"Harry O" Elegy for a Cop (TV Episode 1975) Poster

(TV Series)

(1975)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Goodbye Manny
MissClassicTV25 February 2016
Elegy for a Cop begins with the somber voice of Harry: "My friend Manny Quinlan called in sick, took the day off, and came north to Los Angeles on family business." There's a lot of Harry's narration in this episode, more so than in others, and it's another example of great first person narrative. The incomparable David Janssen is just pitch perfect when he voices Harry's thoughts.

Manny is ambushed in a run-down apartment building. His death scene is done so well. Henry Darrow played it perfectly, not over-the-top. After paying his respects at the gravesite, Harry goes to a bar and buys a bottle of tequila, writing "Manny Quinlan" on the label, and tells the bartender not to open it yet.

The middle section of the episode sags a bit. The interplay between Harry and Lt. Trench is great as usual. But Sal Mineo playing the bad guy and Kathy Lloyd as Manny's drug-addicted niece were less interesting.

This episode ends with an absolutely wonderful, really touching scene where Harry goes back into the bar alone and finally opens the bottle of tequila that he had purchased earlier. Harry is both sentimental and a realist. And we see this in the perfectly written ending. He had talked about private grief. And several of his voice-overs had begun with "my friend Manny." But in the end when the bartender asks about the bottle of tequila, Harry's response is, "Nobody lives forever." Although Harry is at heart a caring romantic, he's also a world-weary former cop who knows human nature and has experienced the disappointments of reality.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A wasted opportunity.
kindofblue-782211 October 2022
This episode should have been excellent. Unfortunately, they used a significant amount of material from the shows pilot.

This reduces the quality of the whole story.

A great story that's totally wasted.

Manny deserved a better send off than this.

Things start well when original material is used but it descends into farce when they start to rehash and reuse so much film from the pilot.

The pilot wasn't best story or introduction to Harry O. It was laboured. Therefore the material in this episode is obviously laboured.

Why couldn't they resist the Temptations to save money and give Manny a send off he deserved?
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
STUNTS
fitzsimmons-062331 June 2023
I looked @ all the cast & credits & I must say...I didn't see any credits for Stunts.

I can't believe the actors...especially David Janssen...rode those motorcycles. Someone had to be listed for stunts.

I luv Harry O & tape every episode.

However...I think this episode was WAY over the top for Janssen.

I think it was silly & VERY out of character.

I think it was a very bad way to end Henry Darrow out of the show. It was sooooo fast and pointless.

They could have had a combo episode of Trench replacing him and him moving to another area or maybe being killed helping Harry on a case.

It was just so bad & silly.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
God awful and confusing
spunkins1 January 2023
Makes little sense with the rehashed crap from the even worse pilot.

In fact, this whole series is just mind bendingly confusing, incoherent and inconsistent.

Many of the secondary characters have their dialog based on gibberish.

After the move to LA, it gets even more bizarre and the wise-cracking new lieutenant is just gratingly irritating.

He moves into a condo, in LA... but a few episodes later he is back in his beach house, along with the boat, again. Did he have it all moved from San Diego? A total lack of continuity.

Plus the weird manner in which an old guy seemingly manages to pull a string of girls barely old enough to be his grand daughters. 16-19 year olds apparently loved greying old dudes back then.

I feel like I'm watching an "acid-trip" detective series... maybe that is what is actually meant to represent?
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed