Black Widower (TV Movie 2006) Poster

(2006 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
A Movie About A Local Man Accused Of Murdering His Wife
Phill-132 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Spoiler #1: My only complaint, was that the exterior shots were not filmed here, in Anderson, Indiana, so it kind of spoils parts of the film for us local residents.

Spoiler #2: When Mr. Amos allegedly killed his 3rd wife in Detroit, MI, he was 53-years old. Mr. Lipper looks like he's under 30, while Mr. Amos pretty much looked his age. You know, dark-haired, graying at the temples, well-tanned.

Being a life-long resident of this town, I am acquainted with some of the participants of this case, but not all of them. We do have over 53,000 residents, so it's kind of hard to know everyone. Regardless, the case, as portrayed in the Lifetime movie, was pretty accurate in most aspects. Mr. Lipper's portrayal of Mr. Amos was very good, although he was way too young--(see spoiler #2 above). Still the film is not bad if it's type. As of this writing, the local police and prosecutors still haven't re-opened the cases involving Mr. Amos' first two wives, nor of the death of his mother. Too bad. My mother and grandmother used to shop at Mrs. Toles' (Mr. Amos' mother) flower shop. Anyway, it's a pretty good film. The only reasons I rated it a 5/10 was because of the spoilers. To non-residents, these spoilers shouldn't matter, so, if you enjoy this genre, watch it and enjoy. I recommend it.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Not real
Christiboze2 October 2007
I went to high school with Ed Amos. I worked at the same General Motors plant as Ed. I knew all three wives. This movie only scrapes the surface of the lives of the people involved. As was said before in another comment: no body in Anderson was interviewed, Ed did not run for Mayor, he had filed in the primary and then Saundra was found dead and he withdrew. Why did the movie leave out his college love interest died falling from a balcony, his parents house mysteriously burnt to the ground after being for sale after he inherited it. His sister's husband had a mysterious stroke while jogging and Ed studied Pharmacy in College. I wish someone would really investigate all the things surrounding Ed and then write a book. What a mystery!!!!!!!!!
35 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Black Widower **1/2 When The Obvious isn't that Bad
edwagreen28 March 2006
Ed Amos is a good looking guy. He is a GM executive. He has money and is very popular. He is even the Republican candidate for mayor in a small Indiana town. Trouble is that Amos' 3 wives all died suddenly under very mysterious circumstances as well as his mother.

Isn't it obvious that something is terribly wrong?

Ed is such a charmer that he has literally been able to get away with murder for all these years. His latest mother-in-law complains that something is wrong. Later on, we find out that she has been meeting him secretly and knew him before he married her daughter. What's going on here?

By the way, did he drop out of the mayor's race when wife #2 died? (She was also a closet Democrat who privately joked that she'd vote for the opposition.)

A prosecutor arrives on the scene who decides to take the bull by the horns and go for murder 1. At one point, the prosecutor announces that her husband died of heart disease. Ironically, he was a cardiologist! I began to wonder about her.

Nevertheless, she uncovers the way that Ed did away with wife #3 and most likely the other ladies as well. Pretty intriguing.

This is a true story and Ed is serving a life sentence. He was never brought to trial in the other 3 deaths.
16 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A very untrue story about real people
freekeffect6 April 2006
As a person closer to this story than I care to divulge, I can say that this movie is hardly a true story. Ed Amos did kill 4 people (at least) and is serving a life sentence. However, the movie itself makes a mockery of the real people involved and it makes me sick to my stomach that the producers of this movie would claim it to be based on a true story. Not because it is not "based" on a true story, but because by labeling it as such, every single person who watches this movie and does not have access to the real story will assume every moment of it to have actually taken place. The reality is that it is a nearly entirely fictional film that uses the names of actual people. Not a single interview was conducted before production . That said, I do not know what else I could have expected from the Lifetime network. Families of the deceased deserved better.
33 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An incredible way of disposing of one's wives
clanciai14 April 2024
Who could believe anything bad about this brilliant businessman, an executive at General Motors, a golden boy admired by everybody and who had an amazing way with women, but when his third wife dies by just dropping off after a night of orgies there has been one dead wife too much, since all of them brought him lots of very much desired money by their demission. But how did he do it, if he did it? That's the object of the investigation here, and there are a lot of flashbacks into his past and his past wives, and two of those cases were never resolved or even reopened. But the third one was just one too many.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Y'a well...
kfnbrndxz6 February 2022
I clicked not knowing what to expect and then recognized local spots! Ottawa lol... an American story told in the parking lot of a Canadian Tire Store... so funny....
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Depressing
nightroses5 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I didn't think the entire film was true to the real events, although it was based on a true story. Loosely based on a true story more like. I can't comment on the real story because I've not heard about it but will comment on this particular film. The acting was not that good and the music was dreary. The write-up explained that the older cases on the former wives and his own mother's deaths have never been reopened. That sounds very shocking, as no justice was done for them. The killer was put away for killing the third wife but not for the other people he killed.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Disappointing Film
whpratt117 August 2007
Loved the film "Black Widow", which had a very tricky plot and held my interest from beginning to end. In this film there are many tell tale signs just who the killer is but at the same time it keeps you guessing just who is responsible for these murders. There are some very attractive gals that the Widower was able to catch in his web. The story makes references to some exceptionally forbidden subjects concerning a female and can be offensive to many people. This subject was addressed in a court of law in one of the scenes and this gave the jury something to think about. This film was a big disappointment and held my interest for a short period of time and that is all I have to say about this film.
5 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed