Die rote Jacke (2002) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The circle closes Warning: Spoilers
This is a 2002 short film that runs for approximately 20 minutes without credits. A young boy is fan of the soccer team Bayern Munich. He has a tragic accident and dies. His father gets rid off the son's jacker and it ends up abroad with some help organization. Another boy gets the jacket and ends up (as unlikely as it sounds) with the dead boy's father. Maybe one coincidence too many, but still a decent short film. Ulrich Noethen is good as always and I personally was surprised to see Tetje Mierendorf in here, even if it is only for one scene. I only knew him as a comedian so far. This short film is an early directorial effort by German filmmaker Florian Baxmeyer, not his first though. He managed to build a career on the success of his work here and is one of Germany's most prolific television directors currently, with quite a few movies and also many "Tatort" episodes. He has not written a single one of his movies himself though and same goes for this short movie. The script is by Elke Schuch who also worked on several projects in the last 13 years, not as many as Baxmeyer however. All in all, "Die rote Jacke" is a good short movie. I am not sure if I would say it is one of the year's best or if the Oscar nomination is deserved, but it's worth a watch I guess.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best short film I have ever seen. Yes, really.
ptb-822 September 2005
I never want to see this film again. I cannot watch this film ever again. Instead, I want everyone else, including you and all your relatives and friends and every politician and their advisors to see it. It should be mandatory viewing in schools everywhere, in every country, especially for 12-15 year olds so they are welded to realising the utter useless ridiculousness of old men's war, what it causes to happen to children and what it makes young soldiers do. I saw it packaged as a short film fest at Sydney's Bondi Beach outdoor cinema one breathtaking summer night. We all walked in chatting and laughing and ready for Internation short film fest. Then, after two claymation funnies, came this film THE RED JACKET. The complete and utter collapse of 300 hearts was heard across the park, only to be followed by breathless silence and truly genuine tears of every emotion. I have no idea what films followed, I like everyone else there was absolutely shattered by this neat 20 minute dialogue free film that simply presented a storyline with bullseye precision. And then reaffirmed the generosity of the human spirit. Who made this film? (It is German) why are these geniuses not celebrated at Oscar time and promoted as the real international talent they clearly are. I do not want to see 'worthy' cinema, and I shudder at media superlatives and I am very aware of what I am writing here. I am raving about this perfect short film, what it delivers and what it has to say about a recent war in Europe. I do not want my heart broken in some fake or contrived cruel movie. This film is not that. This film delivered exactly what I suspected was real, but did it in such a way that I will never forget. If you have to ask a German film consulate to find it, do so. But I saw THE RED JACKET and you should too. This film is a genuine, succinct, perfectly realised cinema masterpiece. It has everything in it that I would avoid if I had any idea of what it contained. Find it, watch it yourself and then just hand it to others - but don't prepare them. Let me just finally say that if each generation of impressionable teens was shown this film, instead of Hollywood gun fun, we would finally generate the politicians of the future who would avoid warfare forever. I saw THE RED JACKET two years ago. It has taken me until now to write about it. Sounds ridiculous and over emotional but every word of what I have written is here should not put you off.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent short
jposs21 November 2003
We watched this recently in one of my film school classes and I was greatly impressed. The story is very simple and told in a highly visual style. There is almost no dialogue, which makes this originally German film accessible to non-German speakers like many of my classmates. I was instantly engrossed in the film, from the opening images of the aftermath of a traffic accident. The story is well-paced and not overbearing, as student films have a tendency to be. The photography is nice and even beautiful in several places, but it is never distracting and the story is always the focus. Excellent work.

This is a filmmaker to keep an eye on.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A little Info to the Jacket and the only spoken words
Digital_Data6 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
ATTENTION: This is an additional information to the movie from an Bavarian citizen to a plot point in the movie. You normally should read that, after you have seen it.

I also like this movie and I like to see, that the movie also makes a good impression overseas.

Here for all a little information to something what happened in the movie. It's about the only spoken words in the movie. The Jacket is a fan jacket of the FC Bayern München (FC Bavaria Munich) soccer club. This club is very successfully in Germany and more in Europe, so everybody in Europe knows this club. But in Germany there is also much envy and dislike. So the FCB has won most of the German titles in the last years and holds all records. This brings many fans of other clubs to the point to say "Scheiß Bayern" or in translation maybe "Shit on Bavarians" or better "Fuck the Bavarians". And that is, what the other young boy says in the hospital.

I think this background is important, because it shows how a jacket is transferring hate to others, even that the boy has at least nothing to with it. Like in war the hate is created by different uniforms. A super great effect in this story and a great reason, why this are the only spoken words in this movie. Never seen something better !! Digital_Data
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A truly ironic tale.....
661jda9 February 2023
The story of how tragedy eventually can lead to hope and salvation. The problem here is there is no way to get this thru the imdb edits without telling the story. Boy is hit and dies, his grieving father is given the jacket he was wearing at the time of his death. The father is heartbroken and gives the jacket to charity so that it can help someone else and he doesn't have to be reminded of his loss. From there, the jacket virtually takes on a life of it's own and thru another tragedy, the jacket is eventually returned to the father in a very ironic twist of fate that is incredibly heartwarming.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
great
Kirpianuscus14 June 2023
It is a great film. You know this because, after its end, the only fair reaction is the deep silence. It is precise crafted, moment bz moment, offers a simple storz, who you feel being real not realistic, proposes amazing performance of young Nikola Jankovic , reminds the war in its brutal naked aspects and it is reflection of direct truth.

And this makes it not exaclz a magnificent film but an experience, very personal , proved by the whole inspired end.

A father lost his son in a car accident.

A Bosnian boy losts his parents in atack of one of armies.

But he survives, is saved, goes from hospital, his life is saved second time.

A red jacket is the link between characters, dramas and the seed of second chance.

So, only/ just a great film.

A masterpiece ? No doubts, it represents more than that.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed