"The Golden Girls" Dorothy's Prized Pupil (TV Episode 1987) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
As good today, as it's always been!
Aroura646 June 2020
I have just watched this episode and feel compelled to comment. Golden Girls is all about friendship and inclusion. The actor who played Mario, was brilliant, you could tell that he had talent. I especially enjoyed the scenes with him and Bea Arthur, they both made the episode believable. Golden Girls was never about hitting the audience over the head, with hard hitting storylines, it was about escapisim and entertainment. That is why the show was so successful, and why we still cherish it today.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A future media star seen at the beginning of his career.
mark.waltz16 September 2019
Warning: Spoilers
It's obvious that there is some level of stardom ahead for the adorable Mario Lopez, a Cuban kid whom Dorothy is tutoring in creative writing. His young character seems a bit too good to be true, but taking that into consideration as well as flaws concerning immigration laws, this ends up being poignant as it shows the friendship that grows between a student and his teacher. Dorothy is loyal to Mario and perhaps promises too much, and this episode is one that definitely should have had a much needed follow up. One of the issues with sitcoms in general is that it sets up stories that the audience feels emotionally about then never revisits them. Lopez gets to show his young character as likable, funny, sad and ultimately defeated even if Dorothy tried to give him some hope. She could easily have stepped in and helped him more, but outside of adopting him, I can't think of a proper way to have ended a difficult situation that would have changed the course of the series.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Tutoring
msudude225 June 2017
This was a good episode. The only problem I found with it was the following: If Mario was such a bright student like Dorothy claims, why did he need a tutor? When I think of someone needing a tutor, I think of someone who is struggling in school. I can't think of another reason why he would need a tutor.
7 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
They just take the kid from Dorothy's house?
jespo222 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I would think that immigration would contact his parents and they would go together.... not picking the kid up at his tutors house and hauling him downtown.... never made sense to me.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Dorothy's Prized Pupil (#2.21)
ComedyFan201016 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Dorothy has a very talented student and she submits a story he wrote into a contest and he wins. But this leads to the immigration services go after him and say that he came illegally. Talking to the judge doesn't help and he has to leave. And Blanche thinks that Rose lost her earrings so Rose offers to be her servant, but then it turns out Blanche lost them herself.

Once again they touch a serious topic. And I am surprised that it didn't end up in happy ending. In a way it is good because it makes the show more unpredictable instead of cheesy. Only with such an ending it would have been good if they mention Mario again.

Was fun to see Mario Lopez in his pre Saved by the Bell years. And it was funny to realize that Schwarzenegger, whose movie he was watching in the theatre didn't get to the highlights of his career yet as well!
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This rose has thorns.
Sleepin_Dragon18 April 2023
Rose manages to lose Blanche's earrings and her own watch, to make amends Rose offers to play Blanche's personal servant. Dorothy enters her student Mario's essay for a prize, he wins it, but draws attention from The Immigration department.

It's one of those first class episodes that combines humour and sadness, the best combination of all, it works very well. It doesn't go in the direction I was expecting, I thought the story would revolve around Mario pinching the jewellery, but it's totally different.

The best moment has to be that scene where Rose confronts Blanche with the missing jewellery.

For 1987 this show really was ahead of its time, not many comedy shows would have used immigrating and deportation as a theme, but it works incredibly well. I really liked Mario's character, nice young actor.

Brilliant, 9/10.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Disappointing and Tasteless
lalisachaibon6 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This episode does an amazing job at doing the impossible, by making Dorothy completely and utterly unlikeable. Usually, I enjoy the end of the episode where the girls all get to relax and reflect on what happened to them, and usually, they move on.

In this episode this works against the girls and the show itself, it makes it that much clearer that Dorothy's interest and care for Mario was fleeting. She didn't truly care what happened to him, but she sure did seem fine being pampered and fawned over when he left. Even though she is almost entirely at fault for what happened and was the only adult present who could have helped Mario but didn't. She never tried to get him a lawyer to make him a case, did the bare minimum to help, and she moved on incredibly quickly.

The concept of this episode should have been scrapped from the beginning. 25 minutes is nowhere near the time needed to explore the vast issues with the immigration system in the United States. I understand this episode was made in the 1980s. That doesn't prevent me from finding an issue with how they, once again, treated other peoples suffering like a fun little accessory/adventure to one of the girls' lives.

This is just another example of 80s/90s shows with a white-only cast, and the occasional person of color written in for all the white people at home to feel a momentary bit of pity for.

If nothing else, I can always appreciate this shows well meaning attempts at telling a deeper story.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Annoyingly wrong
colorsflashing13 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This episode has bothered me for years, mainly because of the incorrect way immigration cases are presented, and because of the inaction on the part of Dorothy to actually help Mario. First, it is unlikely, especially in Miami, that a deportation hearing would be held the day after the INS picked someone up. Further, it is highly unlikely that the Immigration Judge would have ordered the boy deported the next day. Most judges would give the person time to find a lawyer. Even if he didn't, in all likelihood he would have given the boy "voluntary departure," which in those days could be granted for months at a time, with the possibility of extending it. Second, why didn't Dorothy get Mario together with an immigration attorney? It is ridiculous that she thought that going into court with a bunch of emotional statements was going to "save" him (although again it might've made the judge even more disposed to a grant of voluntary departure). While it was nice of her to point out that Arnold Schwarzenegger is an immigrant, he came to the United States legally. Mario did not (or so we are given to understand). Other than both being potential immigrants to the United States, there is no other similarity. Her statement to Mario "There are legal ways to keep you here, and tomorrow we'll find them.," is a day late and a dollar short. Since Mario has to leave the next day, she says, "Then I'll do it myself, and we'll get you back here. I promise." That's a hell of a promise to make, given her ignorance on the subject. When he tells her he'll miss her and never forget her, she responds, "You won't have time to. You'll be back here before you know it." Great. So when he's back in his country with the vain hope she has given him, then what? While I think it is nice that the show tried to address a serious topic with a sympathetic immigrant, I believe they would have served the viewing public better by showing Mario taking intelligent steps to fight for himself. Dorothy should have found him a lawyer, then they could have a scene where the lawyer gives Mario his legal options. That would have been more educational and engaging.
13 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Built around a deeply troubling trope
CubsandCulture1 August 2022
You can complain that the immigration case isn't very realistic and you could complain that Dorothy doesn't seem as invested in Mario's fate as she could have been. Both of those issues I chalk up to this being a sit-com and the form limiting both realism and dramatic depth.

No my problem with the episode is Mario's plight is held in sympathy *only* because he is a gifted student. I'm sorry but the tired, the poor, and the huddled masses also get messed over by the US cruel immigration system and Americans' xenophobia. They deserve our consideration too.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Dorothy is an awful person in this
angelakscudder21 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
She gets a kid DEPORTED and it's like nothing to her. He literally gets kicked out the country because of something she does and she just shrugs her shoulders and moves on. These women did more to save the dolphins from tuna factories than they did for poor, sweet Mario Lopez. I hate this episode.
9 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed