediocre and uninspired, with no interesting developments in it.

Was there humor? Oh, maybe. If Dana Carvey's Master of Disguise was funny, so was this.

Was there excitement? Just imagine the slow moments from 2001 a Space Odyssey, and remove the sci-fi elements (or ANYTHING with a budget).

This movie was boring, dull, and over-dramatized with the weak point it was trying to drive home. It feels like a play, probably because it was adapted from one. A weak 1990s movie in a 1980s setting hearkening back to the 1930s, with all the appeal of the dud it portrays.

Do not watch.
1 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great Movie!!
snaffulafugus16 November 2000
Despite cliche slapstick scenes (which are little and tolerable), "Radio No Jikan" is a refreshing comedy for someone who is tired of mainstream cinema blockbusters. It had my sister and I in tears during the second half of the movie when things really turn chaotic. Unforgettable characters were the tiresome Bucky and the charismatic Mr. Horinouchi. I give it an 8 out of 10 !
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
BEAUTIFUL!
One of the best movies I've ever seen. Perfectly acted, perfectly written. From other reviews you all know the plot. A rather shy young housewife has written a radio script that won a contest and a radio station is putting her script on the air. Not only that, but it will be done live! And as everything begins, the trouble begins. Someone doesn't like a character's name. Someone wants the city changed. The occupation of the main character changed. More changes. On and on and on, until the poor writer's script is hardly recognizable and she's practically in tears. I refuse to spoil the ending, but trust me, it's absolutely perfect and I almost cried and laughed at the same time. What a wonderful beautiful movie!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
lightweight farce with satirical touches
screaminmimi31 December 2008
Fun in the same sort of teeth-gnashing way Mitani's "Minna no Ie" is. I found myself wanting to rescue both films' main victims of everybody else's machinations. Similar plot in both movies about what happens when your dream falls into the hands of supposed experts. Both movies have leading characters who work in commercial entertainment, so I suspect the satirical elements of both scripts relating to this career path are very near to Mitani's experience.

The rest in both movies is stock-character-driven farce, over-the-top, as all well-wrought farce should be. This picture was derived from the work of a live sketch comedy troupe, so it has that wild, loosey-goosey feel you get when actors get to improvise major chunks of the plot, reined in just enough to make it a coherent movie, while still nodding to the art of improv in the script-within-a-script.

Look for Ken Watanabe somewhat reprising his role in "Tampopo." He doesn't do nearly enough comedy anymore. His early work is a hoot. This is only a small taste of it.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A hilarious night at the radio!
altea22 February 1999
Imagine being a desperate house-wife in Japan falling in love with a man who doesn't have a clue that you are in love with him. So how do you transmit your feelings as a women in modern day suppressed Japan? Your solution: writing a radioplay mentioning your feelings and love for him. You are in luck because a radio-station is willing to broadcast your play. Mission accomplished? During the course of the broadcast of your play, one of the radio-actors has the bright idea that he has to improvise on his role. Outcome: the whole story has to be rewritten at will by the actors, director, producers, sponsors of the show...because of the continuity. Are you going to defend your script at all costs? I had a great night at the radiostation. The actors are wonderful and hilarious. The direction is first class. A must see movie for everyone who loves world cinema and is looking for a different kind of movie than normal US fare.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
DVD here at last!
noirfilm24 March 2003
I'm glad to see this movie is finally available in the US on DVD. I saw this years ago in a Los Angeles theater and have been looking for it on tape or DVD ever since. There was an expensive DVD version available in Japan and also an Asian VCD version with poorly-visible subtitles. The English sub-titles on the US DVD are large and clear. The movie has a nice ensemble cast and is very funny! There is a long tracking shot at the beginning which introduces most of the characters. The other reviews will give you more details.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Funny Business
Teen Vig18 September 2001
I, myself, enjoy some very obscure films. I love Japanese mangas, all of Hitchcock's films and a lot of foreign films. I have a hard time convincing most people that there's so much that isn't made by modern hollywood and is just as good, if not, better. This is one of the few films I would recommend to everyone. This isn't just for Japanese cinema fans... or people that enjoy subtitled movies. This movie is so funny it hurts at times and very clever, without being pretentious. The performances are second to none. You feel so sorry for Mrs. Suzuki, who has put so much of her own aspirations into this radio play's script, only to have it so quickly and frequently ripped apart on a has-been starlet's whim or for the convenience of the sound effects department. It really is one of the funniest films I've seen in a long time. I highly recommend this film to EVERYONE! If you have never seen a Japanese film... or a film with subtitles, this is a good one to start with. Trust me... everyone will love this film.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hilarious
breadandhammers16 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A late-night radio show becomes a producer's nightmare after actors, businessmen, and everyone else besides the directors makes request after request to change the script and compromise the artistic integrity of the ending. The film ends with the second in command, Kudo, taking charge and making sure the Miyako Suzuki's script maintains its happy ending.

I thought this was a wonderful allegory of an artist working within the business. We see small compromise after small compromise snowball into a slew of completely arbitrary changes for the script, ending up with a Frankenstein of a creation. The film is hilarious and a wonderful tale for an artist.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A must see for would-be foley artists!
clomax-117 July 2001
Ever thought it must be great to direct or write or be a crew member on a show? Think it's a snap? Think again...Everything that can go wrong, does: it's NOISES OFF on the radio in Japanese. Watch for the least likely rescuer to save the day!
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed