Space Battleship Yamato (2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
65 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Consider the history
garwhite446 November 2011
I have to say that i think one of the best things to take away from this movie also seems to be one of the things which nobody considers.

I'm not familiar with the original series or comic so i can not attest to its being good or bad in that sense. What i am familiar with is the historical significance of the battleship Yamato and the symbolism and slight role it played in WWII for the Japanese People. Japan had one of the most powerful navies (and arguably the most powerful)in the world at the beginning of hostilities in the Pacific theatre of WWII. By the 6th of April 1945 when the Yamato left port for the last time, the Japanese navy had been ravaged, they had lost most of their carriers and cruisers with only about 10% of its original naval forces remaining. The Yamato and a few escorts were to attempt to attack the now Allied occupied Okinawa in a near-futile attempt to deal a blow to the US fleet. She was destroyed en-route to the battle by relentless air attack by the US and never got to use her 9 46cm batteries, the largest in existence at the time. This story is about hope, honour, and the tenacity of the Japanese people as a whole. Of course it was corny, they raised the hulk of the ship out of the ground! And besides bearing a resemblance in spirit its clearly not the actual ship, its about 5 times as large. The acting was perfectly appropriate for the type of story this was and despite a few drawn out scenes i was still very entertained. Sure, some of the CGI at the end was, to quote another review, "dodgy", but for the most part actually pretty good. But, thats not what this movie is about.

Its about the symbolism of a desperate mission which only a Japanese navy would have taken, its about remembering history, and its about transferring it to a modern setting of hope prevailing in a time of despair. Enjoy the CGI, enjoy the space battles, don't worry about the inconsistencies with weapons and apparent inept "Gamillas" forces towards the end (maybe new recruits?),and instead enjoy the heroes and unmistakable, "fight to the last man" mentality and Japanese spirit which comes through in every scene.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Can we leave Star Trek and Star Wars out of this...?
empty-bin3 July 2011
While I'll grant you similarity in the setting of a space cruiser named after a famed WWII ship in space (USS Enterprise was a famous WWII air craft carrier, senkan Yamato was a famous WWII battleship), beyond that, nothing about Yamato has anything to do with Star Trek other than Matsumoto Reiji may have been inspired by it.

That said, no further invocation of American media landmarks is necessary in discussing this title.

The film was entertaining. I didn't look at the clock until the end. At times, the film was a bit melodramatic but all-in-all the movie was good.

The special effects were very good. I've heard it said this was a low budget film. I can accept that assessment. But the story telling was decent and conveyed the starry-eyed intensity of the comic nicely!

There were some downs but the only one I'd bother with was the romance between the main character and the ace pilot. It hit me like a pizza delivery scooter from outside my peripheral vision. Never saw it coming and didn't quite understand it.

In the end, I enjoyed it and I'd recommend people familiar with the comic/anime series check it out.
34 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Space Battleship Kimura Takuya
domidoya5 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This movie was supposed to be some kind of "revolution" in the Japanese movie market: great actors, great story (based upon an icon of animation from the 70-80ies), great CGI...BUT only CGI should be considered good. The acting is too mediocre especially Kimura Takuya whose presence is in 95% of the footage. There is absolutely no believable romance between the main characters, the last 20 minutes are dull, amateurish in both script and acting. The only good part is the CGI but you will see it only in 5% of the movie as i said before the other 95% is occupied by Kimura Takuyas face...

To recap in short:

The Good: CGI,the fact that its based on a successful anime series.

The Bad: acting, story, the last 20 minutes, lack of battle scenes involving the Yamato, dumb and very stupid aliens.
23 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Toho's new masterpiece
ebiros220 July 2011
This latest production of Reiji Matsumoto's classic series deserves high ratings for its production value especially considering its low budget of 12 million USD, which is less than a fifth of average Hollywood motion pictures.

In the year 2199 earth is under attack by planet Gamiras and is hopelessly contaminated by radiation. One day they receive a transmission from planet Iskandar with a plan for warp engine and a wave cannon. In their last hope, people of Japan uses this information to transform battleship Yamato - a world war II relic that is now exposed out of a dried up sea bed into a spaceship. They set out to Iskandar which exists in the great Magellan nebula in hopes of finding an answer to earth's problem.

I see touch of Babylon 5 and Battlestar Galactica in the overall looks and feel of the props, ships and the battle sequences, but it's certainly the very best special effects science fiction I've ever seen to come out of Japan. I'd say that Japanese sci-fi have finally come of age in this movie.

The final sequence of this movie is very Japanese in my opinion, and might be over melodramatic for the international audience, but the movie was made for the Japanese viewers, so I don't have any problems there.

Takuya Kimura has a habit of stretching out the ending of a word when calling out orders, and speaking dramatically which sounded odd at times, and the dead pan acting of Meisa Kuroki could have been more charming, but overall things were believable and didn't mess up the story.

Beautifully done movie with real feeling of being out there in space, with unbelievable special effects considering its budget. This is certainly the best sci-fi movie to come out of Japan, and is Toho's new masterpiece.
40 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
We all know how its going to end.....
mmushrm21 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
The live action version of Space Cruiser Yamato. It is quite faithful to the Yamato story lines, hence my summary above.... (for those of you not familiar with the Yamato animes, they all end the same way).

I am caught between disappointment and being satisfied with this movie so I will break it down into pros and cons.

Pro - Great CGI work especially the space action sequence. Pro - It adheres to the Yamato story lines. Pro - Quite abit of action.

Con - unfortunately the CGI accounts for very little of the movie, less then 10% IMO. Most of the movie is filmed in badly and cheaply made sets. It goes from the beauty of the CGI to bad B movie sets. Con - The acting in this movie is WOODEN. The anime characters are able to portray better feelings and emotions!! The lead actors acting abilities are almost non existent.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Wrong gender.... This is a PARODY!
victorsalisgrave16 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
THE GOOD (And the reason it gets this vote): good CGI. The Yamato crew has the right looks, those who watched Japanese movies surely recognized many faces. The uniforms are cool. A couple of nice scenes.

THE BAD: I watched the whole production, serial and movies, and I can say that they took the WORST of the first two seasons and mashed it up in an incomprehensible garbage. The acting is totally lame, considering the actors: I've seen more emotions conveyed by Michael bay's TRANSFORMERS 3 (need to say more?!). The battle scenes are unbelievable: the Cosmo Tigers had to fight for dear life, and those were great-looking battles, while here a couple of fighters can take down a whole Gamilas fleet?!? Where were those pilots during the war for Earth????? The voyage to Iskandar took the better half of one year, here it looks like it took barely a week. What made the first season so emotional was the sense of this countdown to doomsday. 'Hurry up, Yamato, it's only 265 days before the Earth is doomed!' Abraham's Enterprise had it harder, guys! Though of course the astronomy has evolved since 1974, and Pluto couldn't be considered a full-sized planet as depicted 40 years ago, the lack of the battle to end the Gamilas base in the solar system dulls up the movie. I like the idea of Yuki being a more hard-ass babe, it's more modern, but seriously! The gal in this movie is cardboard-cut! her so-called 'love story' with Godai/Wildstar is something made for the sake of it, it has no premises and no development at all. The budget was poor and it shows: is that a battleship or a cramped submarine? Not to mention that they used THE SAME SET for Okita's first ship of earth defense and the Yamato's command bridge. Sheesh!

THE UGLY: Nothing could have been more spectacular than showing the binary system of Gamilas and Iskandar. Take that away and you rape half of the original script. there is no Starsha: She's the beautiful queen of Iskandar who gives the Earthmen the Cosmo DNA to clean Earth...and only NOW, at the end of the movie, we discover the cleaner is a sort of superpower hidden inside Godai?!?!? Why do all this voyage then?? Oh, yes, to die en masse like on the finale of season II, and in even a more ridiculous way. and finally (because I got not enough room to list the horror in its fullest details), The Gamilas... ARE. YOU. SERIOUSLY. KIDDING?!?!?!? Dessler was the archetype of the 'honorable enemy', witty, cruel, but capable of complimenting its adversaries, stubborn but never crazy, loyal to an ideal. A tragic figure that fought a war to find a new home, a creature like us (despite the blue skin), forced to fight for survival...and there is NOTHING of that in this pale excuse of a movie! Heck, even Prince Zodar was an interesting character in season II, while we have a 'Dessler' who is a funny-looking, dull hologram, and the gamilas as faceless 'Aliens' drones.

yes, total destruction of the ship at the end was the best solution, and the song that came with the credits will make us remember NEVER to go beyond renting this horror. Long live Yamato (the anime!)
17 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A fairly good adaptation of a classic cartoon
q_leo_rahman2 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
In the 1970s Leiji Matsumoto created a sci-fi manga-anime called SPACE BATTLESHIP YAMATO, which told the adventures of an Earth spacecraft sent on a quest through space to save its world. The saga became a great hit in Japan, ushered in the space opera genre of anime, and became one of the first animes to be seen in the West (under the title of STAR BLAZERS).

This film is a fairly good live-action adaptation of a classic cartoon, which is a genre known for misfires and disappointments. Its strength lies in that the story is presented faithfully enough to the source material (a trip to save the Earth, a young cadet matures into a soldier and hero), but enables some interesting upgrades made that effectively work out (the alcoholic Dr Sado portrayed by an actress, the robot Analyzer given a palmtop mode). It was also a nice touch to feature voice actors from the original cartoon in major roles in the film.

The story sadly also comes up short on a few changes, though. The original work dealt with the alien invaders the Gamilons as a parallel alien race to Earth, with their leader Desslar as an honorable villain who eventually becomes an ally to Earth. The film pushes this aside to make the Gamilons an unstoppable insect swarm; it was probably a necessary move to put the Yamato against incredible odds, but the story is reduced in scope by only focusing one race of warriors and their quest, in comparison to multiple races and their dynamics. Compared to the manga and cartoon adaptations this comes off a little disappointing, but to be fair an independent person who didn't see those works won't really care about that.

The cast perform their roles competently and loyally. The VFX are an interesting mix of practical sets (ship interiors, caverns) and computer-generated imagery (space vistas, starship fights). The music is a wonderful orchestral homage to the original show's stellar tunes.

All in all, it's a great adaptation that pays homage to the cartoon/comic it came from, and by itself is an above-average space adventure tale.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Dull and silly.
watanabe_carcass11 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
First of all pardon my English, not my mother language.

The first thing that comes to my mind after watching this movie is a "Southpark" episode, specifically the one in which S.Spielberg and G.Lucas rape (and I mean literally rape) Indiana Jones.

My feeling about this movie is basically the same, the creative team behind this movie raped a World Icon of Japanese animation.

The characters in this movie have a total lack of empathy, you cannot possible care less about any character, whatever happen to them is of no importance in terms of feeling. Most of the characters are pale and dull, and seems they are speaking the lines without any emotion attached to them, beside being overacted roles which deliver the usual "japanese performance" of looooooooooooooong cheesy lines. (anyone said Eli Wallach in "The Good, the Ugly, the Bad"?.... - If you are going to shoot, shoot, do not speak, just shoot!").

Kimura Takuya delivers "his usual performance", nothing great, but the rest of the crew is plain and even silly, including the venerable Captain Okita. The movie relies heavily on the "mental image" created by the audience based on the original anime characters and do not make any effort on creating new psychological features that could give emotional deep to the characters, they are just soulless caskets.

The plot is basically the same as the original anime version, but focuses completely on accomplishing a mission rather than on "the journey". They go to Iskandar by crossing the galaxy, jumping a couple of times to warp speed and fighting the Gamilus's forces, but that's it, plain and simple. There is no "Odyssey" attached to it, there is no "costly enterprise" full of sacrifices and self-immolation that built characters and join the crew as "band of brothers".

The director made a terrible job in terms of "time management".The trip seems to have taken no more than 2 days, instead of the original 1 year, there is no pace, no tension after one could say "Oh, my God the clock is ticking, the earth is gonna die, c'mon Yamato!". In addition, the design does not present anything relevant or vaguely original, everything seems plastic and fake, people do not sweat, bleed, or cry, and to make things worst..."insectoid aliens", for god sake!

The original Anime series delivered a compelling "conflict" by making the aliens a Humanoid race whose planet is dying and need to colonize other planet. In this movie the Aliens are the insectoid kind who are "super dupper evil", that's it, bad for the sake of being bad.

And the ending... the ending...c'mon! Where did that children come from?, Maybe I'm missing something but, Do I have to assume he is the fruit of a "5 minutes relationship"?",Do I have to assume that Love is just 2 persons Kissing each other? Even Padme-Anakin's relationship is more credible!

I could spent hundreds of line complaining about how the creative team behind this movie raped the original series and gave us, the loyal fans to the Yamato Universe, the biggest disappointment since Dragon Ball Evolution. What's next, somebody is going to take a cr#p on Macross?
21 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A visual and nostalgic treat!
viligeidiot7 July 2011
I watched and loved the anime 'Starblazers' as a kid and now 30+ years on I find out they've made a live action version of the series that I knew absolutely nothing about! Well, I just HAD to watch it, not expecting anything great.... putting my hopes as high as a SciFy movie of the week or a campy Godzilla movie.

Boy was I surprised! The movie does leap right into things without the background development of the main 'spaceship' or real character introductions, but to enjoy the movie, especially if you have any familiarity with the source cartoon, it really didn't hinder it that much. When the 'Yamamoto' took off and the special effects were introduced, I almost crapped my pants! It looked FANTASTIC!! Exactly like my 9 year old mind pictured as if it were brought to life!

This movie is FAR from Shakespeare, but for an action space romp, popcorn munching entertainment vehicle... it sure impressed me silly... especially compared to the dreck coming out of Hollywood these days.

If you have fond memories of 'Starblazers', this is a MUST SEE... even if you never saw the cartoon, I'd highly recommend this as a decent time waster.... you could do far worse!
46 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Pretty Good Science-Fiction Film
Uriah438 August 2013
An alien race known as the Gamilas has launched a nuclear attack upon earth and after five years of increased radiation the human race has been forced to go underground in order to survive. Realizing that their spaceships are no match against the Gamilas, the Japanese send their new battleship (the Yamato) off on a desperate mission to the planet Islandar to find an anti-radiation device to save the earth. Now, from what I understand this film was based upon a popular anime series and as a result there was quite a bit of storyline to pull from. Because of this massive quantity of information, the film was hard-pressed to cover all of the details necessary and character development was especially limited. This was made even more difficult due to the large amount of combat scenes. On the other hand, the special effects were quite good and kept the film humming at a fast pace. In short, although it might help to have read the books or viewed the anime films first, it isn't a requirement and as such it's a pretty good science-fiction film in its own right.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Space Battleship Yamato (2010)
jtwcosmos30 June 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is the story of Earth's last hope. It is the year 2200 and humanity has only one champion left: the Yamato.

The space adventure that follows the ship and it's crew across the galaxy is the long awaited live action version of the classic animated series Starblazers. It has great special effects, good - but tiny- sets and young actors. I have no idea what they were saying, because my copy had no subtitles.

The special effects are impressive, both in quantity and quality. The visuals of outer space are mind blowing, even if a little monotonous. There are scenes that rely entirely on CG and they work well. There are also scenes that mix CG and actors and they are also very good.

Talking about the actors, they all look a bit unsure of themselves and not really in character, but I suspect the script didn't give them much to work with. All I could see was a lot of shouting and posturing.

The sets are good and they look right. At first. The problem is that as the movie progresses it becomes painfully clear that they only had a tiny amount of real estate to work with. There simply is no room to do anything. Even though this is a - supposedly - huge space battleship, the overall impression is that of a tiny submarine: crammed and overcrowded. To be clear, this is no Enterprise. And when compared with Battlestar Galactica, the flight deck of that ship looked far more impressive.

The directing is childish and the camera doesn't move very much. It is always front and center and I suspect this has something to do with the tiny sets.

Space Battleship Yamato. Great special effects but... not much else. 5/10.
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Relatively faithful to the original series
darkmax5 April 2011
Well, considering the length of the original series, the movie producers have done well cramming it all into a 2-hour long film.

There are a few flaws in the movie I thought needed a bit more work on.

1. There is little feelings of romance between Kodai Susumu and Mori Yuki. It just felt flat. This, I attributed, to the target audience of the original animated series.

2. The melodrama at the end, on the bridge, was very Japanese..... in the 1970s. It should have been shorter and more modernized. I guess one has to be a die-hard fan not to find that scene particularly long-winded.

3. There wasn't enough battle footage of the Yamato and her enemies. This I was seriously looking forward to, but was left disappointed.

4. I wish Mr Kimura would shed a few tears, that would have made his performance more believable.

That said, there were quite a few good points about the movie, 1. Realistic space-fighter maneuvers. The big turnarounds of spaceships and fighters in American sci-fi is just plain BS. The only other sci-fi that got it right was Babylon 5.

2. Up until the bridge scene right at the very end, I was actually not aware of the time passing.

3. This movie have some of the better Japanese actors in recent years. Overall, their performances are well delivered and their friendships believable.

4. Swearing and vulgarities are non-existent in the entirety of the movie (or none that I am aware of). This is a rarity these days, especially with all the filth coming out of American and European films.

5. The graphics and SFX are quite good. They are quite realistic. I have no problem with much of it except for those SFX sounds the lasers and beams made.... sound very arcade-like and very 70s.

This movie is worth the ticket you paid for.
48 out of 72 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pray for Japan
moviexclusive24 March 2011
There is just something about viewing modern Japanese-made science fiction/fantasy, be it in the forms of comic or TV show or movie that simply takes one back to childhood. If I were to pinpoint a reason, perhaps it is because of the Japanese general reluctance to adapt to a gritty futuristic and high-tech production aesthetic thus only serving to evoke memories of Saturday morning television no matter the age of the viewer. However, this is not to say that the tech-crazy Japanese do not employ modern techniques to the production process. They do, but they also somehow manage to preserve a nostalgic feel to their work.

Speaking for those who grew up in the nineties, even if one has never heard of Space Battleship Yamato before, a recollection of past enjoyment drawn from watching shows like Ultraman, Transformers and the Power Rangers is all is needed to have fun watching the movie.

Based on the widely popular 26-episode anime series of the same name from the 1970s, Space Battleship Yamato has been reproduced into multiple movies from the end of its series right up to the early 2000s. When the latest installment opened in Japan in December 2010, the locals loyally lapped it up, pushing it to overtake the much-anticipated first part of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. If nostalgia has nothing to do with it, which I hardly doubt so, its form probably does. Unlike its animated predecessors, the movie is shot for the first time in live- action. So to Takuya Kimura fans – feel free to rejoice that you will be seeing him in the flesh on screen instead of simply hearing him through an animated character.

Playing the heroic yet reluctant leader who only does things from his own book, it is no wonder why he has been picked to play leading man Susumu Kodai. His trademark charm and internationally-recognizable face are definite pull factors because let's face it, not everyone is drawn to watch movies because of things like plot and filming technicalities. Do watch out for the mess-immune nature of his famous locks. It seems that Gatsby products can really make your 'do stay in place even after long-distance space travel and alien-fighting.

Compelled to partake in a do-or-die mission to save the world from an impending radiological doom and attacks from an alien race known as the Gamilas, Kodai is forced to take over the Yamato – the last functioning battleship on earth, when its Captain turns ill mid-journey.

The space battle scenes and the exterior scenes of the Yamato are definitely something to look forward to in the movie as they are no less superior than the ones we are used to watching in Sci-fi hallmarks like Star Wars and Star Trek. Crazy flight maneuvers and cool gadgetry add on to the excitement of an action-packed movie filled with likable characters and situations that seem impossible to get out of alive. Two hours, however, can get a bit tiring for those who just want to find out the ending.

As we follow through the tale of honour and sacrifice (a lot of dead heroes in this one), one cannot help but notice the poignant irony of the story considering the current situation that is faced by Japan. In fact it gets slightly discomforting knowing that the movie might end well, but reality itself is not as reassuring.

  • www.moviexclusive.com
3 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
If you never heard of Yamato...
yiapap26 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I found it very interesting that all the reviews make references to the original series and/or anime. I for one have never heard of 'Yamato'. I watched this movie because it is Sci-Fi and because I always try to find and watch off-Hollywood movies.

Unfortunately Battleship Yamato was not a very good choice.

People praise the CGI; and they would have been great. In 1990. Perhaps even 2000. Not in 2010, come on fellow reviewers! The battle scenes are OK but... quite unbelievable. A squadron of fighters destroy opponents stronger than them in... orders of magnitude! They defy the laws of physics not just in the ever present "space sounds" (lasers, explosions etc.) but also in the little matter of inertia. The space fighters love to stop and make 179 degrees turns in ways that would make any human passenger a blob of... you know what. And this is the favourite tactic of our Black Tiger squadron, the one that always succeeds. Of course the enemy can accomplish no such feat and is therefore laser fodder.

Talking about the enemy... This must be one of the worst caricatures of aliens in SciFi movies. They are close to giant mutant spiders and flesh eating clouds. Their tactical choices ridiculous. Their range in skill spectacular. One of them can kill several elite troopers inside their own spaceship while avoid the bullets from dozens of their colleagues, while a little later gazillions of them die storming a vehicle and a silly-voiced robot. Oh and in case you are wondering, this is an individual yet collective mind race. Both, yes!

All of the above were the best parts of the movie. The worst parts include cheesy dialogue, undeveloped (not underdeveloped) characters for whom you have no sympathy or attachment, bad to hideous acting, boring camera work, a photography that has too few well placed frames and A LOT of awful ones, all the clichés in SciFi and War/Action filmography and (I left the worst for last) a love story that makes you yearn for an Adam Sandler movie. Preferably with Paris Hilton as the object of his undying love!

So why the three points? After reading the other reviews and doing some homework all three points are given out of respect for the original Yamato story and for the original productions. 0/10 for this one.
12 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent stuff
zorp90920 May 2012
OK so why Japanese movies don't have higher budgets? These types of movies deserve much more money. What they can do with 20x time less than US movies is amazing.

Excellent work, excellent movie, please film more of such Sci-Fi movies, this is great. More more more ! I just can't believe that we could get for instance 16 movies of such quality e.g. 12 milion per movie = $200 million, and one US movie costs $200 million(Transformers). I could watch 10 movies instead of 1, that would be superb ! Blu-ray's here I come :-)

I mean Transformers for example are ALL about mambo-jumbo folks, some teen "superstars" and we have a movie - WRONG ! Quality movie doesn't requires superstars, it requires good story, great directing and great production. 'Yamato' movie showed us that.

Now about the movie, effects, robotics etc only Japanese can do that, nice stuff guys. Love the sound, and sound effects.

Enjoy watching this !
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Fun and creative, good CGI. Recommended to SF fans.
thimage7 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
There may be spoilers in the following review, although no part of the story is mentioned at any time. There's a lot to like about Space Battleship Yamato. The concept flies light years ahead of Hollywood's sclerotic and rewarmed releases. When you see that Japan's film makers dare to go beyond crowd-pleaser productions, you have to rejoice and recognize that all is not lost for science fiction. The budget is obviously smaller than an average US movie, but most CG space actions are nevertheless very good (Not comparing to spectacular productions like Avatar, of course). And the battleship itself is an icon that's worthy of placing as a wallpaper on your laptop. Its space version is beautifully anachronistic, mixing high-tech capabilities with mechanical WWII menacing lines. As in all Japanese movies, I wish there was more of an international mix in terms of actors, as well as seeing the participation of more nations for the storyline (this shows a serious lack of global aperture from the authors. As a matter of fact, no other nation or population is ever mentioned during the movie) and the acting is, in many cases way overdone. The story is a little naive and can get a little long winded, especially at the end. The last point I'd like to address is about discipline on a battleship. It's clear that the authors have no idea of proper military behavior, how to man stations, how to pass information up and down the chain of command or acknowledging orders. So my advice would be for a next release to look for consultants in as many aspects of the movie as possible. Many spectators want now more realistic themes, solid background, technological realism, and good special effects on top of good acting. These points are the reasons why I gave it a 6 out of 10. If these last issues had been met, I'd have given it a 9 without a doubt. Now if you're ready to forgive them, you'll have a lot of fun. TM
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Disappointed By The Changes
jagooch7 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
**** Contains Spoilers ****** Disclaimer: I am not fluent in Japanese

First, some background. I watched all of the episodes of the US of "Star Blazers" when back in elementary school. When I heard from a friend that it was being released as a movie in Japan( where I currently live ) , I just had to go see it. So much so, that I rewatched the TV series, and did some research about it on the Web. Some interesting facts:

The Argo in the US release was originally called the "Yamato"

The Yamato's namesake was a WW2 Destroyer.

The Yamato was built right where I work at today!

There is a museum near Hiroshima dedicated to the ship

Now for the movie. I watched this last week in Yokosuka, JP. Despite being in Japanese, I felt confident I would be able to follow the storyline even if they changed it to adapt it for cinema. OK, I go into the late showing and it's the theater is practically empty. Not a good sign of the 3 day after the release. The beginning was promising, but slowly it became obvious that they made some major revisions to the story. That in itself isn't bad or unexpected, but they removed several key elements, or neutered them. They had a huge palette of source material, and made a film that felt half-full.

Let me explain. First, the good: *Wildstar was still pretty crazy shoot-em up kind of guy. *The Wave motion gun still owns. *Nova( Yuki ) was still hot. Plus, now she punches people and flies a fighter ships! Special Effects/CGI were well done.

The Bad: * Starsha? Where are you? Your sister is also missing. Thanks for still managing to get the Wave motion gun blueprints to us without appearing in the film. * Dessloc is no longer the witty arch-enemy, he's some weird crystalline hologram. * Gamelons look like the flying lizards from Pitch Black. * 5 fighter ships can take on the entire Gamelon fleet * The radiation purifier is inside of Wildstar. Weirdness. * Everyone gets drunk for no reason. * The music...you have got to be kidding me * Long scenes of a character staring into space for some unknown reason. * The spaceship only has 12 people on it, apparently. I would have been an extra...for free! * The ending...I won't spoil that for you. It's a major disappointment. * Don't pick up random ships and let them inside of yours...it could be a trap. Or a bomb.

There is no reason it had to be this lame. I'm still glad I went to see it as it was my first Japanese movie in a Japanese theater. The experience was good, but the film was lacking.

My recommendation is to wait for it on DVD/Netflix, unless you want to donate money to the film in hopes they make a worthy sequel.
11 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Why are they all so long?
ericstevenson28 March 2018
What's up with all these long movies I've been watching lately? I'd think they'd be more enjoyable if they just didn't go on forever! Anyway, this is a live-action movie based on an anime cartoon. I guess it's still lightyears ahead of "Dragonball: Evolution", but it's still not quite good. The worst thing is probably the CGI with the aliens. I guess they at least aren't on screen that much. I know practically nothing about the franchise.

I can't tell if this is faithful to it or not. It seems to be at least okay. I must say that I was impressed by the romance in this movie. I really wasn't expecting that. The acting is, for the most part, pretty good. It's just nothing unique enough to recommend. **1/2
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Stay away from this if you have any sense of sophisticated entertainment
Macsoni11 July 2014
It is an absolute mystery to me how this movie could get a 6 Star rating, my faith in IMDb ratings dropped once more.

All conversations in this movie are so incredibly cheesy, dull and shallow that there probably grew tumors in my brain because it was so unbearable.

Even Twilight is 2 times more worth seeing than this and that's no overstatement at all + I'm saying that as a die-hard SciFi fan.

3 stars for the main plot and 4 stars for the animations but not a single star for the dialoge and acting gives well-meant 2 stars for this.

If you like wasting your time with moronic nonsense, this is probably one of the best movies you can go for.
7 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Finally, a true "Space Battleship" movie... (i.e. more RTS than FPS)
dont_b_so_BBC29 March 2011
... should have been made by the people who made this "live-action" Space Battleship Yamato (2010) movie-- which is based on the Classic (first major "space opera"-- after Star Trek, before Star Wars) animated TV series of the same name , and much closer in style and content to Star Trek The Original TV Series... since it doesn't devolve into the teen-angst or "slo-mo" action of recent Hollywood blockbusters.

The source material is given many judicious "updates" which largely made sense to me from a story, if not production, stand-point: e.g. the talking robot "Analyzer" is now a "SIM" module which you can load into other devices and the aliens are now truly "alien" with technology and energy signatures which humans have difficulty detecting or understanding.... And the writing is smart enough to make light of the "old-schooled" stuff they keep-- like their costumes ("we're still wearing this?") and one-liners. In fact, there is so little "fan-service" or "sequel baiting" that non-fans probably won't realize that this is an adaptation of a 1970s TV animation series (using the ORIGINAL music)!

P.S. To anyone who thinks that the characters' reactions to the movie's apocalyptic story is unrealistic (taking time to make decisions, say farewells, mourn/salute the dead)-- just look at how real Japanese people deal with their earthquakes and tsunamis.

Owing to the fact that the Japanese "general movie audience" is not that much larger than the Japanese anime/manga audience, there is no faux issue of "re-imagining" the source material for a "new/larger" audience-- and the writers rise to the monumental task of "condensing" many epic, if episodic, story-arcs (which should have taken a trilogy, if not a series of 7/8 movies) into a single feature film... by focusing on the STORY! In fact, this movie is so tightly structured that the only really unexplained or implausible thing in it is probably all of the actors' great hair... and the secret lies in using sci-fi movie tropes (most of it actually originating from their source material), NOT explaining them-- since no amount of techno-babble will turn a plot device into reality.

Which is where, I believe, this movie will divide audiences into fans and non-fans of the source material (or sci-fi/anime in general)-- a downside of all this emphasis on story is, of course, a relative lack of characterization.... Though thankfully, anime stereotypes have at least one more dimension than their Hollywood counterparts and the casting is mostly SPOT-ON (you who believe skinny anime characters with fluffy hair do not exist in Japan, repent!) And some inevitably heavy narration and exposition which might have been risible were thankfully short, focused and well-delivered-- with a touch of self-awareness (*eye-rolling*) by the characters themselves. And as expected, veteran actors deliver their lines and inhabit their characters without batting an eyelid, while younger cast members are less convincing with their histrionics.

So while this might seem like a pretty generic space adventure to "general audiences"; it is and has always been intended as a treat for the fans. And this movie won me over for the simple fact that, after decades of Star Wars and Star Trek, it could still make me go "WOW..." every time an alien or a space-ship appeared, for all of 3/4 of a second-- because it's not what you have, it's how you use it!

For this is low-budget movie-making by Hollywood standards, so there is absolutely no "pimping" of expensive special effects-- which means that the only time you get to see the aliens/space-ships is when they are actually doing something ESSENTIAL to the plot. And sci-fi fans might also note that they got the relative speeds of capital-ships (bigger = slower) vs fighter-ships, missile-fire, warp-effects (almost instantaneous by comparison) RIGHT-- so there is no such rubbish as waiting for "visual confirmation" (which is meaningless in the vastness of space) or capital-ships "dodging" long-range fire (which would hit almost as soon as they are "detected").

All this means going back to the "bridge battles" of submarine/battleship warfare (this Yamato looks/works more like a submarine with a skeletal crew, than some cruise-boat or flying-city) which rely more on having good scripts/actors than special effects-- and people who don't think this can't be nerve-wrecking should see how they "set-up" the Yamato's SPLIT-SECOND "warp-maneouvers"!

The budgetary limits really start showing up near the end of the movie-- but if the money is lacking, the heart is not: the relatively simple yet distinct special effects design (transforming "2-stage" fighter-ships!) is always a pleasure to behold, even when very tight (or wide) shots are used in order to avoid rendering very expensive details. It may be just a few frames of CGI, but the "impact" will leave you re-playing it in your mind...

The real only disappointment for me, if any, would be how the human and environmental issues (Living with irradiated earth? Leaders making up "white lies"?) ever-present in the best of Japanese anime is left in the background-- as both the challenges and solutions presented in the story are essentially alien-related. I mean, I'm ashamed to admit to one of the more touching moments for me was when "Analyzer" finally took on its robot-form (hey, it had more lines than the "red shirts")....
26 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A cut down version of a classic TV series
The-Sarkologist6 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I remember as a child I used to sit down at 5:00 pm every week day and watch Star Blazers. I absolutely loved that series, both the original and the second season where they were up against the Comet Empire. In a way I would love to be able to watch them all over again so many years after watching them, however it just seems to be impossible to find a video store that actually has them on the shelves, and since I really only want to watch them once, I don't want to fork out over $100.00 to purchase the DVDs.

Anyway, the story goes that Earth has been attacked by an alien race that is bombarding the planet with meteors and the Earth is on the brink of extinction. However, at the last moment, they receive a message from a distant planet that contains the schematics for a wave motion device that will allow them to travel to that planet to retrieve a device that will rejuvenate the Earth, so the people of Earth take an abandoned battle ship, the Yamato, turn it into a space ship, and put the wave motion engine into it and set off on a journey to attempt to save the Earth.

This movie is basically a cut down live action version of the cartoon series. Personally I must say that I actually preferred the cartoon series over this movie because, simply, the length of the series enabled me to become so much more attached to the characters. I would rather spend the time sitting down and watch the episodes over a long period of time than to watch this cut down version of the series. Further, a number of things had changed from the original movie, in particular the fact that the Gamelons had become some sort of energy creature that used humanoid shells to move around.

I guess that a lot is lost when one attempts to take a series and truncate it into a movie, in the same what that a book is generally truncated into a movie as well. There is a difference in that a movie is much more restricted than a book, while a book tends not to be anywhere as visual as a movie. At least with a movie you are able to actually see the events rather than attempt to conjure them up in your mind, which is not necessarily a bad thing. In some cases, such as Game of Thrones for instance, I am happy that they are making a television series so I don't have to read the books (at least just yet).

Anyway, there are still a number of memorable things about this movie, such as the captain who I remember as seeming to always be sitting in this box in the bridge from which he never moved, except for when he became sick. However, too much was simply cut out (which is not surprising), and the pretty much killed off most of the major characters by the end of the movie. What the series enabled us to do was to grow attached to the major characters so that when they died there was much more of an impact, however the shortened version simply did not enable us to develop such an attraction. However, as mentioned, since it can be difficult to find the series, this movie is probably the second best thing. However, after watching the movie I simply want to get my hands on the series again.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
unrealistic behaviour
imdb-296519 May 2017
I absolutely get that this is an adaption of an old anime series, and thus you can't just go and change everything.

May contain spoilers, because of nuts.

I can also cope with unrealistic technology, spaceships doing battle over only several hundred meters distance but travelling 158000 light years, spacecraft braking and turning with what must be 1000ands of Gs. Of course nobody is wearing spacesuits during battle or even sits down in crash couches, instead they run around and need to put on glasses when the main gun fires.

What I really hate is when, for no reason at all, some guy that clearly can't delegate, constantly abandons his post to play firefighter, apparently is happier in the cockpit of a fighter craft, micromanages, and never even read the manual gets promoted "acting captain" of a battleship. Starting an affair with a subordinate while the ship is doing a hyper-jump doesn't help..

Speaking of Jumps, why aren't they going to battle-stations before they jump when they know there can be surprises at the other end? So, after being acting captain for bit, the acting captain leaves ship for leading some fighter attack. After which he lands to shoot a bit with assault guns and has to be persuaded to go back to his ship.

To sum up the whole movie: Highly illogical.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Nutshell Review: Space Battleship Yamato
DICK STEEL16 March 2011
While it is its own film with material drawn from its rich source content (the film is mostly based on its 1974 series), one cannot help but to see shades of JJ Abram's reboot of the Star Trek film franchise here. Granted there are many parallels between Star Trek and Yamato, for starters the legendary space ships are named after their equally legendary real world counterparts, and are the best of their fleet and make in the reel world (though one comes with seat belts that got seldom used), manned by the best crew that an ideology can supply, which the story takes some pains to introduce at least their core duties on board. It's also the story of the coming of age of a young captain, where in this case Takuya Kimura's Susumu Kodai is the equivalent of James Tiberius Kirk, possessing qualities befitting a captain that he needs to realize and grow into, with that level of hot headedness and past famed exploits to allow him some gravitas and stature amongst peers and crew members.

Then of course this film went for broke in its action sequences, beginning much like Star Trek putting the audience right into the thick of a big set action piece which culminates in a loss that will shape the events of things to come, and seriously, the way the space voyagers attempted to disable an enemy planet's defenses, was uncannily similar to the Star Trek one in its approach. I suppose if Yamato had beaming technology, then this would complete its Trekkie influence, but thankfully it held back on that temptation, making it a little more challenging each time it had to reign in crew outside of its hull.

Fans of the long running series will have to accept the fact that this is not something from our generation, since a translation to film means a huge amount of compression having to take place to tell something worthwhile, creating in a sense its own version of events. It's Year 2199, and Earth is plague by radioactive attacks by the alien race Gamilas, who are adamant in creating an atmosphere suitable for their race for a total takeover. Gone are Earth's greens, and it's up to the crew of Yamato, hastily assembled may I add, to travel to the planet of Iscandar to retrieve what could possibly be Earth's last hope to restore its environment. This sets off a round trip for Yamato's voyage, and along the way the crew will face various hostilities always threatening the ship or to extinguish the hopes of Earth.

The special effects are all detailed and intricately done, so much so that they really look like something to scale and real, making space dogfights in the various Star Wars films seem like a walk in the park. It's incredibly edge of your seat stuff as ships of different sizes battling it out, and if watched in a good theatre with excellent sound system, you can bet your last dollar of feeling every laser, cannon and even the trademark of the Wave Motion Gun round that goes off. Best part is, and I think some films and filmmakers need to learn from this, is that it's never shy of utilizing its best weapon in its arsenal whenever it can, avoiding plenty of the usual cliché pitfalls of saving the best for the last. Really, whatever for, when you have a threat in front of you that you need to neutralize, why not deploy the best you have on board?

Don't expect too much character development here though, because there isn't much time to jam pack so much into what's already close to 2 hours and 20 minutes. As such the first act suffered a little from the lack of a proper introduction on characters and their motivations, preferring to keep you in suspense as it slowly unravelled them, sometimes just through a one liner in passing. You'll soon acquaint yourself with the crew enough to know their core function, and most of them time everyone sticks to their one single function on board the ship. The end result is a rather choppy beginning just as Yamato finds its feet in its maiden voyage, before things smoothen out as the voyage progressed. With a new crew in a new ship also come the avenues for mistakes to be made, and one of the more telling one is how everyone let their guard down en route to base (common pitfall in the military), where one's guard should be up until you actually reach paradise.

The other issue I found wanting in a minor way, though it still worked, was Takuya Kimura's presence. He's such a big star, and is really charismatic on screen that my memory of the Kodai character pales in comparison, but like how Tom Cruise's Mission: Impossible was, my memory of Yamato was that this was a group attempt and mission, which Kimura's star power inevitably made him prominent in every step of the way through the story as if it's solely a one man show, often overshadowing that of his co-stars such as Meisa Kuroki (who is a big name herself), Toshiro Yanagiba and Tsutomu Yamazaki, who plays the ship's Captain Okita, responsible for crafting the mission of hope that Yamato finds itself in. Throwing in a romantic subplot for good measure that was expected though hurried, and side characters such as Analyzer the robot was fun, but could have been better executed rather than a short supporting appearance.

Still, Space Battleship Yamato is one nostalgic guilty pleasure. It helps if you have a little bit of a background on characters and motivations, as the story hits the ground running at breakneck speed from the get go, and is a special effects romp that will wow even the most jaded of audiences who have seen one space battle too many.
22 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Nothing like the original series.
sakurakitsune12 July 2015
I wanted to like this movie... I really did. It had everything down right. The SFX, The actors, the over the top acting, the beautiful ship sets. It had so much going for it... Then you get the actual story....

The story is not bad per say... It's just not interesting. It's meant to encompass and cover 26 episodes (of the 1974 first season of the SBY series, I know because I'm a fan of it.) in a 2 hour time frame, which anyone knows is a pain and a real struggle to make a good movie from.

The film however tries to throw everything in along with the kitchen sink. And 2 hours is not enough time to cover the story from earth to Iskandar and back to Earth, and try to cover other minor character sub plots.

This is what hurts the film. Because they are trying to cram in as many characters and sub plots from the anime as we can. And it takes away from the film making it drag and be sorta boring. I do understand and realize that Space Battleship Yamato was a character driven series. and you had more moments on the bridge rather than in battles at times. But in 2 hours you can't really have everything from the series.

If the film had been cut down to a sorta trinity... Susumu Kodai, Okiti, and Yuki Mori, And focused on the 3 of them and the trip to Iscandar and back to earth, I think the film would have been tighter and pulled together better.

Because the way the film goes right now... It should have been broken up into either a trilogy or a quadriology. So you could tell more story and focus on more of the characters from the series.

As a Space Battleship Yamato fan... I couldn't recommend this to fans or people wanting just a fun film to watch. Look into the original series or even the remake "Space Battleship Yamato 2199. You'll enjoy those more than this.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Useless condensing of the original series that inspired BSG
freydis-e28 December 2022
A couple of minutes in, the irritating and unfeasibly cute male lead tries to attack the venerable white-bearded ship's captain, only to be (literally) decked by a random unfeasibly cute yellow-clad woman. No-one will be surprised to hear that these two cuties will pretty soon be romantically involved - nor by anything else about this cliché-ridden nonsense.

A reviewer compared this with the latest Startrek films but it's more obviously related to Battlestar Galactica with humankind threatened by powerful aliens and everything depending on a single battle star/ship. In this film the eponymous craft may be absurdly based on a WW2 battleship, but it's crewed by the same stock collection of hotshot pilots, sober officers, yawn, yawn. In fact the original anime series of SBY inspired BSG in the first place and the main problem here, I suspect, is that any quirkiness or originality which might have existed in that 26-episode series has been lost in condensing the story to a 2-hr movie.

Leaving what? I'm not entirely sure but the first hour of dull cliché, ordinary script and acting and lack of any kind of interest was enough and I couldn't see a reason to watch on. Fairly sure there is none.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed