"Naked City" And a Merry Christmas to the Force on Patrol (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Great Acting, Sterling Silliphant Script, Authentic New York Locales
poetcomic114 February 2020
I could enjoy Naked City for the scenery and people alone! Amazing journey into a New York that is no more. This is yet another top Silliphant script, tight and always with little unexpected turns and characterizations of Cinema quality. The demanding role of hold up man Marco is none other than Frank Sutton of Gomer Pyle's Sergeant fame which is so sad as he was a top notch actor wasted on junk TV. The quality of Naked City acting in the small roles is stupendous - just check out the 'old lady' stealing liquor - she doesn't have much screen time but makes it unforgettable - her name is Mary Boylan. You cinema buffs may remember her as the suffering 'Mrs. Peabody' in the movie Night of the Iguana, also Annie Hall, Midnight Cowboy etc. etc. I am a new Naked City tv fan and I am up to #13 of the first season with only one real 'miss' for me. I'm canceling Netflix and henceforth binge on fine old television from the golden age.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
He'll better make it or you'll wish you've never been born
kapelusznik187 October 2013
****SPOILERS**** Attempting to knock off a mid town Manhattan liquor store results in a deadly shootout where one of the robbers Quint Butcher, Roberts Blossom, ended up fatally wounded in the exchange. There's also Det. Hal Pearlman, Michael Strong, who was gunned down by the retreating and badly wounded Batcher who's now on life support at a local mid town hospital.With Quint's accomplice and big brother Marco, Frank Sutton, in police custody he's given the third degree in telling them where his brother is or else, if Det. Pearlman died, he may well face the death penally even though he wasn't the person who pulled the trigger.

It takes a while for Let. Dan Muldoon, John McIntire, to get Marco to talk but the fact that his kid brother was shot and may well end up bleeding to death if not found and treated in time has him finally open up and tell the police where he possibly may be hiding: In a run down and deserted building in the Manhattan waterfront.It's now up to the police to find Quint before he passes away so if convicted he'll be made to face justice in Sing Sing's electric chair.

***SPOILERS*** It turned out to be a sad Christmas for Marco who sadly finds out that his kid brother Quint was found dead in his secret hiding pace on the New York City docks from loss of blood. The good news is that Quint's victim in the liquor store shooting Det. Hal Pearlman did in fact pull through and lived to see another day as well as cook up a pot of his favorite brew, coffee, for his fellow policemen at the 65th prescient. And the person who enjoyed the coffee the most is Det. James Halloran, James Franciscus, who's place Det. Pearlman took in that deadly liquor store stake out so he could spend Christmas Eve with his family.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Frank Sutton is terrific!
lor_16 November 2023
Stirling Silliphant wrote a powerful slice-of-life Christmas show for "The Naked City", giving a feel of the difficulties of the cops of the 65th Precinct on the Christmas holiday.

James Franciscus swaps assignments with a Jewish cop played by Michael Strong, but the latter is seriously wounded in a liquor store holdup. One robber is shot and on the loose, but his partner is captured, and in that role Frank Sutton demonstrates an impressive acting range, from comic to pathetic. The accumulation of crime is disheartening but there are elements of hope especially as the script develops believably.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed