"The Rifleman" The Retired Gun (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
We learn from any western- a gunfighter can never retire.
kfo949417 December 2014
In this episode we get a classic western tale of a gunfighter that wants to change his ways and settle down for a life away from guns. But as most all stories with the same theme, there is really no way for the gunfighter to suddenly changes his spots without coming to face with his past.

Wes Carney is the gunfighter that has meet a young beautiful girl named Clair. Wes marries the young girl with the understanding that his gunfighting days are over. It just so happens that Clair use to be the best friend of Lucas's wife and she comes into North Fork to seek advise from Lucas.

They decide to buy a feed and grain store and just melt back into society. That is all very good until an old adversary, Owny Kincaid, finds out that Wes is living in North Fork. In no time, Owny has four other foes of Wes just waiting to take the former fighter down. It will be up to Micah and Lucas to help the town get rid of the killers on the streets.

Since this plot has been played out so many times in nearly all western shows, it was nearly obvious what was going to transpire early in the episode. This left little to the imagination for the viewer as they await the anticipated climax to beginning. Nothing really wrong with the script but it was just to routine.

I will agree with another reviewer that the gunfight scene was poorly fashioned. You have five villains, at close range, shooting at three citizens and the most the citizens received was a mild wound. With bullets flying, they could not even inflict injury on Micah that was standing like a large piece of plywood on the streets and less than ten feet away. Oh well, it is all part of the TV magic we all accept when watching any series. -- Even with little suspense, this was still above average watch.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Most storekeepers kept a gun behind the counter
mldardar10 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This wasn't a favorite. Micah was judgemental about Wes wanting to settle in North Fork.

Any storekeeper would've kept a gun behind the counter, especially a former gunfighter who'd already been confronted by crooks, despite an unreasonable wife, who didn't even care that Lucas & Micah were going out to fight their battle alone. So Wes being beaten up wouldn't have happened.

And they gave up on the store too easily. Being a marshall would bring more chances of gunfight challengers, than continuing to run the store.

But I was always happy to see John Anderson get what he deserved in the end. As a child, I even hated to see him in any movie because of playing bad guys so much. Happy to say I grew out of that, & enjoyed him in the many fine roles he had.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Why was the character in this episode not listed. One woman nothing and 11 men listed. You figure it out
ruthcartwright21 March 2019
After watching this show to see who the female actress was I was quite disappointed that no women were listed in this episode. Considering the wife Clair Carney is a fairly main character in this episode I'm surprised at this omission. He name in the credits is Eileen Harley
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"High Noon" -- without the lecture
grizzledgeezer19 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
One of the problems with "The Rifleman" is that Lucas is (most of the time) an incredibly decent and good-hearted person. He rarely passes judgment, hardly ever fails to help someone in need, and never cowers in fear. (Did I mention he's usually aware of his failings?) Abraham Lincoln, Mother Theresa, and Superman can all retire. Lucas /has/ to be this good in order to be raise Mark as a mensch. (You do understand that Mark is the principal character, not Lucas?)

Unfortunately, the series' creators decided that Lucas has to tower not only physically, but morally, above everyone else (Micah excepted). The rest of North Fork's citizens are a bunch of sniveling cowards. (This is played for laughs, with a plump citizen running out of the saloon in fear, and two men dragging him back in.)

This episode makes plain their pusillanimity. When a gang of bad'uns arrives to wreak revenge on the eponymous retired gunfighter, they decide to hang around and take over. NOT ONE PERSON is willing to stand with Micah to chase them out. (Twenty armed men would have no trouble running them off without a single shot being fired.) So he, Lucas (of course), and the retired gunfighter are obliged to do it on their own. (The shootout is poorly choreographed. It's hard to believe the three heroes are able to take out six bad guys at such close range, with only one minor wound.)

One wonders why Micah is willing to remain as sheriff, or Lucas can tolerate living in such a community. Given Lucas's tendency to deliver lectures on morality, it's surprising he doesn't chew out the town, a la Will Kane. Of course, Lucas's and Micah's recognition that North Fork doesn't "deserve" them would bring the series to a screeching halt.

I've downrated this episode to 6 for its lack of dramatic logic. But it's otherwise decent. And John Anderson is unusually handsome.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed