Out of Hand (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A touch of Funny Games Warning: Spoilers
"Keller - Teenage Wasteland" is a German-language movie from 2005, so this one is already over a decade old, and it runs for pretty much 1.5 hours exactly. It is the only filmmaking effort by writer and director Eva Urthaler at this point and given the fact that she did a decent job here for the most part I find it a bit disappointing that she has not made any other films. The cast is basically a multicultural mix as the female lead is Italian, there are several Austrians in here, a Serbian and the two male lead actors were both born in Berlin with one of them obviously having exotic roots as well looking at his name. Trepte and Moya were under the age of 20 when they made this one and Urthaler also wasn't 30 yet which makes Friedrich and Rocchetti look like seniors almost. Anyway, one personal problem I may have had with this film is that Trepte and Moya are both actors that I do not really like that much. But it's all subjective. The Italian actress in the center of it all i do not even known, but I have liked Georg Friedrich for quite a while and I wish he could have had more screen time.

Anyway, this is the story of two young men during difficult phases in their lives and their loneliness, frustration and lack of direction results in them committing a terrible crime, namely abducting a clerk from the local supermarket. But after they did, they are just as clueless not only when it comes to their lives, but also in terms of what to do with the hostage now. Obviously money was never a factor here, it all resulted from boredom. Through unlucky coincidence (for the captors), the woman's boyfriend gets on their trail and the situation escalates completely quickly afterward. I think this was already the third time I watched this film and I still like it. I believe the script here is the biggest strength as especially the subtle parts about one character's homosexuality were done extraordinarily well. There are more than just a few scenes that deal with this subject and somehow even give a human side to the possibly least likable character of the film. In movies with such a low quantity of characters, it's always a bit tough because those that are there need to be especially memorable, but Urthaler succeeded to that regard as well. The only thing I did not like too much was really the female protagonist's masochist tendencies as they crossed the line at times I must say and it did not feel too authentic to me. as a consequence I also did not like the ending very much. But with Rocchetti's stunning looks, I can certainly live with it nonetheless. If you enjoy watching films like the one I mentioned in the title, then this one here is certainly worth checking out. I even managed to ignore my dislike for some of the actors thanks to the interesting and tense plot. Go see it!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Even for German film, too arid and uneven
BeneCumb20 January 2015
This ca 1,5 hour film starts off well, but then, after a certain event related to a checker called Sonja, the power decreases and the scenes become protracted at times, the characters "run aground", even if their development is visible... There are some twists coming, but together with some clichés, paving the way for predictable ending (fortunately, created with versatile accomplishment). As for performances, they are good: Elisabetta Rocchetti as Sonja Ludwig Trepte as Paul, and particularly Sergej Moya as Sebastian. It is the performances that make the film more or less watchable, although there are dozens of stronger youth films available, including from Germany.

Well, on the other hand, I acknowledge that I do not belong to the target audience of the film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
It deserves better reviews
Void-Horizon1 April 2024
I'll admit that this is a dark and twisted film, and difficult to watch at times. However, I feel people are missing the whole point, and mistakenly judging it for its content, rather than its message.

Sure, the film features some truly ugly deeds and events, but that's all necessary to convey the hopelessness and abandonment experienced by too many young boys going through the sort of things these two are dealing with.

At least one of the boys is gay, and is struggling with his unrequited feelings for the other boy. That is literally tearing him apart inside, and drives him to become callous and dead inside. As a matter of fact, this film has one of the most powerful scenes of gay suffering I've ever witnessed in film. That scene alone was so well-done, and it deserves praise.

The message is about how homophobia is so toxic, and destroys gay people inside. The whole film is like a fever dream. In fact, it's that dream-like quality which feels so nostalgic to me. I have to admit, I used to dream these sorts of things when I was a closeted youth. This is exactly the sort of hopeless despair I experienced. Very few other films have ever portrayed that experience better.

To me, this message is important. I think people don't really understand how difficult being gay can actually be, and this film presents how internally destructive homophobia is. That may be difficult to accept, but it's no less true, and I think everybody needs to know it.

I guess, very few people will ever understand the internal struggle the two are going through. The film is no celebration, but a warning. Not everybody will accept that dark reminder, but I think it's important, nonetheless.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Disturbing and powerful
Mr. Bug4 August 2005
This is a disturbing and powerful first film from a woman director who did no other films before that and went to no film school. You can't tell from the film. It looks like the work of an experienced professional who knows exactly how to direct the cast and use the language of film to get the desired effects. Two teenage boys meet and strike up a friendship in a short time. They are caught stealing in a supermarket by an employee, a young woman. They are thrown out by her. They follow her home... In no time the boys and we, the audience, enter another world as Jeffrey does in "Blue Velvet". A disturbing world of the human mind where the lines between victim and perpetrator, right and wrong, the normal and the abnormal start to dissolve. The film is deeply disturbing because it goes to extremes, but stays believable, even plausible till the end. The cast is excellent throughout. No doubt this film will be controversial which might cost it the main prize here at Locarno. But on day one we have already seen what might be the most important film in the competition this year.
37 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Flawed but interesting German kidnapping film
lazarillo13 April 2014
This flawed but interesting movie is about two teenage German boys who attend the same private school, but are from very different social classes. They embark on a decidedly homoerotic friendship with the wealthier but less bisexual of the two becoming the dominant partner. When the rich boy is insulted by a female liquor store clerk (Elizabetta Rochetti) after she catches him shop-lifting, the pair impulsively decide to abduct her and hold her captive in an abandoned warehouse owned by the rich kid's father. But their seemingly helpless victim finds a way to drive a wedge between her two volatile adolescent captors. . .

This story is quite believable in the bi-curious relationship between the two adolescents (even if both actors look a little long in the tooth for these roles). The class dynamic is also very interesting. I didn't quite buy the psychological resourcefulness of the woman, however, but I would blame in on the character on the page rather than the actress. Elizabetta Rochetti was memorable as the sexy blonde in Dario Argento's "Do You Like Hitchcock?", but she's done other things like this and "The Embalmer. She goes through a lot of acting paces in this film (even if it's not very believable a single character WOULD go through all these paces). She gets kidnapped after some unsatisfying sex with her boyfriend sends her down to the laundry room to, uh, finish the job in a sexy masturbation scene. Then she's a believable victim who suffers a great deal of humiliation from her sexually confused captors. And finally she's a sexy femme fatale who turns the table.

This movie kind of reminded me of the recent British film "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" (with Gemma Aterton in the Rochetti role). This movie makes the bisexual/gay male captors confused adolescents, and functions better as a "coming-of-age" film, but that film was more generally believable. Both are certainly worth seeing though
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
They should have given this movie's budget to Alan Brown
jm107011 April 2014
How does a movie like this even get made, when there are dozens of extremely talented directors who can't make movies because there's no money? Regardless of how little it cost to make this one, it was too much.

The two kids are very good actors, but their characters are the most obnoxious thugs I've seen in ages and should have been killed off early. But then we would have been left alone with the duck-lipped Italian woman and her gross, greasy German boyfriend, and God knows: NOBODY deserves such a fate.

Watching this movie is torture! I felt like I was tied in that chair with Duckwoman for 95 minutes. The ONLY interesting thing about this movie is that her armpit hair didn't grow even a millimeter during her days of captivity. Now, does that sound like a movie worth watching?
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed