"Maverick" Day of Reckoning (TV Episode 1958) Poster

(TV Series)

(1958)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Texas cowhands are bad losers
bkoganbing15 August 2018
This episode of Maverick finds James Garner in one of those Kansas cow towns where the herds from Texas come up to meet the railroads in the 1870. It's a plot situation for a gazillion westerns on the big and small screen.

Anyway the cowhands play a lousy game of poker which is where Garner cleans up. But here Marshal Will Thorson whacks one of them with a gun butt before he can do Maverick any harm. Only he whacks too hard the cowboy dies.

Which leads to the gunslinger who is on the trail drive as a ramrod gunning down Thorson. After that the situation deteriorates until the inevitable showdown. Veteran character actor Mort Mills is a man eager to show off his skill a gunhand. He's a mean sadistic sort, no kind of hero.

James Garner is grimly cynical about the whole affair. In the end he does the heroic thing. You'll have to watch the episode to se what happens.

This town sure could have used John Wayne for a marshal.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An Unnecessary 'Psychological" Thriller
jtaulard22 January 2023
An Unnecessary 'Psychological" Thriller which was a type of show trying to gain traction in the 1960's. Cowardice redeemed, but up to then, explanations and long faces displayed the fear and 'unmanlyness.'

And that is another theme: be a man. I concur, agree and encourage being a man. We certainly never saw much on display in our day, though it is there. David told Solomon as much: Be a man.

Anyway, the whole thing is improbable, but since it is Maverick and I am an irrational fan, I always think people should see it. The closeups of the defeated men are a credit to the camera and lighting crew. The extras of both the 'filthy cowhands' and 'respectable townsfolk' are well cast, as usual.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not at all like other Maverick episodes
FlushingCaps19 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
This is a hard episode to gauge because it was so unlike other episodes of this series.

It begins with Maverick winning a hand of poker and being accused of cheating by the losing cowhand. Bret has both hands on the table, away from his gun and the man appears about to draw. He does but before he can shoot the sheriff buffaloes him on the back of the head, just in time.

The next morning, Maverick observes the town is too quiet. He is told the cowhand died and his buddies, let by the head man of the cattle drive, are out to get--not Maverick, but the sheriff who struck the blow that accidentally killed the man.

It turns into a drama about how it seems nobody in the town wants to fight these cowhands, afraid they will destroy either their business place, or the whole town. It seems almost every man in town wanted to let the cowhands do whatever they want, fearful of the havoc they would cause if anyone opposed them.

One man chose to fight with words printed, not in a newspaper but in a broadside, a sort-of 19th Century blog, if you will. This caused the cowhands to return after they had gotten their revenge, and go after him.

Bret wound up trying to convince the citizens to do more, and trying to convince the cowhands to not destroy things.

There was even a shoot-out near the end, just the type of thing you almost never saw on this series.

Throughout the episode, I kept thinking how it seemed like this was a script written for a Bonanza where one of the Cartwrights was visiting another town, or The Rifleman, or some other series. It had none of the usual Maverick plot twists or action.

That doesn't mean it was a bad episode, just so different from what Maverick fans expect. ADD--I've since watched the next two episodes and they also seem like generic Western scripts that were not like most Mavericks. OK shows, but not Maverick-like.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Day Of Reckoning
jcolyer12292 February 2016
When Bret is accused of cheating and called a "tinhorn," he responds that he believes in peace and quiet. When the marshal is murdered, a cowardly printer circulates an article with intentions of going to the governor in Topeka. Trail hands threaten to destroy the town unless the printer is handed over. Bret wants to get out before hell breaks loose but is unable to. The scared printer regrets his actions, while Bret refers to himself a "fence-straddler." Bret chastises the printer. The expression "tree the town" is tossed around. Jeanne Willes as Lil tells us what cowboys are really like, that they are nothing like they are portrayed in the east. Even in this serious episode, Bret's biting humor shines through.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Horrible episode!
golfalphatango-995312 November 2020
Maverick is uncharacteristically such a wuss!! Hated this episode!
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed