Breaking Surface (2020) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
79 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Beautiful scenery, well shot - but too many things that irritated me
joeri_dp20 December 2020
As some have reviewed it before me, the movie certainly has good elements:
  • the environment is beautiful !
  • the shots under & above water are really good
  • acting is good


But personally for me, some elements were irritating as hell:
  • the main actress plays a pretty stupid person (some could argue she's maybe inexperienced as a diver and does silly things and/ or attribute her reactions to panic). But still, it's ok to be stupid in a film - but if it starts to be irritating... it's too much
  • I'm a diver and wow some pretty amazing stuff happening under water. Maybe for the non-educated viewer it looks ok, but as a diver ... it's not realistic. The amount of dives/ quick surfacing/ recompressing she's doing... don't think she'd still be walking. Freediving to 33m (in a drysuit), looking for the bottle on the bottom on one breath, ... a lot of those things are not realistic


A pity ! I think with some small finetunings this could have been a very good movie.
60 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Requires suspension of Disbelief
xpudqjjf15 December 2020
Keeps you at the edge of your seat. You just have to get over how dumb the main character is.

Also, the movie could have done without the backstory. I would have cared about what happened to these characters irrespective of their past.
34 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beautiful scenery on the surface
chris-h-319 December 2020
My biggest take away from this film was the scenery and cinematography on the sisters drive to the dive site which was beautifully shot and made you wonder why they wanted to go diving in the dark rather than hiking.

I think the lack of any 'wonder' in the diving scenes did make what they were doing seem a little pointless and the younger sister, who we see taking one risk after another throughout the film, more unsympathetic.

It was very well shot and must have been a lot or work for the cast and crew to make. It had some tension but it would've been better if I'd cared a little more for the characters.

Shame for dogs in this movie too.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Distracted diving is a no no.
jamosmonk1 August 2020
The cinematography is great. The many frustrating issues arise from the many situations that befall the duo, and the emergency decisions they must make. One poor decision after another. It is definitely worth a watch.
21 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Brilliant woman dependent on hilariously stupid sister to survive diving accident
cstkbr23 April 2023
I made an account just for this. This movie is insultingly stupid. Tuva makes all the intelligent choices after a diving accident but is undone by the utter stupidity of her own sister. If you treat it as a slapstick comedy it's fun to watch, but as a suspense thriller it's just insulting to its viewers. The writer didn't even check with a diver to make sure it's basic assumptions about diving were correct. It also contains all kinds of unnecessary complications, plot holes, convoluted story lines it is just a mess. Need more characters characters characters otherwise the review is too short..
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Very good overall survival movie from Sweden. Realistic and with lot of suspense in the entire film. Recommended.
Mivas_Greece29 April 2021
Survival film from Sweden. Two sisters who are reunited after a long time, go together for diving like they used to when they were kids. Only while they're at the bottom of the sea, rocks fall and the younger sister gets trapped on the bottom. The older one doesn't have her sister's experience but with her guidance she tries to do everything to save her. Constant challenges and setbacks and constant effort against time as oxygen runs out. Will they both make it out of the frozen seabed alive? A pretty good and serious overall survival film from Scandinavia, with snowy landscapes and cold seabed, quite realistic and with very good acting, suspense throughout the film and combined with its short duration does not become boring at all. Pretty good effort from the north. Recommended.
13 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Character behaviour keeps it from being perfect
DerangedPika11 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Great cinema photography and setting. I love those cold shots of northern Norway. The acting is solid (from my English speaking perspective) But it does get a little ridiculous as to how many things go wrong for the characters.. I'm still not sure why she had so much trouble with the car... or certain furry characters figure so prominently yet don't seem to add anything to the plot. Symbolism perhaps?

At any rate the movie does a good job turning up the tension from scene to scene. It might actually make you feel stressed if you can get around some of the absurd character behaviour that make you want to scream at your TV.

... also stop leaving 1 star reviews without any details! It's stupid to rate something 1 star just because you don't like a character or part of the plot. It's not a 1 star movie but it's not a 10 either that's for sure.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The quintessential stressful movie and clostrophobic abstain.
thor202925 October 2020
Going diving in the middle of winters in Norway, and in a secluded place, is not the best thing to do. Well, this is the very type of movie where the story is built to stress the viewer until the end and make them hold their breath, for that, the movie succeeds, stress free! But it stops there. Of course there are worse movies.
14 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dumb and unrealistic
fuckyou-785801 January 2021
The smartest characters in this movie are the dogs.
60 out of 83 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
How to open a trunk
Selppin2_2 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I'd rate this higher, as the scenery is beautiful and I'm always up for a single-setting survival style movie... but HFS the trunk thing was just absurd, and rather than continuing to look for the button to open it, she went to a house down the road for a crowbar.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Disappointing Movie
sudipmaitra31 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Everything about the movie was good except the story. The story made the main character so stupid that every few minutes you ask yourself what the hell is going on. Then why kill a dog? Why stop to help someone with a flat tyre when help was on the way if only to show the reason for the jack to be left behind. Pathetic.
19 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
As a certified PADI Enriched Air Diver, this is as real as it gets
Top_Dawg_Critic23 July 2020
This is a Swedish/Norwegian production, and only the fourth full length feature film written and directed by newb filmmaker Joachim Heden. It's a tense, and well executed film that portrays a very accurate representation of the dangers of diving. The cinematography was perfection. Norway's Lofoten Islands setting was spectacular and breathtaking. The underwater filming was on par with big budget Hollywood blockbusters. I've read some reviews complaining about the writing; sure it's not perfect, but the weird offside scenes add to the real-life "when it rains it pours" events. It was a refreshing non-Hollywood-ed film, and considering this was written by a newb filmmaker, it was still much better than some of the big budget Hollywood flops put together by seasoned filmmakers that have been coming out lately. The score was on point and the acting very convincing. The 80 min runtime was just right, as was the pacing. Had the writing been a little tighter, this would've been a perfect film. It really felt like it was based on true events, and even caused me, a certified diver, anxiety watching the drama unfold. It's a well deserved 8.5/10 rounded up to a 9 from me. Click on my username to see more of my 1000+ ratings and 900+ reviews.
63 out of 103 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dislikable Protagonist
Slarkshark24 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I was drawn to this film for two reasons. I enjoy films about diving, and also films that are based in the arctic ir something of that nature.

The film gets props for being realistic. The diving was very well done, and everything was done as it should be.

It's quite unfortunate that the younger, more experienced, and smarter sister is the one that gets trapped. Our main protagonist is painfully unintelligent. Like how can you not just find the trunk release button in the driver seat, guaranteed there is one, I looked it up for Volvo's. Then, she kills a dog inside its own house. How can you cheer for someone like that? Afterwards, she leaves a note for the people who live there asking for help. If you broke in to my house and killed my dog, you better not tell me where to find you. Help is what you'lI need when I get there. I was really hoping she would just die and the trapped sister would survive.

So yes, that's what really drags this film down. Otherwise, it's actually well made.
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Everything that can go wrong, goes wrong.
cauwboy18 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It's hard to write a review like this, it's a small, swedish film that needs all the support it can get, yet I can't rate it higher than 4 out of 10. Why? Well, first of, to me this was a 40-60 minutes long film, stretched out to barely 90 minutes. Keep it in the water the whole film through instead. I also guess my hopes were too high because of tag lines on the poster, calling it "the best swedish thriller" and other sentences with "Best" in it.

The thing is, all the technical stuff is great, the cinematography, the sound, the music, the scenery, it was a very easy film to follow and not shaky cam or something like that, it felt like I was watching a Hollywood film at some scenes.

What drags it all down is the story. We get some flashbacks to the main characters lives as kids, some look at their daily lives with one working as a repairman/diver and the other one having a difficult relationship with her husband, none of it really matter to the story. Then there's arguing among one of the sisters and their mom, feeding their dog cigarettes (wtf?) and then for some funny reason, a stranger on the road having a flat tire that one of the sisters decides to help, even if the owner of the car already called for help. Why? To show the jack-screw that lifts the car, it will obviously have an important role later in the film... but then again, no, it doesn't. An important thing when I watch a film is that I can somehow relate to the characters or if nothing else, get some kind of reward throughout the film, something that makes me like it, but as the film went on, I just didn't care if anyone lived or died, there wasn't really any reason for why I wanted them to live - one of them have kids, the other one going travel to the Philippines next week, not enough reason for me to care. At least make the main character smart, or even smarter than the viewer, that way I can actually cheer more for her - instead I was just rolling my eyes over every new mistake she made that lead to nowhere. It's noot until the end that she does something smart, but by then I had already stopped to care.

I think another thing that would've made the film more real, would be if the main character didn't talk as much, most of the things she said was obvious and already known by the viewers without having it told to them. It just made her sound more stupid. Just look at All Is Lost (2013) another thriller about a single person in a dire situation, barely no words are said during that film and it's not any side stories or flashbacks in it. I'm sure the two lead actors are great at their jobs, but with the wrong screenplay or direction, it's just another forgettable film among others.

Oh, and then there's the dog that gets killed, was that even necessary? It would've been enough with her being bitten and barely escaping the house, but to kill the dog and leave a message? There just wasn't any reward with the house-scene. At least she could've found a jack-screw or something else to try and save her sister, instead of destroying their car any more. It just made me dislike the main character even more.
47 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great film for the budget - Realistic and well constructed!
omendata18 December 2020
All really good films have a good start sequence like films like Cliffhanger or Vertical Limit and this film is no exception with a heart stopping sequence beneath a ship being sucked into its propellers which immediately grabs the viewers attention - well done to the director for paying attention to the rules of good movie making.

Add to that some utterly breathtaking photography and drone footage and it starts looking very good indeed.

Good acting and nice characterization, one character is focused, extremely intelligent and capable then we have the other one who obviously has problems , ruined her marriage and is a bit of nightmare and of course its the intelligent and capable one who becomes trapped and so the incompetent partner is the one who has to try everything (and mostly failing) to free her sister and save the day - it has all the things a good movie should have right from the off and it does not disappoint! As one reviewer has pointed out it is actually quite close to reality when you are diving so they clearly researched before they made the movie and having seen someone with a case of the spinal bends its quite disturbing and a completely horrifying experience even for people watching it happen to someone else as i did once so this film did bring back memories!

You have to laugh at the one star reviewers complaining about the dog scene or this and that would not happen in real life and the sister was stupid - Err yes that is why she was chosen to be the one not trapped under the rock as she was the incompetent dimwit of the two sisters - what didnt you get? When are people like this going to stop reviewing movies? If everyone did the logical and sensible thing then the movie would last 10 minutes and be over immediately - its what is called making a fictional movie guys - perhaps stick to dominoes if you cannot review a movie properly or dont understand the construction of a screenplay! It really does disappoint me to see low brow reviewers giving a good film like this a 1 or 2 star review which means its the worst film you have ever seen and which this is plainly not if you have ever seen the Bad Batch with Keanu Reeves - Go watch that and then tell me you still think this is a 1 or 2!

The only disappointment is that they went for the usual hollywood happy ending when they should have ended it with what would really have happened if someone had made so many ascents and descents without the safety breaks they should take to remove nitrogen from the blood then it would really have broken movie making rules and we need this to make movies that truly shine. Overall a good exciting 7/10 nights entertainment.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Movie os Fine.
EthanTan778 October 2020
Movie is fine.. Just wondering about opening a car compartment... isnt it juat a latch located somewhere on the seat?
12 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
the day everything
ops-5253518 December 2020
Felt and went rockbottom at 20 phatoms below the sea surface. do you have any kind of cronic obstructive lungs issues, do have your oxygen at hand ,because youre automatically catching and holding your breath in this flick.

but its not the very best of die on a dive films ive seen through the years, but its intense though. the dynamics between the actors are so shallow and bad ,i would never have dove with any of then because daredevilism isnt my preference. and if all the signs from heaven had occured to me before my dive i wouldve called it a day long before dipping into the water. im not a certified diver, but have done a lot of diving as a freelancer in my younger days, though i still have my orange scubapro wetsuit .but all the dire straits these two women are up to could never have been foreseen or predicted.. if there are one bad thing about norway ,its darn desolate where they are diving and the phone signal basicly dead if turning round the mountain.

but to all viewers that doesnt understand the language, the 2 dames are swedish and not norwegian,that maybe the reason for all their bad luck and headless hunting for rescue. the wooden stick brought to the seabottom would actually have been a near impossible task to take down, just a little glitch among others.

but its a viewable film and im very squemish and grumpy and old man tonight so its just a 7 from me.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
No silence in the deep
tazeemali-7920228 December 2021
This film kept me interested and emotionally connected to the characters.

Suspenseful and intriguing to watch.

IMBD wants me to write a story here due to the characters length of this review.

Keep it simple it's a good movie and will keep you interested.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
nope
zombie84-112 April 2021
I have to agreed with everyone here. That girl was a complete moron. She ruined the whole movie. Good thing i only wasted a dollar.
20 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Murphy's law and a stupid lead weaken this otherwise great survial thriller
aronharde4 February 2024
I really like survival thrillers like this one and I thought the idea was pretty interesting. The movie introduces us to two sisters and their relationship between each other and their mom. Right off the bat you get an idea how their characters work and what kind of people they seem to be.

Then the incident happens and you mostly follow Ida portrayed by Moa Gammel. She is trying her best to save her sister from drowning or is she? Because her character was so dumb that it was really annoying at times and I was just shaking my head screaming at the screen. She is the kind of character that is hard to root for and also it didn't feel like she was aware that everything she does is a play against time. I get that she is probably exhausted but she was moving so slow at times and also took time with lots of the things she does. And also this movie suffers from this rare phenomenon where everything that can go wrong does and this is something that a lot of survival thrillers do and I really dislike it because the only reason is that it drives the plot forward but most of the time the realistic aspects are left behind. There is also a scene involving a dog that many people will probably really dislike and it also didn't make sense and there was absolutely no reason for it to be in the movie. Overall it was a decent survival thriller that definitely had some flaws that could have been avoided to improve this flick. [5,8/10]
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Unbearable to watch this much stupidity
holyturbinebatman24 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
How can anyone be this dumb? If I go out to dive in the middle of nowhere in the freaking ice cold sea, I would look for a partner who is at least with more than an IQ of 50. Like come on. She could not find the lever to open the trunk of the car? Has she driven a car in her life? And then she walks like a mile to find a house - in the middle of nowhere, mind you - and then she breaks in because there's no one answering the door. And then, get this: she kills the dog that was inside. Kills it. With a knife. I could not watch any further than that.

Every decision made by that character is stupid. There's no way anyone can justify any of her actions. I would think that any diver even remotely familiar with professionalism would not be this stupid.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very good movie
nickpedersen17 June 2020
Wow I was happily surprised with this one. It really kept you on the edge of the seat! There is not much talking so even if you dont like foreign movies, this one will engage you :-)
30 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Edge-of-your-seat theiller
kmkraft26 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I found myself very invested in the characters and the seemingly hopeless situation they found themselves in this film. The acting was great, the direction superb, the music evocative. If I have any complaints, it that the main character seemed irritatingly stupid sometimes and did not move with a much alacrity one might expect given the time sensitivity at hand. Also, I'm no diving expert, but I don't think anyone would have survived after the number of dives and ascents she made without safety stops. But still, a solid survival thriller.

The relationship between the two sisters could have been more rich, I think. They never discussed the near-fatal dive that occurred when they were young, even though the incident definitely defined the relationship between they two and their mother. I don't know...I thought they should have discussed it more. But it might just me me.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Its a VOLVO Warning: Spoilers
Why dident she fell the seat so she could get to the back?! Instead she walked 1km to get to a random house and kills a dog on the way! (wtf)
50 out of 80 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Beautiful Norway, Childish script
scotteydog-0387717 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
10 minutes in and I'd had enough of the unrealistic and childish script.

Making us believe that you could survive a ships propeller turning on, while your there to unravel a tangled web of nets & ropes, first dumb move.

And while she is down there she makes a comment over the radio, that it is very cold & she should have worn double thermal wear under her wet suit.

When she surfaces, the weather looks quite warm wherever it is?

When she angrily steps into the ships navigational cabin, the crew, tell her that it was no-ones fault and that's the end of it.

I mean really, in reality she would of sued the ships company for all they were worth.

When she arrives in Norway on the other hand, it is Arctic winter and then her and the mother go for a swim in their bathing suits?

And then later she is outside with her sister smoking a cigarette & states that if mother finds out, I will get in trouble, so feeds it to the family dog. Then states that this is the second dog she has done this to.

Well, that was enough for this viewer to not bother watching on.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed