"Maverick" Benefit of the Doubt (TV Episode 1961) Poster

(TV Series)

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Let's Give Robert Colbert the benefit of the doubt
schappe15 September 2023
After James Garner left the series after the third season, (he's in one fourth season episode, 'Hadley's Hunters' that had actually been filmed for the third season), Warner Brothers thrashed around looking for a replacement from the actors they had under contract.

First they created a British cousin of the Mavericks, Beau, (actually he came for Texas just like Bret and Bart but was sent to Britain to be educated and learn a British accident), played by Roger Moore, late of 'The Alaskans'. He had the light comic touch the role needed and some of the scripts they gave him to do were pretty good, (so good they'd already been done on the studio's other western shows). Roger got an offer to return to England to do 'The Saint' and Warners again had to find a replacement.

They created a third Maverick brother "Brent" and assigned Robert Colbert, who had appeared several times in warner's shows and acquitted himself well. He was about the same size as James Garner and bore a vague resemblance from a distance, so they put him in Garner's old outfit, (which had been Errol Flynn's outfit in 'Silver River'). The public reaction, (and those in the other reviews here, was completely negative and after two shows 'Brent Maverick' disappeared and it became the Bart Maverick Show starring Jack Kelly.

I thought the Brent Maverick episodes were pretty good, better than several on the non-Brent episodes this season. I also found Robert Colbert a very agreeable performer. Like Jack Kelly, he lacked Jim Garner's bread smile and Oklahoma twang. He seemed less of a rogue at heart. (Garner would have made a great used car salesman.). He didn't have the precision of the stage-trained Kelly's performances. But he did have warm sincerity to his acting that I liked. I think if they'd continued with the character he might have grown on people. (It might have helped if they also made him a cousin or a nephew, not a never-before mentioned brother and given him his own distinctive outfit.)

Colbert got a second chance at series stardom a few years later in 'Time Tunnel', not a show that required warm earnestness. He final found a spot in the soaps, where such qualities were more useful.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Now, Which Arm Was It?
dougdoepke6 July 2008
So who has the money or, as it turns out, who's pulling the strings behind the money grab. Brent Maverick (Robert Colbert) doesn't have much to do, except hold his arm and watch others maneuver for the stolen 40 thousand. The episode starts out with a bang and gets really interesting when the sheriff decides he should have the loot instead of the mail office robbers. However, things soon get really complicated, so you may need a score card to keep up. Certainly, no one can accuse the script of being too predictable. What with the many twists, Maverick spends half his time explaining who did what and why, which doesn't help the pacing. Colbert plays the part with none of the usual sly Maverick humor, so don't look for the expected chuckles. Question-- Brent gets an arm wound early on which he sort of holds, but it's one of those miraculous Hollywood injuries that apparently cause no blood nor pain. As they used to say, "Only in the movies". Average entry at best, with an energetic turn by veteran actor Trevor Bardette as the way-station agent.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
No wonder Bret and Bart didn't talk much about this brother
mlorenzen-15 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
His second episode and he still tries to out manuevre someone with a gun drawn him by turning around and slowly moving.

Tired lines, tries to hard to deliver, too stoic, too much trying to be the hero.

This episode really suffers from poor writing. The main girl's beau, dead. Her sister, killed. At the end... happy as a lark!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
yet another maverick
sandcrab27727 December 2019
This series is all about con jobs from the first episode .. this episode has brent maverick broke from playing poker and put on the stage out of town ... then the twists begin ... every one in the cast is working very hard to get their hands on 7 thousand in stolen cash ... mort mills shows his true colors and gets it in the end ... warner brothers had the market sewed up in the days these series were made so they could sell you anything but truth
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed