"Perry Mason" The Case of the Green-Eyed Sister (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A feel good show- except for that nasty death
kfo949427 October 2011
This episode starts out with an ugly step-sister Harriet Bain (Virginia Vincent) and a beautiful sister Sylvia Bain (Tina Carver) living in the same house as their sickly father. Just from the opening of the show we get the impression that it is going to be the battle of the step-sisters. But hold on to your Cinderella books.

Their father is being blackmailed from a bank embezzlement that happened many years ago. It is clear that Ned Bains, the father, (Carl Reid) and another man JJ Stanley (James Bell) were involved in the embezzlement. When a third man begins the blackmail- JJ Stanley ends up dead and all the evidence points to the meek and mild Harriet as the main suspect. The wild and beautiful Sylvia is in the clear.

And Perry is left to defend Harriet against a large amount of evidence present by Lt Tragg at the court hearing. Thus making Perry's situation seem hopeless. But after all we are talking about Perry Mason, so we should feel comfortable about the outcome.

There is also a sub-plot to this episode. There is a handsome young man named Addison Doyle (Robin Hughes) that said he will marry the lonely looking Harriet. But every time he is shown he in the presents of the step-sister Sylvia. It appears to the viewer that Addison is only after ugly Harriet for the money she is suppose to get from the death of the sickly father. This makes the entire show more interesting and we, as viewers, get a dislike for Addison and Sylvia since they seem to be plotting against all Harriet has in her life.

But feel better my friends, this episode has some twist that makes the outcome much more acceptable to the watcher. In fact the show makes you feel better at the end that you could have guessed during most of the show.

Other things that you need to watch for is- During the court scene we get a man on a stretcher haul in by medical staff to give testimony in the trial. At one point in the trial we leave the courtroom to hold court in a apartment. With help from Lt Tragg and Hamilton Burger, Perry catches the killer outside the confines of the courtroom. And we also get to see how Della controls Perry's day-to-day operations.

This episode was very interesting. It is a must see for Perry fans and one that leaves the viewer feeling better than before the show started.
24 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Della Street, fairy godmother
AlsExGal10 January 2023
A plain and drably dressed young woman, wealthy Harriet Bain, enters Perry Mason's office and requests to speak to him. Della Street advises her that Perry is in court and is then headed out of the country for several weeks.

At first Della is just politely lending an ear to the distraught young woman, but then she tells a tale of her dad, ill with heart disease, being blackmailed by an unscrupulous P. I. over an embezzlement that allegedly happened years ago. But besides the threat to her dad's health young Harriet is afraid that her fiance, from a respectful old money Boston family, will desert her if any scandal emerges from this situation. Della then has her tell the whole story, which she takes down on a legal pad, and goes to plead with Perry to cancel his trip and help the young girl. Of course Perry cancels his trip, and of course this ends up in murder with Harriet being charged with the crime.

After the trial is over - and if you've watched much Perry Mason at all you know I'm not giving anything away to say Harriet is acquitted - Della returns from the beauty shop, not redone over herself, but with Harriet looking and dressed much more attractively than before. Della always had a good heart, and this episode gave her a chance to make that characteristic shine.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Deep Freeze
Hitchcoc28 November 2021
A story of embezzlement. Two women are both connected to the same man. One is foxy and the other rather plain. We have a private detective in the mix and an accusation that the women's father was the embezzler. There are some serious scientific explorations including methods for determining when a person has died. The conclusion to the episode is quit startling.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Freeze Out
darbski26 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** The key to the episode is the freezer, of course. How did it get in the kitchen? In a small apartment? I would think that Tragg would absolutely check that glaring feature out, we needed it for the story, right? Second, even though Perry's client seemed like a doormat, by the time they are adults, siblings know how to handle each other; the dirtbag writer would have been either sent on his way, or fixed up some other way by dear old daddy. He's also a central figure in another one of Perry's dramas, "The Buried Clock" another fine episode. The characters are polar opposites, though. Della is beautiful, ending is weak, but the acting is strong. It's a 10.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Perry postpones a trip
bkoganbing11 July 2014
Wealthy Carl Benton Reid has two daughters, sexpot Tina Carver, and plain Virginia Vincent. Their father is being blackmailed by a private detective over an embezzlement charge that the statute of limitations has long passed, but Vincent is worried about the scandal as she's landed a prospective husband in Robin Hughes.

The private detective is Dan Riss and he's got a sordid reputation in the profession according to William Hopper. That gets Raymond Burr to postpone a trip to the United Kingdom to take the case which is blackmail, but graduates to murder when James Bell, Reid's former partner is murdered.

No it's not who you think it is, but the perpetrator is a most satisfactory individual to get comeuppance.
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Case of the Deep Freezer
zsenorsock13 October 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I can't help but notice how in these early episodes, how much the young, svelte Raymond Burr looks like current day actor Greg Kinnear. Their expressions and movements are very similar. If Kinnear ever gets tired of movies and wants to go back to TV, I think his Perry Mason would be very similar to one seen in season one.

The story, based on an original novel by Erle Stanley Gardner has ugly duckling Harriet Bain accused of murder. Her father Ned (Carl Benton Reid) is sickly with a heart condition and is being blackmailed by his alcoholic ex-partner and a unscrupulous private detective named Arthur West (Dan Riss). When the ex-partner turns up dead and an ice pick is found with Harriet's fingerprints all over it, Tragg charges her with the crime.

The story is okay, but there is oddly very little character development. While Virginia Vincent is good as the mousy sister, we get almost nothing from Tina Carver who plays her sexy sister or Harriet's opportunist boyfriend. Perhaps there just wasn't enough time to properly adapt the Erle Stanley Gardner story into a one hour story.

I also wonder about the chances of a poor man in a furnished room having a modern top of the line freezer unit. Generally you only see those in houses, not apartments because of their size. Also, it seems unlikely Arthur West would have paid for such a modern and costly appliance.

The end shot of this episode has Paul literally holding the bag as Mason walks away arm in arm with Della and the newly made over Harriet.
18 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who put the stiff in the ice-box!
sol12182 July 2013
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS*** It's when private detective Arthur West, Dan Riss, tracked down in a skid row hotel room this flat out drunk J.J Stanley, James Bell, he used him by giving J.J cases of free booze to blackmail his once banking partner the suffering from serious heart disease Ned Bain, Carl Benton Reid. J.J a former employee of the Texas National Bank was involved in embezzling it of $50,000.00 together with Ned Bain some ten years ago. Since the statute of limitation had already expired on the crime and Bain was not subject to criminal prosecution it was his good name that he tries to protect.

Blain's daughter Harriet, Virginia Vincent, in trying to get both West and J.J off her very sick father's back hires defense attorney Perry Mason, Raymond Burr, to keep the two from revealing his shady past. Mr Bain in an attempt to pay off his blackmailers goes to see both J.J & West with the pay off money despite the serious condition that he's in. But after he leaves their double,their connected to each other, hotel rooms J.J is found dead stiff as a board by Perry and his private secretary Della Street, Barbara Hale. And the murder weapon used to ice J.J an ice pick has Harriet Blain's fingerprints all over it!

Harriet now on trial for murder has Perry try to prove to the court that J.J was murdered by someone else besides his client. That in Perry proving, through the process of Rigor Mortis, in how long he was dead before his body was found. Even before the trial was over Harriet was completely exonerated of J.J's murder and now it's up to Perry and the presiding judge on the case, played by the venerable Eternal Colonel of movie and TV fame Morris Ankarum, to uncover just who J.J's killer really was. And as it turned out J.J's killer was about the greasiest oiliest and sleaziest, just one look tells it all, character in the entire cast!

***SPOILERS*** Perry Mason who suspended a flight to London where he was to attendant a lawyers conference found the case more then worth while for him. Finding a cold storage unit at the dead man's, J.J Stanley, hotel room Perry knew instinctively that it was in fact a way for his killer to cover up his crime. And the cold cash that Perry got from Harritt Bain helped also in paying Perry's very expensive office, situated in downtown L.A, rent. It, the case, also had Stella give the plain Jane looking Harriet Bain a complete makeover so she was both presentable as well as gorgeous as she together with her lawyer and escort Perry Mason traveled to London to attend that boring and uneventful, unlike the case that he just handled , lawyers conference!
7 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Case of the Green-Eyed Sister
Prismark109 March 2022
Ned Bain is being blackmailed for embezzlement by a shady private investigator Arthur West. He has tracked down. JJ Stanley an old business associate of Bain but who is now a drunken bum.

West has a tape recording. Bain's daughter Harriet goes to see Perry Mason about it.

Mason uses a devious trick with a magnet to wipe the tape recording. Ned Bain who is seriously ill goes to see Stanley on the sly late at night. When Stanley is found dead, Harriet is arrested for murder as her fingerprints are on the murder weapon.

Worse her philandering fiance Addison Doyle is getting even more friendly with her more glamorous sister.

I wonder if it might had been easier for the dying Bain to take the wrap for his daughter.

Instead Perry Mason uses some forensic science to determine when the deceased might have been killed.

I would have liked to known more just when Perry suspect the actual culprit. It was clear they were just too questionable.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed