Uncle Petrie takes Timmy and Lassie into town. Uncle Petrie treats Timmy to ten rides on a pony. Dressed out in his best "Roy Rogers" outfit, Timmy falls in love with a pony named "Star". Timmy needs guidance. He asks mom if he can pray to God for a new pony. Mom wisely tells Timmy that prayers aren't meant for the purpose of getting things. Not to be daunted, Timmy asks if he can wish really hard for the pony. The ever hopeful little Timmy sneaks in the idea that he's wishing for a pony to God after he thanking Him just the same for the soar throat He gave him last week; even though he didn't want one. Lassie always knows what Timmy wants and bounds off early in the morning to have a private conversation with "Star". Next thing you know, Star and Lassie are racing off to be with Timmy. But, wait! Who's that chasing after Star and Lassie in a truck! It's Star's owners, who are secretly bad guys getting ready to leave town after stealing money from the townspeople. What a surprise for Timmy when he wakes up that morning. Wishes do come true! Or do they? Some of the townspeople lay claim to Timmy's knew pony to cover the damages they suffered at the hands of the bad guys. It will take the wisdom of Solomon to decide the fate of little "Star" the pony. Will "Star" get to say with Timmy? Will the County Judge be able to channel King Solomon to solve this? Will "Star" get out of jail? Will Timmy get trapped in the well? Just what does Lassie say to Star that gets her to follow him home?
—Ten Inch Toni