Dolphins (1999) Poster

(1999)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Beautiful film
jjaroch1 May 2000
I recently saw this film during the USA Film Festival in Dallas. The USAFF's new program director mentioned it was her personal favorite of the festival. I can see why. Although there is no dialogue in the film, the director's visuals tell a tale all their own. The film is beautiful to look at with sharp colors, haunting music and amazing poetic images. The emotional pull of the actors makes the story both fascinating and moving. This is definitely not a "typical" film. It is unique, mysterious and moving, yet simple and elegant. It feels both gentle and brutal. A very emotional experience. This director's first film is a stunning accomplishment. I wish I could see more films like this....it's truly beautiful.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Boring, obscure and besides seen a thousand times before, but better
christoph.hass3 December 2000
My girlfriend and me were very disappointed about that film, because we had expected more - especially if we thought of the long time the director has needed to make it. But first, we didn't really understand why the title is "Dolphins", for the animals are just seen in two scenes, each of them not longer than perhaps one or one and a half minute. It could be called as well "Nuts" (if this title wouldn't already exist), "insane", "Lara" or just "Without words": each of those titles would tell the same about this movie, and that is to say: nothing. Second, the film itself didn't tell us a story with which we could do anything. Yes, of course we got that it's about love and dreams and pressure and so on, but: what precisely? Perhaps it was a mistake to use not even a single word, for this would possibly help to clear the darkness of the plot. Many things can be said and shown without words, but in our opinion this mediocre film doesn't belong to them. Too many things are well-known, as in films like "One flew over the cuckoo's nest", "Awakenings" or "Der Krieger und die Kaiserin" (Germany), but these films are very much better and have a message one can understand. "Dolphins" shows us nothing but many symbols we have do decipher, and if we cannot, we stand alone and ask us: What does the author want to tell us? The only bright spot of the film is Julia Brendler, a really beautiful girl with a very, very poetic personality. But the film as a whole is extremely boring and in our opinion need not to be seen.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just get touched...
stefanhoeffllin13 September 2000
A story about a girl in a psychatrie hospital who just wants to be free. She lives in her own dreamworld with dolphins. There is a young boy who falls in love with her. He wants to help her to come free...

There is no dialogue, but that doesn´t matter.You don´t need dialogue to feel the love between the people. This is the way cinema has to be: pure magic! If you don´t cry when you watch this movie, you must have a heart of stone. Open your mind and feel...
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beautiful, lyrical short film
Swampfox23 June 2008
This is one of those excellent short subject films that doesn't seem like either TV episode or someone attempting to get investors to expand it to feature length. It's a very simple, straightforward narrative brought to soul-stirring life by the gifted director. Ignore comments from those who seem too jaded to appreciate this little gem of a film. And at less than 30 minutes what do you have to loose just to check it out.

In fact the reason I am writing this at all is because I wondered what he had done since (I saw this years ago) and found to my shock and dismay no one has given him a project.

It is included on the DVD for the now defunct Film-Fest DVD series, Issue 3 (along with some other good shorts)
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Two thumbs way down ...
kookyscientist11 February 2003
...for this disappointing short. This movie is full of embarrassing clichés (e.g. the asylum inmates behave absolutely unnatural) and looks to me like a "work in progress" that was finished by all means. The fuzzy and arbitrary story and the David Hamilton optics are just an obvious trick to cover the dilettantism behind all. However, some people will be fooled and mistake it for poetry... for those I recommend the insightful audio commentary on the film fest DVD that reveals absolutely no useful information - not to let room for interpretations - just because the directer himself doesn't have the slightest idea why he did certain things. I'm pretty sure that "deep inside" this german equivalent to Mark Borchardt (I clearly prefer "Coven" to "Dolphins" by the way) is aware that he is actually an untalented filmmaker...even (and much more because) he thinks he has created something wonderful and unique. The latter it is. 1 out of 10
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Stunningly Beautiful
kencomer3 May 2000
The opening sequence alone is worth buying a "Dolphins" DVD. This movie is one extended moment of intense beauty, more like a modern dance performance than a theatrical production.

There is no dialog, so don't worry about having to deal with sub-titles inherent foreign films. The movie unveils itself in such a way as to reach any person in any modern culture.

The story is small and the plot simplistic, but you won't care. I promise.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dated pictures, no talent
LordOfTheForest19 September 2000
Want to see an average 1986 commercial, directed by a guy with a big mouth and not much talent? Enjoy!! Farhad Yawaris debut displays an array of "Been seen before" ingredients and bores to death. Including the wasted orchestral soundtrack, which is nice for 5 minutes but from there just goes on and on... All in all: what a waste of time, energy, talent and money.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Not a bad idea, but just too long for its own good and that's why it ended up feeling a bit pretentious
Horst_In_Translation3 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Here we have the German live action short film Dolphins from 1999, so this one is easily over 20 years old now and when I say German, I mean that this is a German production. It also says Germman for language here, but this is really only partially correct as there is no talking in this film, at least none that we can hear. What you hear instead, is basically a soundtrack of instrumental music. For me, this made the entire thing really feel more like a ballet than film. There wasn't any dancing, but the sometimes exaggerated movements from the characters made it feel that way and the underwater sequences of course also felt like really swift at times, while on other occasions rather smooth. But let's not move entirely away from the basics: The director here is Farhad Yawari and to this day it has been his only filmmaking credit, also for writing and with all the time passed, it is fairly safe to say that there will be nothing new to his body of work. It is a bit surprising because this film here garnered a great deal of awards recognition, also abroad. For example, the prestigious Palm Springs Film Festival really liked it. This also may have had to do with this film including no spoken language, which means that no matter which languages you speak or don't speak, you can check it out no matter where you are from. If you want to, that is. I'd rather say skip, but I will get to that later.

The lead actress here is Julia Brendler and she is one I always find a bit fascinating. Not really because I think she is particularly talented actress, but rather because of where she is from and also because she is simply stunning and 100% my type. This applies to her being in her 20s here and also applies to her being in her 40s now. But as I stated, she is not the most talented and most versatile performer out there. This is also proven by all the stuff she did after this film here and that's been really many terrible projects unfortunately. She went all in there with Degeto, frequently evven with lead performances. No respect for that from me. The perhaps more talented cast member here is Marco Hofschneider and if you find his face familiar, then this is probably because of him being the lead in Agnieszka Holland's Europa Europa that won so many awards almost a decade before this film here, but basically only did not win Best Foreign Language Feature because Germany submitted another film. Terrible decision. Anyway, I am not really sure what Hofschneider is doing now career-wise, but he's nowhere near as big as he was back then. And with back then I mean 20 years ago. Or 30 years ago even. Kinda unreal that the time in-between this film here and the movie One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest is almost the same now as the time between this film here and the year 2021. Or if you happen to read this a little later, then maybe the latter is even the longer timespan.

Now a few words on the story: During these 40 minutes, we follow the female inmate of a psychiatric ward and her special relationship with her goldfish that helps her basically to flee into a world of joy and relief in which she is connected with dolphins. Thus the title reference. There is an evil female warden (thus the Ofotcn reference) and she is the main antagonist in here. When we see her try to grab the fish relatively early on and this was filmed from the water, from the fish's perspective pretty much, it was a fairly memorable shot. In general, the camera work here is not bad at all. A bit of a pity the filmmaker did not end up making more stuff. But he should have picked another writer perhaps and not come up with the script himself. I do think that the material was enough only for 20 minutes perhaps, so half the running time, and the consequence was that the film began to drag eventually and not just a bit. Pity. Awards bodies and also imdb voters seem to disagree, but thats how I saw it. It's still not a terrible film by any means, but there is certainly room for improvement. Must also be said that the implied romance story between the two (with the girl being rather shy and distant because of her issues and the male nurse being more focused) did not work well enough to really get me emotionally involved in the more dramatic moments like when the guy is thrown out. Literally in fact. The scenes when the girl gets poseyed (is that the right word? like in the sense that she is pushed down and cannot move) are more haunting and sad, at least to me, and reminded me a bit of Angelina Jolie's Oscar-worthy performance in Changeling. Anyway, the ending kinda fit here. It's not super happy, but a bit hopeful nonetheless. Overall, this film gets a thumbs-down from me unfortunately and I think I have made myself clear why I think this was not a particularly memorable watch. It's also pretty difficult to find this film nowadays, but if you get lucky, then you can go for it. Or better don't. It's probably a better watch on the big screen at some movie theater, but I think chances are literally zero this gets shown to a big audience again. Probably the better choice.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed