"Route 66" A Bunch of Lonely Pagliaccis (TV Episode 1963) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Silliphant's Word Play Spotlighting A Dark Trait: Jealousy.
AudioFileZ24 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Sterling Silliphant's love of classic written words, no matter if a play, a novel, or poetry inspires him. He comes up with another enigmatic title here naming this episode "A Bunch of Lonely Pagliaccis". What is he unearthing is, perhaps, the viewer's first question...So, with some inquisitiveness one must watch.

Tod is still sans Buz (the echo virus is still implied as the reason, however fans know better). As Tod reports to work in a quaint rural Mississippi town we learn he is a famous writer's assistant. In almost the first scene we see the writer's daughter silently, and stoically, passing Tod by and leaving in her car whilst Tod is attempting to engage in conversation. Obviously something is very wrong. Silliphant attempts to paint the small town as a kind of fishbowl where everyone knows everyone else's business and is harsh to judge. There's a kind of uneasy tension were jealousy is the poison threatening a otherwise very slow and staid day-to-day pace.

Soon the lid blows from the sleepy town as it becomes the focus of a nation when the famous author's daughter is arrested for murder. On the surface it seems it is simply a jealous lover's jealous reckoning for a lover's infidelity. Yet, it seems to not make sense as the other woman isn't killed too. Making matters worse the accused tells her father she will not talk to anyone, including his high-powered defense. In fact, she says she'll thank the judge when the sentence of death is handed down. Talk about a darkness on the edge of town and all points in between! Tod walks around town in a kind of a dazed funk as he attempts to assist his employer. He is faced head-on with the ugliness of the press and society at large when an out-of-town older woman reporter hopes to use him to unearth the unsavory dirt of the story. Not only that, but there's a chauvinistic jealous local who goes after one of the visiting press who he chooses to believe is making unwanted advances toward his woman. As mentioned, it's a boiling pot and the kettle is about to whistle.

About this time a real twist occurs when the deceased present lover reveals she was in with the author's daughter in a sort of euthanasia due to the victim's being diagnosed as terminal. The story shifts from how jealousy destroys to the temperance of mercy. While we actually do get the jury's final decision we are left to ponder their request of clemency. It's a choice everyone can make, that is to let jealousy overtake humanity or vice-versa. In many ways this is a thinly disguised look at racism without being too overt since it applies to the human condition in an equally much broader way.

Excepting Vivian Blaine's portrayal of the harsh gossip-mongering tabloid style reporter, all the performances are delivered very low-key to great effect. Actually, Blaine's edgy, more dramatic, role meshes well indeed creating more color to an otherwise black and white Peyton Place-ish small town.

Slow paced with a low entertainment quotient this is one of Silliphant's "thinking mans" episode. As the episode ends everyone is largely in need of healing which we hold out hope will soon begin. The cinematography really captures a mood as the drab look as it shows a winter time drabness. You want the sun to come out and, perhaps, the trial's outcome may just be the first day of spring for a sleepy Mississippi fictional town named Eduardo.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Solid, Introspective Look at Society and Justice
rwint161128 July 2008
This is a solid story that keeps you engaged despite the fact that it has very little action. It involves Tod going to work in a small town of Hernando, Mississippi for a famous author and then dealing with the sensational trial that ensues when the author's otherwise peaceful and quiet daughter suddenly resorts to murder. Nothing is quite what it seems and everything is bubbling just beneath the surface. When the bombshell finally does hit it changes everything and makes an interesting point about society and how it interprets and dispenses justice.

The only real fall-backs to this episode are the fact that it was filmed in winter instead of summer, which never looks completely right when it is done in the deep south. The steamy, hot weather and look could of helped accentuate the steamy subject matter. This episode also features a couple of side stories. One involves Tod's rocky relationship with an older woman reporter (Blaine) who comes to town to cover the trial. The other centers on the tensions created on a rural couple when the wife starts showing signs of interest with a visiting male reporter. Both these scenarios have potential and could of been interesting in their own right had they been played out more.

In the end the most memorable parts of this episode have nothing to do with the story itself. One is the glimpse of a sign in a barber shop window that advertises haircuts for only seventy-five cents! The other has to do with some surprisingly unchivalrously where a couple's car breaks down late at night on a lonely road and it is the husband who has his wife go walking for help while he stays in the car! This episode also gives one the nice chance to see a rare appearance of James Leo O'Herlihy as one of the reporters covering the trial. He later ended up writing the novel 'Midnight Cowboy' that was later made into the Academy Award winning film of the same title.

Grade: B
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/4/63 "A Bunch of Lonely Pagliaccis"
schappe130 September 2015
Todd now has a cushy if demanding job as a secretary/chauffeur for a Faulkner-like novelist. He even has his own office with a cup of hot coffee waiting for him when arrives for work each day. In the first scene he takes some time to write a later to Buz describing his situation.

The novelist, (Barry Sullivan), has a beautiful daughter, (Laura Devon, who was last seen in the season premiere, "One Tiger to a Hill"). She is first seen shooting her husband in the presence of an old flame he has apparently rekindled his relationship with. She gets put on trial which, with her father's notoriety, becomes a media circus. Todd spends the episode on the periphery of this, jousting with a columnist played by Vivien Blaine, who gets to utter the title line, saying that we're all here to provide a mixture of laughs and tears. Warren Stephens plays another journalist, even more jaded than the rest who has a dalliance with a local young lady and then beats up her husband when he objects, (due to a greater familiarity with the martial arts). Neither of those sub- plots connect directly to the main story, where we find out that all is not quite what it seems. The ending suggests a tolerance for mercy killing that wound be controversial now: it must have been even moreso then.

There's nothing here to suggest the original presence of Buz in an earlier version of this script.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
If this is "Thinking Man's" stuff, I must be brain-dead.
lrrap7 November 2019
Another tiresome, "poetry-laced" tale from Silliphant, which would have benefited tremendously if he would have just TOLD THE STORY and left most of the "ART" out of his script. CASE IN POINT: at the close of Act 2, Barry Sullivan, having just been told by the duty-bound County Prosecutor that his (Barry's) daughter will not receive favorable treatment in her trial, gets into the Corvette---and instead of saying to Tod "Let's go, kid" like any normal person would do, says "Tell me, boy---WHO IS BORN FREE? [What??? How???? WHY????]

The plot is strong, and much of it works very well. But what's with the Warren Stevens character? WHO NEEDS IT, and all of the screen time it takes up?? And what's with the local couple and the wife's little dalliance with Stevens? WHO NEEDS IT, especially when all it does is distract from the main story?

The drama would have been FAR better served without these three useless characters, plus a couple of intense scenes INSIDE the courtroom in addition to all of the bustling and running around outside of it. I know....yes, I realize, Mr. Silliphant...that this would have produced a more standard, ordinary, run-of-the-mill, less "relevant" show for slow-witted viewers like me, who just can't seem to get the hang of your artsy, abstruse, stream-of-consciousness dialogue and plotting.

I am reminded of many of Joe Stephano's OUTER LIMITS (Season 1) scripts, which usually cluttered up the narrative with soulful, tortured characters who were undergoing a personal crisis and needed 50 minutes (with monsters and aliens tossed in) to achieve some sort of emotional catharthis. Sometimes it worked, but most of the time the writer's need to burden his characters (and us, the viewers) with this sort of stuff blunted the thrust of the drama and made the viewing experience much more tedious for us common folk.

Vivian Blaine's "show-biz" acting style seemed somewhat out-of-place with everyone else in the show, but maybe that's the reason the producers felt she was right for this particular part. Unfortunately, due to the unnecessary, pointless characters I've mentioned, even her role seemed underdeveloped and gratuitous.

I realize Silliphant and crew were accomplishing a seemingly-impossible task in producing this hour-long series in different locations every week---but, if you can create an artsy, flowery, unnecessarily contrived script under these conditions, you can certainly produce a more direct and cogent one. LR
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed