Cast (in credits order)
| David Muir | ... | Self - Co-Host | |
| Amy Robach | ... | Self - Co-Host | |
| Rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
| Ryan Avis | ... | Self | |
 |
Jim Doty | ... | Self |
| Cari Lea Farver | ... | Self - Murder Victim in 2012 (archive footage) (as Cari Farver) | |
| Shanna Golyar | ... | Self - Convicted in 2017 of Murdering Cari Farver (archive footage) (as Shanna Liz Golyar) | |
| Tony Kava | ... | Self | |
Produced by
| Jennifer Wilson | ... | field producer |
Music by
| David Starck | ||
Editing by
| Gina Caruana | ||
Editorial Department
| John Breitling | ... | assistant editor |
| Caitlin Hartie | ... | assistant editor |
| Lori Riendeau | ... | assistant editor |
Music Department
| Albert Behar | ... | composer: additional music |
| Brian J. Casey | ... | additional music |
| Nick DePinna | ... | composer: additional music |
| Johannes Hammers | ... | composer: additional music |
| Zac Selissen | ... | music |