"Stargate SG-1" The First Commandment (TV Episode 1997) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
*cough* heartofdarkness *cough*
animecatgirl27 April 2021
It's been a while since I read that book, but that's the vibe.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
reminded me of Apocalypse Now
trashgang26 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
SG-9 is lost on a planet with unbearable sunlight. Captain Jonas Hanson of SG-9 finds himself that he must be treated like a god by the people walking around. He let them build a temple and those who are against them are burned in direct sunlight. Not only that, he tells that he can create an orange sky which will turn the sun down so you can walk without any problem into the light.

SG-1 is the search party to find SG-9 but not without problems. The Goa'uld has left that particular device to make the sky orange and carter is captured to help Hansoo with the device. be he doesn't know that two devices are needed to connect. Teal'c does so it's up to SG-1 to tell the people Hansen is no God.

This episode was a nice entry especially due the excellent performance of William Russ (Hanson). Somehow it reminded me of Apocalypse Now (1979) storywise.

All the typical stargate elements are here to see. Good episode.

Gore 0/5 Nudity 0/5 Effects 2,5/5 Story 3/5 Comedy 0/5
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I'm a god to these people
Calicodreamin4 January 2022
A scorched faced god, forced labor, and an even more forced backstory for Carter. The storyline was interesting though it never bodes well when the scientists have to say "this doesn't make sense" in order to cover plot holes.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
This time the false god isn't a Goa'uld, but one of they're own.
joshi_359215 August 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This is an great episode with a very dark and dramatic beginning. The team comes to a planet as a search party to see what has happened to SG-9 only to find that the teams leader has taken control of the local primitive inhabitants and are posing as their god. He claims to the people that he has the magic power (technology) to protect them from the intense UV light on the planet, but he needs Samantha Carters technical abilities to operate a machine left behind by the Goa'uld. The team must expose him as a false god before he gets complete control and devotion over the people.

This is an episode that deals with madness and how absolute power, corrupts. This is one of the more impressive one-time missions, and contains one of the series first seasons more original thinking.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Boring and Inconsistent
claudio_carvalho21 April 2015
Connor and Frakes from the SG-9 are hunted down by natives from a planet and Frakes is captured and killed by an earthling. O'Neill, Sam, Daniel and Teal'c arrive in the planet that has a lethal sunlight seeking out the SG-9 team and they find Connor that tells that their Captain Jonas Hansen is crazy and has executed Frakes. He explains that Hansen is treated like a god by the primitive inhabitants and power has corrupted him and he has become a tyrant. O'Neill decides to stay to investigate and Connor is captured by the inhabitants and tied up in the sun to die. Samantha, who was Hansen's fiancée, decides to turn herself in to talk to Hansen. But he realizes that he is completely nuts and is forced to help him to repair and activate a shield device left by the Goa'ulds. Meanwhile O'Neill, Teal'c and Daniel captures a local called Jamala and Teal'c tells that the shield requires to devices to be activated and he knows how to do it. Now they need to convince the inhabitants that Hanse is not a god.

"The First Commandment" is a terrible episode and the worst until now, with a boring and inconsistent story. Connor explains to the SG-1 team how powerful Hansen that has dominated the inhabitants is; instead of requesting back-up from the base, O'Neill decides to stay in the planet. Sam allows to be captured but seems to forget Connor. She has the chance to shoot Hansen and take control over him, but she let him take her weapon. What kind of military is she? My vote is five.

Title (Brazil): "The First Commandment"
24 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Abusive cult mirrors abusive relationship
kyvago27 September 2014
Warning: Spoilers
SG-1 is sent to see what happened to another team that hasn't reported back only to find Jonas, the team leader, has taken on the role of a god taking advantage of the natives.

It's no coincidence that Jonas and Carter have a past that comes into focus in this episode. As with many abusive relationships, after leaving him for the abuse, Carter still can't bring herself to shoot Jonas to save those following him even though she knows the abuse she suffered is now being endured by his followers.

Jonas is a master manipulator, a megalomaniac sociopath the likes of which we see in real life cults such as L.Ron Hubbard in Scientology, along with the slave labor given intolerable conditions to work in, all with the promise of better times ahead. The certainty carrot and sunstroke punishment stick.

The parallels between the devotion/fear trap that held both Carter and his followers aren't made obvious for the viewer which if it had been maybe via Jack doing so in a speech to the people that got the "enforcer" team member to snap out of the same mind control Jonas temporarily had over Carter I'd have scored this a 10.

Other reviewers that understand neither why abused people stay in a cult nor why a battered spouse stays in that relationship won't get this episode, but survivors of both will.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
One of the worst episodes of the entire series
GusF6 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
This has always been one of my least favourite episodes. It's fairly awful really, though that is at least an improvement over the horrendously awful "Emancipation". There are quite a few plot holes. For one thing, one would think that the SGC, already being aware even at this very early stage that the locals tend to worship people who come through the Stargate as gods, would conduct psych tests on potential SG-team members to ensure that they don't have megalomaniac tendencies or a Messianic complex. In Hanson's case, they either skipped it or Dr. MacKenzie got a bit bored and decided to rush through it.

Another thing that has always bothered me is why Lt. Baker, Hanson's crony, goes along with him. At least Hanson was nuts. What's his excuse? Is he just an amoral bastard who has always wanted to be a slave driver or is he a "brain dead sycophant" as Jack calls him? They never even attempt to explain it. Plus in the final scene, Daniel tells Jamala that the outside world is bigger than he can possibly imagine, yet the shield only extends over the valley which only looks like three to five square miles at the most to me. Perhaps Daniel was just being incredibly condescending towards the locals!

This episode is notable though for being the first of many episodes in which SG-1 convinces the locals that someone is not a god and I think the only time that the wannabe god is a human. It's also the first example of the "Black Widow Carter" curse. Speaking of Sam, I hate the scene where she can't shoot Hanson. Jack's right when he says that shooting a man is no badge of honour but surely it was the lesser of two evils in this instance when compared to the potential extinction of an entire people.
11 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Another ancient civilization
CursedChico6 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Another ancient civilization

I hope we can see developed civilizations, maybe super-civilizations. But it is really good seeing such cultures. And beliefs. A planet without atmosphere.

It was clever that Jamala used that weapon of jaffa. So everyone saw anyone could use that weapon.

And we see how beliefs can be dangerous without questioning.

I like the episode.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Worst episode of SG-1, followed by Emancipation.
jonathanberry-1379810 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This is meant to be Scifi, but this episode is a mess.

You have Samantha's Fiancé who was never seen or mentioned before this episode for no reason went power hungry and Homicidal.

Then the planet has sunlight so intense it can kill you before long, but that's more of a triviality.

Look, I want to see strange new worlds,not just some uncivilized humans worshiping an SG Team member!

Even given all those flaws the, witing is weak and actions taken are inconsistent with any kind of logic or procedure.

This is an episode about power corrupting in a way that is just not believable.

The episode would have made more sense if it had been a bit late than the 5th episode, while we don't know precisely how much time has passed since the fist episode this whole thing feels like it would have made more sense if they lost contact with a team for a year and they found them in this state.

It would have been totally forgivable if there was some Scifi justification for him becoming corrupted (Goa'uld symbiote, mind control, bad herbs/food, Sarcophagus, head injury) and it would also have been a lot more compelling if we know and liked him.

But this is just not really a Sci-fi episode!

It has noting that appeals to or related to Scifi.

It's captured by "power corrupts" (but the episode where the Harsesis shows Daniel how he would go wrong was much better done) and just makes me think the SGC are not that careful about who they pick for their off-world teams.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed