Die Anwälte - Eine deutsche Geschichte (2009) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A "triographical" movie on some of Germany's most famous lawyers/politicians
Horst_In_Translation15 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Birgit Schulz' "Die Anwälte - Eine deutsche Geschichte" is a German 90-minute documentary movie from 7 years ago that focuses on the lives and careers of Otto Schily, Hans-Christian Ströbele and Horst Mahler. I am pretty sure that people abroad without an interest in politics have probably not even heard about one of them, but here all three are fairly well known, now around the age of 80 and still working, even if probably not as hard anymore as they did in their younger years. The three are united with their lawyer background and their connection in terms of who they supported during the days of the RAF terror in Germany in the 1970s. All of them had a fairly left-wing background, though not really a radical, apart from Mahler maybe.

But afterward, their lives went into very different directions. Schily adjusted a lot and became one of the defining figures in German politics during his prime, Ströbele always stayed a bit of a rebel and stayed with the Green Party which may have cost him a bigger career, but fut his ideals the best and Mahler totally changed directions by supporting the extreme right these days. I think it is a fulfilling watch for everybody with an interest in German politics as the trio depicted in here have had quite exceptional careers in the last 50 years and regardless of what they support a lot happened in their lives, so this is never a boring watch. I also liked how they took the chronological path. I recommend checking it out. It is probably not so easy anymore to get a hand on this movie, but I guess it may be shown on television occasionally. Give it a go, you will not be disappointed. I watched this the first time when it came to theaters a couple years ago, but it is still strong on rewatch and also nothing you inevitable have to see on the very big screen and on the very big screen only.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Lawyers and German history
Pippi_langstrumpf20 November 2009
Germany does not have a tradition of jokes about lawyers. Any Brit or American will definitely come up with three or four jokes like

  • My father is a lawyer. - Honest? - No, the regular kind.


But Germans, after all, do not have a sense of humour - or do they? Watching this film, you might definitely think they do.

This film is a documentary about three lawyers, Horst Mahler, Otto Schily and Hans-Christian Stroebele, who were active in the "APO" movement (an opposition movement outside Germany's parliament) and who used to defend RAF terrorists like Gudrun Ensslin, Ulrike Meinhof and Andreas Baader later on.

You see old film material and even a few scenes from old "Tagesschau" news about demonstrations against the Vietnam War, and how the student Benno Ohnesorg is killed during a demonstration against the Shah's visit. This all influences the three lawyers and turns them against the state with its brutal police force. But hey, this was the 1960s and 1970s.

Later on, Mahler and Schily get more and more mainstream, and it is quite spooky to see Schily making speeches in parliament (and occasionally sounding a bit like Hitler) and turning more and more right-wing. So he quits the Green Party and joins the Social Democratic Party and becomes a law-and-order man when he is Minister of the Interior. Mahler's development is even eerier, because he, formerly a member of the RAF, turns into a fully-fledged (neo-) Nazi who denies the Holocaust and is therefore sent to prison.

The only lawyer who has not turned into a joke of his former self is Stroebele, who sticks to his left-wing pacifist ideals. This is probably why he is the only Green politician who is directly elected to Germany's parliament and does not get his seat because of the Green Party's percentage in the elections.

I very much liked this film because it gives you a good idea of the late 1960s and 1970s in Germany - a time I am highly interested in. I can still well remember the RAF times, seeing the "Wanted" posters in every German post office, and I was in Heidelberg when the RAF tried to kill US Army General FJ Kroesen.

For everyone interested in Germany's post-war history, this is a must-see. I'm a brainy girl, not a brawny man, and so I found this film much more thrilling than any action film on offer.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed