"Gunsmoke" Gone Straight (TV Episode 1957) Poster

(TV Series)

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Matt Dillon's Scapegoat
wdavidreynolds3 January 2022
Parker is a member of a cattlemen's association in New Mexico who has been deputized and given the mission of riding to Dodge City to deliver a warrant to Matt Dillon. The warrant is for the arrest of Jim Glass. Glass reportedly now lives in Tascosa, which is a two-day ride from Dodge. Marshal Dillon was chosen for this task because Glass is supposed to be extremely fast with a gun. There is no picture of Glass, but the deputy provides the Marshal with a description.

(One question about this warrant that is never addressed is what the charges are against Glass. Parker says he rode with Billy the Kid, but beyond that dubious claim, there are no specific charges mentioned.)

Matt is not crazy about the idea of being used in this manner, but he is duty-bound to execute the warrant. Matt and Chester Goode ride to Tascosa where they find more than one person that fits the description of Jim Glass.

One of those people is Nate Trimble. Since arriving in Tascosa a couple of years ago, he has been a leading, model citizen. He owns the saloon, has married a great woman, and they have settled into a happy life together. Trimble has even built a much-needed schoolhouse for the town.

Trimble hired Mike Postil -- who worked for a shady rancher named Gunter as a henchman -- to tend bar at the saloon. Postil welcomed the opportunity to do something that did not involve gun fighting. Unfortunately, Gunter is not happy with this arrangement and tries to pressure Postil to return to work for him. Both Postil and Gunter also happen to fit the description of Jim Glass.

Carl Betz plays Nate Trimble in this story. This is the only Gunsmoke role for Betz. Betz fits the part well because of his handsome looks and casual demeanor. Trimble may be the wanted man, but he has been a model citizen since arriving in Tascosa. The character is friendly, but he is also somewhat aloof and suspicious when questioned. Betz plays the role well. He would soon begin playing Dr. Alex Stone on The Donna Reed Show.

This appearance is also the only series involvement for actress Marianne Stewart. She plays Nate's wife.

Joe De Santis had played Mr. Hawtree in one of the most brutally gruesome Gunsmoke episodes -- the early Season 1 story, "Home Surgery." Here he plays the villainous rancher named Gunter. De Santis made two more guest appearances in later seasons of the series.

Tige Andrews participated as a guest in two different Gunsmoke episodes, including this one where he plays the Mike Postil character. He had previously appeared in the film Mister Roberts, but most of his career was spent doing television shows. He usually appeared in dramas, but he did play a Chief Petty Officer in three episodes of Gomer Pyle, U. S. M. C. His most prominent role was as Captain Adam Greer in the series Mod Squad.

Ward Wood appears early in the story as the deputy from New Mexico named Parker. Wood's acting career was most known for the recurring role of police Lieutenant Art Malcolm on the series Mannix in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Wood was also a contributing writer for two episodes of The Rifleman.

Since most of this story takes place in Tascosa, the only Dodge City involvement occurs in the opening scene.

This is a highly enjoyable episode where the viewer is engaged until the very end despite some ethical questions about the Marshal's actions. His actions are unexpected but not completely out of character. Major Gunsmoke fans know although Marshal Dillon was normally a stickler for the rule of law, there were circumstances over the course of the series where he would take actions that might not strictly adhere to the letter of the law.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Matt believes people can change
kfo94947 June 2013
The episode opens up with a man wanting Matt to serve a warrant on Jim Glass that was issued in New Mexico. Seems that Glass is suspected in some criminal activity but the man with the warrant hints that about a hanging even though there has not been a trial. Matt is very suspicious about the contents of the warrant. The man tells Matt that Glass is living in Tascosa, which is in Texas, and he will wait in Dodge for Matt to serve the warrant. So Matt and Chester make their way to Tascosa with the only description being a six foot tall man 180 lbs., black hair and a cut along his ribs.

When in Tascosa, Matt meets three men that fit the description of the wanted Glass. With each a suspect as being the wanted man, Matt will see how each man lives and then determine the best situation for moving the warrant to the next phase.

Not really an exciting adventure but a story that is entertaining in its own way. Matt and Chester make a call that may not be correct but fits the changing times of life. Good watch.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Dillon issues a Pardon
george-84129 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A troublesome episode. Matt is enlisted to serve a New Mexico warrant for a bad guy whose apparent crime is guilt by association: two years ago he rode with Billy the Kid. A powerful cattlemen's association in New Mexico is cleaning up old business; they've sent Pat Garrity after the Kid and an obnoxious "paper deputy" delivers the warrant to Dillon, mainly because of his rep as a straight (and fast) shooter. Matt doesn't like the whole situation but feels himself duty-bound to travel to Tascosa, a TWO-DAY RIDE EACH WAY, to round up this bad guy. The only info he has: he's 6-feet tall, 180 pounds, black hair and has a scar across his ribs. Matt & Chester arrive in Las Cosas and quickly discover a number of men who meet all of the description---except for confirmation of the scar since it's a hard task to come into a Western town and start asking husky young men to take off their shirts! One of the prime suspects, Carl Betz (later Donna Reed's husband), has opened a saloon. He arrived suspiciously two years ago but in the interim has become a solid citizen. He's gotten the growing town to build a schoolhouse and has given a job to another potential suspect, a guy named Postil, who wants to get away from working as a hired gunman for the real local bad guy: a rancher who it is made clear is not above rustling and other criminal acts. This rancher also meets the description---an important fact as shall be seen shortly. Matt & Chester are boarded and fed by Betz's sweet wife and it rapidly becomes clear to Matt (a bit TOO rapidly, but this is only a 30-minute show) that even if Betz is the wanted man, he's turned a new leaf and has now become a paragon of virtue in his new life. Advance to the confrontation scene: the rancher rides into town with some henchmen to force Postil to return to his old job. Matt, Chester, Betz and Postil confront them, some shots are fired and Betz is wounded and the rancher is killed. Chester notices the scar on Betz's chest but Dillon quickly insists to all concerned that the rancher is the wanted man. He assures Chester that they can return and report the death of the man on the warrant. Chester is clueless at first but then realizes the righteousness of Matt's "pardon." Betz isn't going to talk, of course. He thanks Matt and returns to his new life as a small town Western "saint." By now we know that the scriptwriters will sometimes allow Dillon to go well beyond the bounds of the law in seeking justice. But this one goes even further beyond. All we know about the rancher's "crimes" comes from Betz, who cynics would argue has reason enough to incriminate others in trying to avoid justice. It's not entirely clear WHAT Betz did exactly, beyond hanging out with a notorious outlaw. But the law is the law and even though Dillon doesn't have much respect for the cattlemen's association and their flunky who delivered the warrant, he sure takes a lot upon himself in "pardoning" Betz and forever condemning the dead rancher with whatever unnamed crimes appear in the warrant. A mixed bag, this episode, in my opinion. I would have preferred if Matt brought back the real target, while assuring him that he'd put in a good word for him with the judge. (Of course, in another episode a judge still condemns a may to hang even after Matt puts in a bunch of good words, so maybe Dillon remembers that in making his decision HERE.)
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
More Interesting than Suspenseful
dougdoepke9 November 2011
An episode that generates more interest than suspense or tension. Matt is obliged to travel to New Mexico to serve a warrant on a wanted man. The trouble is two men answer the one description, so Matt can't be sure which is the right party. Then too, both men appear to be leading honest lives, so what's Matt to do.

It's an interesting idea, guessing which man is the former outlaw. However, the plot gets pretty complicated (and contrived) once genuine bad man Gunter and his gang enter the picture. I suspect they're added, along with the rather dislikable Parker, to make the ending more acceptable. Once again, however, the series leaves us pondering an important moral question— namely, the relation between justice and the law.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Marshal Dillon Serves A Warrant
StrictlyConfidential14 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
(*Deputy Sheriff Parker quote*) - I've gotta warrant here for the arrest of Jim Glass."

"Gone Straight" was first aired on television February 9, 1957.

Anyway - As the story goes - Hunting down an ex-member of Billy the Kidd's gang, Marshal Dillon finds his quarry has reformed and is living a respectable life under an assumed name.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed