"Gunsmoke" A Noose for Dobie Price (TV Episode 1968) Poster

(TV Series)

(1968)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Season 13 Closes with A Strong Guest Star
wdavidreynolds4 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Season 13 ends with a story where Marshal Matt Dillon and the people of Dodge City are preparing for a hanging. The condemned man is named Dobie Price. The hangman's job is available, but the Marshal has not found anyone among the locals willing to complete the task.

A stranger named Elihu "Huey" Gorman rides into town and expresses interest in the job. Gorman does not care so much about the money the job pays ($100, which would have been a significant amount in those times). He wants to see Dobie Price, who is his cousin, die, because of a past incident. Marshal Dillon refuses to give Gorman the job, since he is related to Price, and Gorman is emotionally invested in the task.

Price's gang rides into Dodge and breaks him out of jail. Festus was minding the jail, and he is severely injured. Gorman tells Matt he knows where Dobie Price and the gang are going, and there is no way the Marshal will be able to find them without Gorman's help.

Matt agrees to allow Gorman to help him find the gang. Oddly, the Marshal gives Gorman a deputy's badge and agrees to pay him two dollars per day.

The remainder of the story involves the pursuit of the gang by Gorman and Dillon and the uneasy tension that exists between the duo. After all, Gorman is an outlaw and was admittedly part of Price's gang before Price abandoned Gorman during an escape. The task is made more difficult by distracting circumstances encountered along the way.

In some ways, this story is similar to the "Us Haggens" story way back in Season 8 when the Festus Haggen character is first introduced. Marshal Dillon is pursuing a criminal with a member of the criminal's family joining the pursuit. Festus Haggen was much more like Elihu Gorman in those early episodes, too -- someone with a dubious background who was not beyond breaking the law when it suited them.

This episode is all about boisterous actor Chill Wills, who plays the Elihu Gorman character. Wills was one of those larger-than-life types of people both on screen and off. He tended to play the same kind of boorish, loud-mouthed, obnoxious, good-ol'-boy figure, whether he was playing a more comedic role, a dramatic part, or a combination of the two as he does in this story.

Wills enjoyed a long performing career starting as a vaudeville entertainer before becoming part of a singing group, which led to appearances in B-grade films. As his acting career progressed, his roles become more significant. He appeared in the films The Yearling, Giant, and The Alamo, which all received Best Picture Oscar nominations. Wills also received a Best Supporting Actor nomination for his performance in The Alamo. As television became more prominent, he accepted parts in numerous television shows, primarily in the Westerns genre.

Shug Fisher appeared in twenty-seven different Gunsmoke episodes. In this story, he is Dobie Price. This character is different than the typical Fisher character. He often portrayed characters with quirky, often-humorous traits, like the Festus Haggen character. Here, he is much more sinister with none of the "hill country" verbal qualities.

The familiar character actor Sheldon Allman plays Skeets Walden, one of the Dobie Price gang. It is worth noting that Allman provided the singing voice for television's Mr. Ed, and Chill Wills provided the voice for Francis the Talking Mule in that series of movies.

Richard C. Sarafian directed four different Gunsmoke episodes. He first directed the Season 10 episode, "Eliab's Aim." He directed the two-part "Vengeance" episodes, which were among the highlights of Season 13. His last directing effort for Gunsmoke was this episode. Sarafian built his directing career on episodic television, but his crowning achievement was (at least arguably) the classic 1971 car-chase film Vanishing Point.

Many of the Season 13 episodes recycle stories and tropes that are familiar to fans of the Westerns genre. It is fitting the season ends with this type of story. There is not much truly distinguishing in the story itself. We have seen other episodes where Matt Dillon and another character find themselves pursuing an individual or a gang leading to a more-or-less foregone conclusion.

However, a few things are distinctive about this episode. A hanging in Dodge City is unusual -- not unique, but rare. Matt being so willing to deputize Gorman is quite out of character for someone so usually cautious. The use of side stories (the line shack scene and the renegades) that do offer some Gorman character development but have little to do with the primary story seem more like time killers in the end. The fact that Festus is injured so seriously he cannot help in the pursuit of the gang is never explored.

This is certainly not among the best of the Season 13 episodes, but I think the performance by Wills lifts it to above average status.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Chill Wills at his best.
bxhanx15 June 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Chill Wills plays a former outlaw, Elihu, who goes with Matt to search for his old gang.

Along the way, the real reason for him tagging along with Matt is discovered. The interaction between Matt and Elihu is wonderful as they search for Elihu's old gang, which is being run by his cousin, Dobie. You see two seasoned actors who truly enjoy their craft and are at their best.

The main allure of this episode of Gunsmoke is that this was one of Chill Wills later roles in life. He did a fine guest appearance and it is worth watching if you are a fan of Chill. He could bring a real genuine charm to a character or bring a tough, grittiness, whichever is called for and sometimes both in the same movie or television episode. That is fully the case in this episode. His interaction with Matt at the beginning shows his earnest desire to help, he is genuine and you feel that he is a man who has made mistakes and is ready to make things right. But later, when he is around his old gang, you see the gritty side, the side that exerts complete control over a gang of ruthless men.

It is a fantastic episode on many levels and well worth watching.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Did not understand Marshal Dillon in this episode
kfo949418 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
If you happen to be a fan of Chill Wills then you might like this episode. But for the rest of us, that just like good western stories, this episode is lacking in more ways than one.

It begins when Dodge is getting ready for a hanging of prisoner Dobie Price. The Marshal is trying to find a person that will serve as hangman and runs across a volunteer named Elihu Gorman (Chill Wills). This Elihu Gorman is a former outlaw that is also Dobie Price's cousin. Gorman wants to see cousin Price hang for some past transgression made against him.

But before any of that can happen, Dobie's gang breaks him out of jail. With Festus injured, Gorman tells Matt he knows where Dobie is going and will lead him. For some unknown reason, Matt gives him a deputy badge.

They set off on an adventure to find Dobie. Along the way they get into a few problems all related to Gorman. Till at last Gorman finds the hideout where Dobie is located.

This is not one of the strongest episodes. Could not really get into the character of Gorman since Matt already knew he was an outlaw and could change his colors at any moment. It's a plot played out many times in the series. The only thing that has changed is instead of taking Festus -the Marshal picks a known outlaw--- he has just met, that is the cousin of the person wanted. That is hard to comprehend.
14 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
From the start...
stonecuttr4 July 2022
In the beginning, the conductor said, "Next stop, Silver Springs", but where Matt Dillon was standing, the sign said Sulphur Springs.. It was kinda funny that no one really noticed that.. but I guess Hollywood is crazy like that........🤣
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed