"Doctor Who" Planet of Fire: Part One (TV Episode 1984) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Not That Hot But Is Engaging
Theo Robertson31 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Refers To All Four Episodes . Spoilers On the Island of Lanzarote Professor Howard Foster is curious about a metal artifact containing a triangular symbol . A long way away on the Planet of Sarn this symbol has particular significance to those known as " chosen ones "

After the breathless and sometimes brainless Resurrection Of The Daleks this is a definite change of pace and doesn't feel the need to squash 20 billion ideas in to four 25 minute episodes . Plot wise it's no great shakes and features one of DOCTOR WHO's forays in to the realms of the dangers of religion . The lack of a radical premise shouldn't be taken as a criticism because the story's function is to introduce a new companion while getting rid of an old one . So hello Perpugilliam Brown an American botany student who is visual Viagra so any red blooded male member of the audience won't notice or care if Nicola Bryant can act or not and goodbye to ... hmmm that ginger bloke . Actually it's also goodbye to the robotic companion Kamelion but since everyone has forgotten he's existed in the first place it's very debatable if it counts as companion . There's also the need to bring back The Master once a season and nows as good a rime as any to bring him back

JNT loved his " Special guest star " casting and here he indulges it by bringing in well known Hammer scream queen Barbara Shelley and Peter Wyngarde who was a household name as the title character of JASON KING whose acting career was ruined by a visit to a public toilet . As you may imagine the characters are rather stereotypical with people portrayed as bland religious zealots or heretic victims . The cast aren't able to inject much towards the rather one note cyphers but no one is outstandingly bad . One noticeable aspect to the production is that it's obvious - far too obvious - is that the Island resort of Lanzarote doubles for the volcanic planet of Sarn . Why not have a story set in Lanzarote with an alien planet being studio bound and set another story in England cutting to Sarn ? This would be a much more effective contrast

Planet Of Fire isn't exceptional but is one of those consistent and engaging stories that made up the bulk of DOCTOR WHO stories over three decades . An average story from this period also shows how enjoyable the underrated Davison era was and with his finale a dark age for the series was about to begin
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Episode number wrong
furpurse30 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Resurrection of the Daleks has 4 parts not 2. season order is off because of this mistake All this is a bit complicated for me to edit

It should be E11 - 14 Resurrection of the Daleks Parts 1-4, E15 - 18 Planet of Fire Parts 1-4 , E19 - 22 The Caves of Androzani Parts 1 - 4 And finally Colin Baker the 6th Doctors first episode series E23 - 26 The Twin Dilemma Parts 1 - 4 ending season 21
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Feeling the Heat
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic13 April 2020
Review of all 4 parts:

This story is really good. It is not one of the top classics but it is thoroughly entertaining and very good quality.

The arrival of Peri as a companion is done very well really. Peri is not a favourite companion of mine at all as they seem to insist on making her scream a lot, be helpless and often annoying. Right from the start those tendencies are apparent but somehow in this story she comes across better. I feel her first 2 stories are higher quality productions with better writing (especially the tremendous Caves of Androzani) and she has better chemistry with the 5th Doctor than with 6th Doctor because they insist on making her bicker and get bullied by 6 whereas she gets on nicely with 5. I must mention she looks very attractive in this too haha. But more to the point I think she performs better and is written better. She is quite amusing.

The storylines with Turlough and Kamelion are very interesting and come to a conclusion here in a decent way. Davison himself is on usual excellent form and Ainley is entertaining as the Master.

Support cast members also add quality in a few cases, Peter Wyngarde especially who is a really classy, charismatic presence.

The story overall is solid and has some fun as well as some peril.

It slows down a little in Part 3 but it really is of strong quality throughout.

My ratings: Parts 1, 2 & 4 - 9/10, Part 3 - 8.5/10. Overall - 8.88/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Is it hot? No it's more like a mild morning in March.
Sleepin_Dragon27 September 2020
The Doctor lands on Lanzarote, where a strange article has been found, he also encounters a new friend.

On the plus side, Lanzarote looks amazing, perfect landscape for filming, and some of the sets look quite nice. I'm afraid that's where the positives end, this isn't particularly good.

Nichola Bryant is a beautiful woman, she lasts all of five minutes before she strips off and starts screaming and whining, not a favourite companion of mine, she needed a better start, it was clear what was expected of her. Bryant would be much better served in later episodes. Some of the acting I find woeful, and I don't just mean Kamelion, who surely was one of the worst ideas of all time.

I wish I could give a more positive review, but Part one is poor, 5/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed