The Radicals (1989) Poster

(1989)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A brave effort with some limitations
steiner-sam8 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The film is based on the novel, "Pilgrim Aflame" by Myron Augsburger. It's set in Switzerland, Germany and Austria from 1524-1527, and recounts the rise of the Anabaptist movement in those areas that resulted in the Swiss Brethren.

The film opens showing some of the chaos of the time, including peasant unrest and the threat of invasion by the Turks. Ulrich Zwingli (Christopher Neame), along with some of his more radical disciples, especially Wilhelm Reublin (Daniel Perrett). We're also introduced to Michael Sattler (Norbert Weisser), the Prior in a monastery, and Margaretha (Leigh Lombardi), a member of the Beguine movement. Part of Sattler's work is to help gather taxes from the common people at the direction of Eberhard Hoffman (Mark Lenard). Hoffman is an official accountable to Count Joachim von Zollern (Lynn Mathis).

The film shows some of the debate on infant baptism between Zwingli and the proto-Anabaptists in the Zurich city council, followed by the first adult baptisms, the later banishment of most of the Anabaptist leaders, and some of their subsequent efforts to attract followers among the rural peasant population.

Meanwhile we learn of Sattler's departure from the monastery and Margaretha's agreeing to marry him. Sattler grapples with various points of Anabaptist thought, and has frequent interaction with Reublin. On one occasion Sattler is arrested, but is released by Zwingli because Sattler has not yet joined the Anabaptists. Michael and Margaretha finally are baptized by Reublin, and Sattler assumes greater leadership in the Anabaptist movement. Reublin favors a peasant rebellion while Sattler firmly rejects use of physical weapons in responding to the Catholic and Zwinglian rulers. A battle leaves Reublin disconsolate as he feels he has failed.

In the wake of this crisis within the Anabaptist community, Sattler calls for a gathering of Anabaptist leaders in Schleitheim to come to agreement on core Anabaptist principles. This results in the 1527 Schleitheim Confession. However, Michael and Margaretha Sattler are soon arrested, and after a lengthy trial Michael is tortured and burned, and two days later Margaretha is drowned. In the trailing notes we learn that Wilhelm Reublin recanted his Anabaptist beliefs in 1535 and died a wealthy man.

This is probably the only commercial film that takes seriously the pacifist roots of the Anabaptist movement. Films made in Europe have tended to focus on the non-pacifist Anabaptist kingdom in Münster in 1534-1535, or the character of Thomas Müntzer, one of the leaders of the 1524 Peasants' Rebellion.

"The Radicals" is a brave effort, but has several limitations. It is so sincere that Sattler becomes a saint long before his martyrdom. Efforts are made at occasional humor, especially between Michal and Margaretha, but some seems quite forced. On occasion it was difficult to keep track of the various Anabaptist leaders in various encounters with authorities. The pace of the film is slow at times as Sattler ruminates about this and that. The low budget of the film results in stiff acting by some of the lesser characters.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The early history of the Anabaptists...a most unusual theme of any film.
planktonrules13 November 2023
"The Radicals" is a most unusual movie. This is because there just aren't that many movies about the early Protestant Church...particularly their offshoot, the Anabaptists. It's obvious that the film had a relatively small budget, though there are a few familiar faces in the film, such as Mark Lenard and Christopher Neame.

The film begins just after the Reformation and much of the story is set in Protestant Switzerland. It mostly centers on the life of Michael Sattler...and early Anabaptist leader. Because they rejected infant baptism, taking up arms, and were in favor of individual understanding and faith, they were looked upon unfavorably by both the Catholics AND Protestants. The film is about his progression as an Anabaptist and the early Anabaptist movement.

The film does a very good job presenting the Anabaptist beliefs and early church history. Surprisingly, it also does a nice job technically speaking...with nice music and acting. Overall, even if you don't believe in many of the Anabaptist beliefs, it's a nice history lesson...and well made to boot.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Praise from a Mennonite
menno-920 October 2004
As a Mennonite, this has to be my favorite B-movie: appropriate for a simple-living faith! Apart from the geek-chic factor of the intimidating Eberhard Hoffman being played by Spock's dad, the film captures the emotional appeal of Anabaptism: an earnest desire for religion without worldly politics woven in, their temptation by and rejection of violence, the persecution from both Catholics and Protestants, the romance of simple living.

I'm no film student, but I think the romance between Michael Satler and Margaretha is touchingly developed, and the dramatic opening sequence where Hans Blaurock and friends march through the snow to arrive just in time to try to stop an infant baptism adds an amusingly ironic touch of Hollywood.

But don't expect to find the movie theologically persuasive
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent movie based on true story of the Anabaptists
elrenaud2 September 2002
Warning: Spoilers
An excellent movie about the lives of the Anabaptists - Michael and Margaretha Sadler. Michael was a monk and Margaretha a nun - they both left their religious orders in search of a New Testament faith. Their brief marriage was terminated when Michael was burned at the stake and Margaretha was drowned. Christian film all should see.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of my Favorite Movies of All-Time! 10/10 and an A+++
author-9238223 June 2016
This is a marvelous movie, just fantastic.

It's historically accurate, inspiring, faith-building, entertaining, informational ... and most importantly, honoring to the One true God of the Bible!

There are no negatives to this film at all that I can think of. The actors certainly are not Hollywood stars, but a lack of such "stars" actually makes the characters more believable. I don't want to see Leo DiCaprio playing Michael Sattler ... I want to see someone I am not familiar with play such a hero of the faith, so that I can actually relate to that man of God, and not think about how well Leo "played the part", etc.,.

In conclusion, every Christian on earth should see this movie in my opinion ... and I believe everyone else would do well to see it also.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This Couple Shaped Church History
BridgeBuilder200619 August 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Here is the journey of a man and a woman that actively put their faith in the Lord Jesus Christ during the Reformation Era.

They were used by God to lead others into the practice of adult baptism. That was contrasted to infant baptism. They were called Anabaptist.

This practice was violently opposed by the leaders of the church and the state.

They continued amidst persecution, suffering and ending in death as martyrs for their faith.

This movie makes personal and real a critical season of church history.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Beautiful Love Story and Tale of Inner Courage
JDahlNV25 May 2010
I first developed an interest in this film because of my interest in the career of Norbert Weisser, the lead actor who plays Michael Sattler. I came away with a deep appreciation for the story, the characters of Michael and Margaretha Sattler, and the people that brought this film to reality. The love story is probably the most well acted and believable I have ever seen. The on-screen chemistry between Norbert Weisser and the beautiful and gracious Leigh Lombardi is a tangible thing. The story of their faith, their beliefs and the inner courage they had is even more powerful.

The supporting cast is fabulous -- everyone turns in terrific performances. However, I must say that I am partial to Norbert Weisser as Michael Sattler. He brought forth a wonderful sensitivity to the character of Michael Sattler. Norbert often plays a villain on the screen, but his quiet and calm manner as Michael was exceptionally well acted.

Even though I had limited knowledge of the Reformation and the Anabaptist movement, and had never heard of Michael and Margaretha Sattler, I got so caught up in this film that I developed and designed an entire website based on the film, the historical characters and the location -- the film was that well done, watchable and memorable. The entire cast and crew really pulled off an under-rated masterpiece with this film that is enjoyable on many levels and one you will want to watch over and over.

Yes, this is a faith-based film, but it is also a well written and produced historical film, a love story that rivals the best of them, and a testimonial of having the inner courage of standing true to your beliefs no matter what the price. You will love this movie!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed