"Wagon Train" The Vivian Carter Story (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Phyllis Thaxter appreciation
glitterrose7 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Phyllis was one hell of an actress. Everything I've seen her in has her putting in a terrific performance and this isn't an exception.

Must admit I had looked at the cast credits for this one and seen that Lorne Green guest starred in it. Didn't even recognize him at first!

I can relate to Vivian's character somewhat. I'm not sure what age the character is supposed to be. She's just labeled as "old maid" by the saloon girl in the story. That still doesn't really fill in the blanks for me because a lady would probably be labeled an old maid if she wasn't married by the time she was 15 or 16 in the time period the story takes place. Let's just be fair and say Vivian's not a teenager, eh?

So she's off to get married but Lorne's character confesses he has feelings and those feelings get brushed off. Vivian's got her sights on the man she's about to get married to. Flint takes her to this area and must admit the writing went in a different direction for me at that point. I thought maybe the guy Vivian was going to get married to was a player and he was have some "fun times" with the saloon girl. NOPE! Turns out the two are married.

Vivian's absolutely humiliated. And it wasn't like she was having that much of a fun time to begin with. This saloon lady was hammered and Vivian was being genuinely nice to her, only for this lady to keep dumping all over her. And then the marriage tidbit comes out, Vivian runs off. She understandably is so ashamed that she doesn't even want to go back to the wagon train. I can't blame her. It's not like Vivian was putting on airs about getting married. I just think Vivian wanted her share of happiness and that hope has just been dashed completely...or has it? I guess the ending of this storyline makes me think of that phrase about when one door shuts, another door opens.

And I definitely see why Flint is on my list of favorite tv men. It's not just his looks. It's his personality. He's an absolute gentleman and was defending and complimenting Vivian to the saloon lady that was talking trash about her.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The wisdom of Robert Browning
bkoganbing4 December 2017
Phyllis Thaxter plays the title role in this Wagon Train episode. Her character is an unmarried thirty something woman who gave up her youth and a whole lot of beaus to take care of her father. But he left her a lot of dollars and he was a gambler by trade. She's going west to marry another charming gambler type Patric Knowles. But he's a cad and worst than that, he's already married to saloon entertainer Mari Aldon.

It was pretty humiliating after leaving the Wagon Train to get married to come back humiliated as she was. Thaxter gives a fine performance of a woman who wasted her youth. But she learns she has a lot more to give.

Two other performances worthy of note. Jane Darwell plays a pioneer widow who has seen and heard it all and she's a person who gives some wise counsel. Also Lorne Greene before he became Ben Cartwright and his hair turned gray plays another and far more substantial man much interested in Thaxter.

A lot of her romantic ideas come from Robert Browning. In the end she finds some satisfying verse from Mr. Browning that address her feelings of the moment.

And you get a chance to see Robert Horton deck Patric Knowles. Believe me he deserved it twice.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An ld Memory Comes Back
drvanda214 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I was a kid, around nine, when I saw this show. I remember that Lorne Green is love with the woman but she keeps rebuffing him. The main thing I remmeber is that he frequently recites a poem to her, which has the refrain, "The Best is yet to me." Even as a kid I knew this woman was in trouble because she was of a acertain age and thought she couldn't have a relationship (marriage) with Lorne green. He keeps pursuing her and finally convinced that it's not too late because "the best is yet to be." I was glued to the story. Why at 9 I don't know, Now, that refraine at the age I am now keeps coming back to me. Does anyone know this poem and where I can get a copy of it? I'd really like to read the whole thing. Thanks if you find time and know to tell me where I can find it. Vanda (I'm a writer now)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed