- Nancy: You got more charity than most in town.
- Johnny Yuma: I was the one who shot him.
- Nancy: Men like him just gotta get themelves killed.
- Jake Fellows: I got four more, Reb.
- Johnny Yuma: Don't make me fight you, Mister.
- Jake Fellows: Reb's always got a fight with Jake Fellows. Now you draw. Or I'll shoot you down like I did Rebs from Gettysburg to Maryville.
- Bartender: War's buried, Jake. Leave the Rebel alone.
- Jake Fellows: Shut up! It won't be the first time I've shot a grey back running away. DRAW!
- Richard Aloysius Sturgis: [as the Reverend Aloysius Sturgis also as a villain] I've been charged with the task of returning the poor lost lamb to the fold. You have the boy, brother?
- Johnny Yuma: Well, I was told the boy had no kin.
- Johnny Yuma: I know of this place down in Travis, a place for orphans.
- Nancy: Orphans' home? I spent the worst part of my life in one of them places.
- Johnny Yuma: Beats the smell of a saloon.
- Richard Aloysius Sturgis: [as Dick Sturgis, villain] Ten days living in a cave, waiting and hiding, don't move a man much for fancy talk.
- [Any old reason for striking a woman he doesn't know]