"The Waltons" The Genius (TV Episode 1975) Poster

(TV Series)

(1975)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The Genius
janet-conant18 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of the best written episodes of the Waltons primarily because of Lyle, Dennis Kort. His explanations of Ike's slot machine, physics and his beliefs in the non-existence of God are intriguing. Love listening to him every time he talks candidly. He makes a lot of sense throughout the show but he doesn't win many friends except MaryEllen. I laughed out loud when he explains how a family having more children that they can't afford should be rewarded for their lack of prudence. He was so right. When asked if he would like to work on the booths for the upcoming church fair he simply says, "No". I'm surprised he doesn't explain the facts of life at the supper table.

John Boy finally tells him to maybe try listening for a change and be more understanding and not so selfish. He winds up doing just that and has probably his first enjoyable time. The last scene is another great laugh. If John Walton were there he and Lyle might have been in agreement about God and put grandma in her place but Waite was absent due to a contract dispute with CBS. He was sorely missed.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not the most promising start , but turned out great.
fentress8 March 2021
The Genius is a story of John-Boy bringing a fellow student from college to stay the weekend with the Walton family. And this student is far from ordinary.

I have to admit when I started watching this episode, I was a little turned off in the first few minutes. It didn't strike me as a very original idea. It seemed a lot of TV programs in those days had an episode with a similar storyline with this kind of stereotyped character: the person who is a genius intellectually but has no social skills and no understanding of human beings at all. And of course you can predict the character either gets his comeuppance and/or learns some lessons about what really counts.

But I'm glad to say I was proven wrong. Sure, the destination was a bit predictable. But it was a great trip getting there, thanks to fine writing. There was a good deal of humor in this episode, some of it in the form of delightful surprises. The script portrayed well how there's much meaning in life that can't be explained logically.

One small criticism: the character of Lyle was maybe a bit extreme. He started college at 15. He was thoroughly knowledgeable of John-Boy's physics course material from having only "looked at" the textbook a couple. The writers could have made him someone who simply was intellectually oriented and introverted, but not at such an unbelievable level of genius. It could have told the same story but more realistically. Less would have been more.

John Walton Sr. is conspicuously missing in this episode. I would guess Ralph Waite was sick or unavailable for whatever reason when this episode was filmed, so they wrote him out. Part of the story concerns how Lyle dismisses religion as nothing more than the product of primitive minds. Naturally this causes great consternation with the family. But John Walton Sr. is the one family member who, while respectful, doesn't find organized religion conducive to his path in life. And that was a theme that came up in some other very interesting episodes. I'm imagining how the conversation could have been even more interesting if John Sr. had been at the dinner table as well. What a lost opportunity.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intelligence vs. Intolerance
JenExxifer9 November 2021
I give this episode 10 stars for demonstrating how intolerant, and rather rude, the Walton clan can be towards people who aren't just like them.

While I don't blame the Waltons for feeling insulted by many of the logical things Lyle says as a guest in the Walton home, at the same time I think they didn't try to understand him and why he is the way he is due to his upbringing.

Nor did the Waltons seem to practice being good Christians by overlooking a person's faults when that person was out of their element. Just because the Waltons are comfortable in their home they assume guests should be too; the Waltons are a clique but they don't know they are.

This isn't the first episode where members of the Walton family get insulted when someone doesn't think like them or has a different lifestyle (The Carnival episode comes to mind), and often it's Mr. Walton who has the more open mind of accepting people for being different; since he wasn't in this episode it makes sense that there was no voice of reason.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed