East/West: Sex & Politics (2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
From Russia With Love
fragmeat131 March 2008
At one stage in this film, somebody jokes that in Russia, nobody cares if you're gay or lesbian or straight - the only thing that matters is oil and money. But belying this is the soon apparent truth that while some in the Russian gay community are willing to live quietly in the shadows of clubs and bars, the few prepared to organise a gay pride march through the streets of Moscow are condemned, arrested, punched and spat at.

Modern Russia, like modern China, is a country that has had to adapt quickly to changing global economics. But a strong economy and aggressive government don't disguise the fact that much of Russia seems to have been reluctantly dragged into the human-rights-for-all-yes-even-gays 21st century. This, along with an ambitious orthodox church, and blatant police disregard for law are just some of the difficulties faced by the marchers, led by organiser Nicolai Alekseev.

Through footage of the marches, and personal interviews with the people involved, this film sets about showing the already-free gay communities of Europe and the US just how much work is still required in parts of the world to achieve equal rights for all.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very good look at Russia's depressing lack of civil/gay rights
Skullen19 October 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I just saw this film at the Warsaw Film Festival and there was a Q&A with the director right afterwards. The documentary was originally intended to be about gay rights in Poland, Latvia, Estonia and Russia, but after the brutal suppression of Moscow's gay rights march - the makers decided to do a more in depth investigation of the situation in Russia since the atmosphere there is much more homophobic than in the other countries mentioned above.

The film follows five or so Russian gay men and women, some who believe in protesting, others who would prefer to keep their heads down and not attract negative attention. One such gay man is claiming disability benefit at the age of around 23, because he and his boyfriend were beaten up one night by skinheads. When he came to in hospital, he was told he boyfriend, his first, was dead. There are many such sad stories in this film, testament to the appalling homophobic atmosphere in Russia.

The gay march itself, attended by various politicians from around European (and the singer from Right Said Fred), was banned and when it took place, the police allowed neo-Nazis to attack the protesters and then arrested the now-bloodied protesters. It's obvious from the film that there is little immediate hope for Russia (and its fledgling democracy), which gives the film a bitter ending, but that's hardly the makers' fault. Overall though, the film is a great document and very much worth seeing. According to the director though, it won't be in Russia for a while: the Moscow and St Petersburg film festivals refused to show it saying that it wouldn't be received to well by their public. A great shame - they need to see it more than ever at the moment.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed