"Maverick" The Quick and the Dead (TV Episode 1957) Poster

(TV Series)

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Just What the Doc(tor) Ordered
sammysdad9720 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
No spoilers here. None necessary. Very enjoyable entry in the "Maverick" series - in the top 10 for my money. Gerald Mohr (as always) is very, very good. This was the first of his two appearances on "Maverick" as the Doc and was by far the best of the two. (He appeared 7 times in all with this episode being his best in show.)

I've singled out Mohr mainly because he is a particular favorite of mine. I'm always happy to see him and since he appeared in just about every TV show of note (including the best Westerns of the era) from the late '50's until his death in 1968 he shows up quite a lot but rarely does he get a role that suits him as well as this one did.

Another favorite of mine is Sam Buffington who is also featured in this episode. He plays Ponca Brown here with his unique style that I can't quite do justice to. He's young, balding, rumpled, sly, amusing and intelligent. (The nearest "match" to his persona that I can come up with is a young "McHale's Navy" Tim Conway.) IMDb lists 44 acting credit titles for the young Sam Buffington, many of them TV series in which he appeared multiple times (for example, "Maverick" featured him 5 times in 5 different roles - this being his best in my opinion) from 1957 to 1959. Despite his early success which, by the time of his death, included a role as a series regular on the Audie Murphy TV series "Whispering Smith" he died early in 1960 at age 28 at his own hand. His entire career spanned a period of 2 1/2 years and into those 30 months he packed quite a punch! (Too bad that he himself does not appear to have appreciated what he was able to accomplish at such a young age.) I always smile when I see him on any show that he may turn up on and this episode of "Maverick" features him at his best.

John Vivyan does just fine as the killer who has bragged about "backing down" Doc Holliday in a prior encounter and who has thereby drawn the Doc into town to put an end to this slander. Marie Windsor rounds out the main cast playing the attractive owner of the saloon in which most of this episode's action takes place and, of course, to provide a potential love interest for Bret.

You will find a synopsis of the plot elsewhere if that is of interest to you. Suffice to say that the writing is first rate, the dialog and resolution of the story are "classic Western" and if you love the genre you will be very much entertained by this episode.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Maverick: The Quick And The Dead
jcolyer122919 May 2015
Bret tracks robbers from whom he won stolen money. He ends up in Bandero at the Red Front Casino, where he meets Cora and Johnny. Johnny has the reputation of having backed down Doc Holliday. Bret takes a job as a dealer, knowing that Johnny is one of the crooks. Suddenly, Doc Holliday appears. He mistakes Bret as the one bragging about backing him down. But it was in Wichita that Doc and Bret played poker, not in Fort Griffin. Doc is superstitious. He never kills a man when he is winning, and that is how Johnny was able to back him down. Bret gets Doc into a game of blackjack and lets him win. When Doc sees the cards are marked, Bret is in trouble. Doc remarks that there are only two kinds of people in the west: the quick and the dead. Gerald Mohr makes a great Doc Holliday.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The time Bret Maverick met Doc Holliday
bkoganbing5 August 2018
This Maverick story has James Garner on a mission to clear his name as he was caught with money identified as stolen from a stagecoach robbery. The sheriff ain't believing these are gambling winnings.

The trail takes him to Marie Windsor's saloon and her dealer John Vivyan who has a big mouth and braggadocious ways. He says he backed the legendary Doc Holliday down. So when the real Doc Holliday played by Gerald Mohr shows up James Garner has an interesting dilemma. He has to keep Vivyan alive long enough to clear the Maverick name.

Marie Windsor who was the queen of noir bad girls is just as evil and scheming as on the big screen. And Mohr makes a menacing Doc Holliday.

You have to see how Maverick works this one out.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Don't Call the Doc
dougdoepke25 December 2011
Bret's trying to find three men so he can clear his name with the law. However, in terms of plot, this is just a sidelight. The real conflict is between Doc Holliday (Mohr) and card dealer Stacey (Vivyan) who's one of the men Bret's looking for. Trouble is quick-gun Holliday is also mad at Bret, so Bret's stuck between the proverbial rock and a hard place.

Mohr makes one scary gunman, in my book the entry's best feature. In fact, the outstanding cast is the most interesting part of a rather complex story. Movie buffs will recognize cult figure Marie Windsor as the casino boss. In typical Windsor fashion, she manages to be both commanding and coy, at the same time. Also, Vivyan makes a good foil for both Bret and Holliday. Note too, the sly innuendo between Bret and Cora (Windsor) as they greet a new day.

More a conventional Western than the classic Maverick brand, the narrative still manages some suspense, but is otherwise unexceptional.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This is Film Noir
caik592 July 2022
This is a repurposed Noir screenplay. Given that so many episodes of the show involve use of the genre's elements, we shouldn't be surprised to find one that seems to satisfy them all. You could change a few particulars regarding the period, the crimes, and the setting, but this could have been rewritten as a gangster movie. Fantastic!

That's all I have to say.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed